Federal Court of Australia

Evans and Partners Pty Ltd v E&P Securities Pty Limited, in the matter of Evans and Partners Pty Ltd [2026] FCA 1785

File number(s):

VID 1290 of 2026

Judgment of:

O'CALLAGHAN J

Date of judgment:

20 November 2026

Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – members’ scheme of arrangement –

first court hearing – application under ss 411 and 1319 of

the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for orders convening a meeting of members to consider and, if thought fit, to agree a proposed scheme of arrangement to implement corporate restructuring – whether requirements to order scheme meeting are satisfied – application allowed

Legislation:

Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act 2006 (Cth)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 411, 413, 1319

Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) rr 3.2, 3.4

Cases cited:

Millennium CHPP Pty Ltd v Millennium Coal Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 1556

Re Absolute Equity Performance Fund Ltd [2022] FCA 933

Re AGL Sydney Ltd (1994) 13 ACSR 597

Re Chevron (TAPL) Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 220

Re CSR Ltd (2010) 183 FCR 358

Re Hastings Deering Pty Ltd (1985) 3 ACLC 474

Re Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd [2026] NSWSC 1010

Re Queensland Teachers’ Union Health Fund Limited [2025] FCA 481

Re Signature Gold Ltd [2017] FCA 1481

Re Woolworths Group Limited [2019] FCA 1810

SGIC Insurance Ltd v Insurance Australia Ltd [2004] FCA 1492

Division:

General Division

Registry:

Victoria

National Practice Area:

Commercial and Corporations

Sub-area:

Corporations and Corporate Insolvency

Number of paragraphs:

51

Date of hearing:

12 November 2026

Counsel for the First and Second Plaintiffs:

Mr G J Ahern

Solicitors for the First and Second Plaintiffs:

MinterEllison

ORDERS

VID 1290 of 2026

IN THE MATTER OF EVANS AND PARTNERS PTY LTD ACN 125 338 785

BETWEEN:

EVANS AND PARTNERS PTY LTD ACN 125 338 785

First Plaintiff

E&P OPERATIONS PTY LTD ACN 080 207 076

Second Plaintiff

AND:

E&P SECURITIES PTY LTD ACN 691 995 669

First Defendant

E&P CAPITAL HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 650 900 815

Second Defendant

order made by:

O'CALLAGHAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

12 NOVEMBER 2026

OTHER MATTERS

A.    The court notes that the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC)

was provided with at least 14 days’ notice of the hearing of this application.

B.    The court is satisfied that ASIC has had a reasonable opportunity to:

(a)     examine the terms of the proposed scheme of arrangements to which the application relates and a draft explanatory statement relating to that arrangement; and

(b)     make submissions to the court in relation to the proposed scheme of

arrangements and the draft explanatory statement.

C.    The court notes the letter from ASIC to MinterEllison (the plaintiffs’ solicitors) dated 11 November 2026, notifying the plaintiffs that ASIC does not propose to appear to make submissions or intervene to oppose the proposed scheme at the first court hearing under s 411(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.    Pursuant to subsection 411(1), 413 and section 1319 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Act):

(a)    the First Plaintiff, Evans and Partners Pty. Ltd. ACN 125 338 785 (EAP) is to convene and hold a meeting of its sole member, E&P Financial Group Limited ACN 609 913 457 (Scheme Shareholder), to be held at Level 32, 1 O’Connell Street, Sydney NSW 2000 on Wednesday, 18 November 2026 commencing at 10.00am (Sydney time) (EAP Scheme Meeting):

(i)    for the purpose of the Scheme Shareholder considering and, if thought fit, agreeing (with or without modification) to the proposed scheme of arrangement between EAP and the Scheme Shareholder (EAP Scheme), being the scheme of arrangement in the form set out in Annexure A to the explanatory statement in Annexure BFO-6 of the second affidavit of Bernard Frederic Oude-Vrielink sworn on 11 November 2026 (Second Oude-Vrielink Affidavit); and

(ii)    the chairperson will be Francis Noel Araullo or, failing him, Marc Falkiner.

(b)    the Second Plaintiff, E&P Operations Pty Limited ACN 080 207 076 (E&P Ops and, together with EAP, the Scheme Companies), convene a meeting of its sole member, the Scheme Shareholder, to be held at the same place and on the same day as the EAP Scheme Meeting, commencing immediately after the conclusion of the EAP Scheme Meeting (E&P Ops Scheme Meeting and, together with the EAP Scheme Meeting, the Scheme Meetings):

(i)    for the purpose of the Scheme Shareholder considering and, if thought fit, agreeing (with or without modification) to the proposed scheme of arrangement between E&P Ops and the Scheme Shareholder (E&P Ops Scheme and, together with the EAP Scheme, the Schemes) being the scheme of arrangement in the form set out in Annexure B to the explanatory statement in Annexure BFO-6 of the Second Oude-Vrielink Affidavit; and

(ii)    the chairperson will be Francis Noel Araullo or, failing him, Robert Darwell.

2.    The Scheme Meetings are to be convened by the Plaintiffs distributing the following documents to the Scheme Shareholder, with distribution to occur in accordance with paragraph 3 below:

(a)    the explanatory statement required by s 412(1)(a) of the Act, substantially in the form set out in Annexure BFO-06 to the Second Oude-Vrielink Affidavit (Explanatory Statement) which contains, among other things, the notice of Scheme Meetings at Annexure C to the Explanatory Statement; and

(b)    the proxy forms (substantially in the form at Annexure FNA-14 to the affidavit of Francis Noel Araullo) (Proxy Forms).

3.    Pursuant to s 1319 of the Act:

(a)    each Scheme Company dispatch to the Scheme Shareholder a copy of the Explanatory Statement and the proxy form for the relevant Scheme Meeting, by 5.00pm (Melbourne time) on Friday, 13 November 2026, by email or hand delivery to a director or company secretary of the Scheme Shareholder; and

(b)    dispatch of those documents in accordance with this order is sufficient notice of each Scheme Meeting.

4.    Subject to these orders, the Scheme Meetings is to be convened, held and conducted in accordance with the provisions of:

(a)    Part 2G.2 of the Act (except for any applicable replaceable rule) that apply to meetings of members of a company; and

(b)    the provisions of the constitution of the relevant Scheme Company that apply to meetings of members and that are not inconsistent with Part 2G.2 of the Act.

5.    The chairperson of the Scheme Meeting has the power to adjourn or postpone the Scheme Meeting in his absolute discretion, for such time and to such place as he considers appropriate (provided that such date is no more than two weeks after the date of the Scheme Meetings set out in paragraph 1(a) above).

6.    The Scheme Shareholder, being a body corporate, may appoint an individual as its representative under s 250D of the Act (Corporate Representative) to exercise the powers it may exercise at the Scheme Meeting.

7.    The proxy forms (substantially in the form at Annexure FNA-14 to the affidavit of Francis Noel Araullo) (Proxy Forms), an appointment of a Corporate Representative, or a power of attorney to act on behalf of the Scheme Shareholder may be delivered to the Chairperson (including by electronic means) at any time before the vote on the resolution to agree to the relevant Scheme is cast.

8.    The presence of the Scheme Shareholder by its proxy, attorney or Corporate Representative constitutes a quorum.

9.    The resolution to agree to the relevant Scheme be decided on a poll.

10.    The Scheme Companies be exempted from compliance with r 2.4(1) of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) (Rules), to the extent that rule requires the affidavit filed with the Originating Process to state the facts in support of the process, and r 2.15 of the Rules in respect of the Scheme Meetings.

11.    On or before Tuesday, 17 November 2026, the Scheme Companies publish once in the national edition of The Australian newspaper a notice of the hearing of the application to approve the Schemes, substantially in the form of Annexure A to these orders, and the Scheme Companies are otherwise exempted from compliance with r 3.4 of, and Form 6 to, the Rules.

12.    An office copy of these orders be lodged with ASIC by 5.00pm (Melbourne time) on Friday, 13 November 2026.

13.    Pursuant to s 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), on the ground in s 37AG(1)(a) that the order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, until further order the Client Transfer Agreement, the Employee Transfer Agreement and the Vendor Transfer Agreement (each as defined in the Explanatory Statement), at Exhibits A, B and C respectively to the affidavit of Francis Noel Araullo sworn 9 November 2026 be marked “confidential” on the Court file and not be published or made available to any person other than the parties and their legal representatives, except pursuant to an order of the Court.

14.    The further hearing of the originating process is adjourned to 10:15am (Melbourne time) on Wednesday, 25 November 2026 or as soon thereafter as the business of the court allows before Justice O’Callaghan.

15.    There be liberty to apply.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


ANNEXURE A

NOTICE FOR PUBLICATION IN THE AUSTRALIAN

NOTICE OF HEARING TO APPROVE COMPROMISE OR ARRANGEMENT

EVANS AND PARTNERS PTY. LTD. ACN 125 338 785 (EAP)

E&P OPERATIONS PTY LIMITED ACN 080 207 076 (E&P Ops)

TO all the creditors and the member of EAP and E&P Ops (together, the Scheme Companies, and each a Scheme Company).

TAKE NOTICE that at 10.15 am (Melbourne time) on [Wednesday, 25 November 2026], the Federal Court of Australia at the Owen Dixon Commonwealth Law Courts Building, 305 William Street, Melbourne VIC 3000 will hear an application by the Scheme Companies seeking the approval of a compromise or arrangement under ss 411 and 413 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Act) between each Scheme Company and its sole member, E&P Financial Group Limited ACN 609 913 457 (E&P Financial Group) (together, the Schemes) as proposed by a resolution to be considered at the meeting of the sole member of the Scheme Companies to be held on 18 November 2026.

If approved, the Schemes will effect a solvent reconstruction or amalgamation of various companies in the group of companies of which E&P Financial Group is the ultimate holding company (E&P Group) to separate the E&P Wealth business and the E&P Capital business into distinct corporate structures. If the Schemes are approved and implemented:

a.    specified assets and liabilities of EAP relating to the Institutional and Research divisions of the E&P Capital business (primarily its institutional broking, research and securities dealing activities), together with its broker execution business, will be transferred to E&P Securities Pty Limited ACN 691 995 669 (EPS) and E&P Capital Holdings Pty Limited ACN 650 900 815 (EPCH);

b.    specified vendor-related, employee-related and other assets and liabilities of E&P Ops will be transferred to EAP, EPS and EPCH; and

c.    EAP will continue to carry on the E&P Wealth business, and EPS will replace EAP as the E&P Group’s market participant of the financial markets respectively operated by ASX Limited and TMX Australia Exchange Pty Ltd.

If you wish to oppose the approval of the Schemes, you must file and serve on the Scheme Companies a notice of appearance, in the prescribed form, together with any affidavit on which you wish to rely at the hearing. The notice of appearance and affidavit must be served on the Scheme Companies at their address for service at least 1 day before the date fixed for the hearing of the application.

The address for service of the Scheme Companies is:

c/- MinterEllison

Collins Arch, Level 20, 447 Collins Street

Melbourne VIC 3000

Attention: Bart Oude-Vrielink

Email: bart.oude-vrielink@minterellison.com

Reference: 1423784

Dated: [●] November 2026

Bart Oude-Vrielink, MinterEllison

Solicitor for the Scheme Companies

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

O’CALLAGHAN J:

Introduction

1    By originating process dated 23 October 2026, the two plaintiffs, Evans and Partners Pty Ltd (EAP) and E&P Operations Pty Ltd (E&P Ops) (together, the Scheme Companies), have applied for orders pursuant to ss 411, 413 and 1319 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) in relation to two proposed schemes of arrangement.

2    The Scheme Companies sought orders under s 411(1) of the Act providing for, among other things, each of them to convene a meeting of its sole member (in both cases E&P Financial Group Limited) (each a Scheme Meeting and together, the Scheme Meetings) for the purposes of that sole member considering and, if thought fit, agreeing (with or without modification) to the two separate proposed schemes of arrangement. The two schemes are the scheme of arrangement between EAP and the sole member (EAP Scheme), and the scheme of arrangement between E&P Ops and the sole member (E&P Ops Scheme), together, the Schemes.

3    EAP and E&P Ops are both wholly owned subsidiaries of E&P Financial Group and are members of a group of companies known as the E&P Group. The first and second defendant companies (being EPS and EPCH, respectively) are also members of the E&P Group. EAP, E&P Ops, EPS and EPCH are each Australian companies limited by shares and ultimately controlled by E&P Financial Group.

4    The Schemes are being proposed for the purposes of, or in connection with, the internal reconstruction of the two Scheme Companies. It is proposed that, among other things, certain of the property and liabilities of the Scheme Companies will be transferred to EPS and EPCH.

5    After the hearing in this matter on 12 November 2026, I made the orders sought by the plaintiffs. These are my reasons for doing so.

Evidence and other materials

6    In support of the application, the Scheme Companies filed the following affidavits:

(1)    affidavit of Bernard Frederic Oude-Vrielink sworn 22 October 2026 (First Oude-Vrielink Affidavit) annexing company searches of each of the two Scheme Companies and their sole member;

(2)    affidavit of Francis Noel Araullo sworn 9 November 2026 (Araullo Affidavit). Mr Araullo is the Chief Risk Officer of E&P Financial Group, a director of each of the two Scheme Companies and a director of each of EPS and EPCH. In his affidavit, Mr Araullo deposes to, among other matters:

(a)    the E&P Group and its businesses;

(b)    the proposed internal reconstruction and how it is to be effected;

(c)    the Schemes and scheme implementation deed;

(d)    the draft explanatory statement and related material, a copy of which was annexed;

(e)    various steps necessary to complete the internal reconstruction not forming part of the Schemes, and the progress to completion of those steps;

(f)    the orders to be sought at the second court hearing;

(g)    conditions precedent to the Schemes and scheme consideration;

(h)    a directors’ recommendation in respect of each Scheme and interests in the Scheme Companies;

(i)    the decision not to obtain an independent expert report on the effect of the Schemes on creditors;

(j)    a deed of guarantee from E&P Financial Group;

(k)    confidential transfer documents and confidentiality orders proposed to be sought;

(l)    wrong pockets adjustment mechanism and other transition arrangements;

(m)    correspondence with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC); and

(n)    the proposed Scheme Meetings and the delivery of documents to the scheme shareholder, notices to creditors and other procedural matters for the Scheme Meetings.

(3)    affidavit of Michael John Swain affirmed 9 November 2026 recording service on each of EPS and EPCH of the originating process and the First Oude-Vrielink Affidavit on 26 October 2026; and

(4)    second affidavit of Bernard Frederic Oude-Vrielink sworn 11 November 2026 (Second Oude-Vrielink Affidavit) which annexes an amended form of the draft explanatory statement (those amendments being necessary to reflect the granting of an Australian Financial Services Licence (AFSL) to EPS), and further correspondence with ASIC.

7    I was also provided with counsel’s detailed written submissions in support of the application.

Background

The companies

8    EAP is an Australian proprietary company limited by shares registered in Victoria. EAP currently carries on the E&P Wealth Business and the EAP Capital Business (as well as the Broker Execution Business). EAP holds an AFSL (number 318 075) and is a market participant of each of the financial markets operated by ASX Limited (ASX) and TMX Australia Exchange Pty Ltd (TMX).

9    The E&P Wealth Business and the EAP Capital Businesses currently operate under EAP’s AFSL and, where relevant, its market participant admissions. Being a market participant enables EAP to broker and execute trades on each of those financial markets on behalf of its clients.

10    E&P Ops is an Australian proprietary company limited by shares registered in New South Wales. E&P Ops provides services (including corporate, administrative and operational services) to various entities within the E&P Group that provide financial services and, in that capacity, it employs staff and is party to vendor contracts that support the E&P Group’s businesses.

11    The E&P Group conducts two main businesses, being the E&P Wealth Business (and the E&P Capital Business, which has four divisions. EAP presently carries on the E&P Wealth Business and two of the four divisions of the E&P Capital Business (being the “Institutional division” and the “Research division”, collectively the EAP Capital Businesses). The other two divisions of the E&P Capital Business (being the “Corporate Advisory and Capital Markets division” and “Hong Kong division”) are carried on by other entities in the E&P Group. Those two divisions are proposed to be transferred to EPCH outside of the terms of the Schemes (by way of a transfer by E&P Ops to EPCH of the shares in the relevant subsidiaries) and are carried on through wholly owned subsidiaries of E&P Ops, being E&P Capital Pty Limited and E&P Asia (HK) Limited, respectively.

12    EPS is an Australian proprietary company limited by shares registered in New South Wales. EPS is a wholly owned subsidiary of EPCH (and accordingly an indirect wholly owned subsidiary of E&P Financial Group). EPS was incorporated under the Act on 20 October 2025 for the purpose of receiving specified assets and liabilities from EAP (and, in the case of certain assets and liabilities, from E&P Ops) under the Schemes.

13    EPCH is an Australian proprietary company limited by shares registered in New South Wales. EPCH is a direct wholly owned subsidiary of E&P Financial Group. It is proposed that EPCH will be the holding company of the new E&P Capital sub-group and will receive certain transferring employees and other specified assets and liabilities under each Scheme.

14    Each of EAP, E&P Ops and EPCH is a wholly owned subsidiary of E&P Financial Group. EPS, as noted above, is a wholly owned subsidiary of EPCH (and thus an indirect wholly owned subsidiary of E&P Financial Group).

15    E&P Financial Group is an Australian unlisted public company limited by shares registered in Victoria. E&P Financial Group is the ultimate holding company of the E&P Group.

Internal reconstruction

16    As I said earlier, the Schemes are being proposed for the purposes of, or in connection with, the internal reconstruction of the two Scheme Companies. The proposed internal reconstruction involves all four divisions of the E&P Capital Business being transferred to a new wholly owned corporate structure headed by EPCH (with EPS, a wholly owned subsidiary of EPCH, becoming the E&P Group’s ASX and TMX market participant), with the result that, following the proposed internal reconstruction, EAP will continue to conduct the E&P Wealth Business while all four divisions of the E&P Capital Business will then be carried on within the EPCH sub-group, separate from both EAP and E&P Ops. The proposed internal reconstruction is to be undertaken through a combination of the two Schemes and certain steps to be undertaken outside of and separate from the Schemes.

17    Two divisions of the E&P Capital Business are to be transferred to EPS and EPCH under the Schemes with the other two divisions of the E&P Capital Business to be transferred to EPCH outside of the Schemes. The objectives of the internal reconstruction are to deliver improvements in operational and capital efficiencies and flexibility in the E&P Group businesses and establish EPS as a market participant with a dedicated AFSL.

18    If the Scheme Meetings are convened and the relevant resolutions passed, the Scheme Companies at the second court hearing will seek orders under s 413 of the Act to facilitate the transfer of, among other things, the relevant property and liabilities from the Scheme Companies to EPS and EPCH. EPS and EPCH are each a transferee company for the purposes of s 413. Under the E&P Ops Scheme, certain property and liabilities are also proposed to be transferred to EAP, such that EAP is both a Scheme Company and a transferee company for the purposes of s 413. EPS, EPCH and EAP (in its capacity as a transferee company under the E&P Ops Scheme) are collectively the Transferee Companies.

Overview of the Schemes

19    The details of each of the Schemes are referred to in the Araullo Affidavit and described in further detail in sections 1.7 and 5 of the explanatory statement annexed to his affidavit (and also the Second Oude-Vrielink Affidavit) (Explanatory Statement).

20    The terms of each Scheme are included in Annexures A and B to that Explanatory Statement. As noted above, the proposed internal reconstruction of EAP and E&P Ops is to be undertaken through a combination of the two Schemes and certain steps to be undertaken outside of and separate from the Schemes. The mechanical terms of the Schemes are complex and detailed given the nature of the transaction. But it is not necessary to recite that detail for the purposes of this application.

21    Under the EAP Scheme, specified assets and liabilities of EAP (primarily relating to its institutional, broking, research and securities dealing activities) will transfer to EPS and EPCH, and EAP’s Broker Execution Business (as defined in the Explanatory Statement) will transfer to EPS as a distinct part of EAP’s business. The EAP Scheme also provides for the identification of “Shared Clients” (being clients of EAP who continue as advisory clients of the E&P Wealth Business while separately becoming clients of EPS for Broker Execution Services) and for related record-copy and operational mechanics.

22    Under the E&P Ops Scheme, specified vendor-related and employee-related assets and liabilities of E&P Ops will transfer to EAP, EPS and EPCH. Other specified assets and liabilities primarily relating to the operation of the E&P Capital Business will also transfer from E&P Ops to EPCH. Under the E&P Ops Scheme, EAP will receive certain transferred employees (by way of the transfer of their employment). Mr Araullo deposes that some employees under the E&P Wealth division will be transferring from E&P Ops to EAP (because, following the proposed internal reconstruction, EAP will continue to conduct the E&P Wealth Business).

23    The specified assets and liabilities to be transferred under each of the Schemes include those identified in the three transfer agreements, being the Client Transfer Agreement, the Employee Transfer Agreement and the Vendor Transfer Agreement. In this regard, clause 7 of the EAP Scheme provides, among other things, that the classes of vendors, the employees (or classes of employees) and the classes of clients which are the subject of that Scheme are as identified in the relevant transfer agreement.

24    Similarly, clause 7 of the E&P Ops Scheme provides, among other things, that the classes of vendors and employees or classes of employees which are the subject of that Scheme are as identified in the relevant transfer agreement. Mr Araullo deposes to the obvious enough confidential nature of some of the provisions in the transfer agreements.

25    The objectives of the Schemes are set out in section 5.1 of the Explanatory Statement. In summary, the Schemes are intended to deliver operational efficiencies to improve the E&P Group’s capital efficiency and to provide the E&P Group with flexibility over its future operations and structure. Section 8 of the Explanatory Statement also refers to the benefits of the Schemes.

26    The detailed written submissions filed in support of the application contained an extensive explanation of the key aspects of the proposed internal reconstructions, including:

(1)    the scheme consideration;

(2)    the AFSL held by EAP;

(3)    the two Schemes’ contemplation of current and continuing clients of the Scheme Companies;

(4)    the adoption of retail client disclosures;

(5)    the regime under the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act 2006 (Cth); and

(6)    the recommendations and interests of the directors of each of the Scheme Companies.

Consideration

Statutory framework

27    The statutory framework relating to schemes of arrangement is set out in Pt 5.1 of the Act and involves a three-stage process:

(1)    the hearing of an application to the court for orders to convene a meeting or meetings (s 411(1) of the Act);

(2)    the holding of the meeting or meetings (s 411(4)(a) of the Act); and

(3)    the hearing of an application to the court for an order to approve the scheme (ss 411(4)(b) and 411(6) of the Act).

28    The hearing in this matter on 12 November 2026 concerned the first stage.

29    The court’s role in considering an application for orders at this first stage is well settled and has been set out in numerous cases. Justice Finkelstein summarised relevant authorities in an oft-cited passage in Re CSR Ltd (2010) 183 FCR 358 at 379-80 [72]–[76]:

72     The first topic concerns the appropriate practice as regards an application to convene a scheme meeting. The function of the court on the convening application is “emphatically not” to consider the merits or fairness of the proposed scheme: Re Telewest Communications plc [2004] BCC 342 at 348. It is largely to decide whether there should be one or more meetings and to decide the manner in which that meeting, or those meetings, should be summoned and conducted.

73     Nonetheless, it seems now to be accepted that there are occasions on which the court is justified in considering, on the convening application, whether the scheme is one which, if approved by the requisite majority, would be sanctioned by the court. Necessarily, the occasions on which it will be appropriate to take that course are few. The current practice is to have disputes about classes determined before the meeting. Issues that go to the jurisdiction of the court to approve the scheme may also be raised at the convening hearing. So also might an issue which could lead the court to refuse to sanction the scheme. What is not clear regarding this last category is how immediately apparent the issue must be.

74     In Re T & N Ltd [2007] 1 All ER 851, David Richards J said at [19] that the issue must be such as would “unquestionably” lead to a refusal. In Re Foundation Healthcare Ltd (2002) 42 ACSR 252 at 265 French J (as he then was) said that “a scheme may appear on its face so blatantly unfair or otherwise inappropriate that it should be stopped in its tracks before going any further”. In Re Central Pacific Minerals NL [2002] FCA 239 at [8], Emmett J said that the court will not convene a meeting unless the proposal is likely to be approved if it were unopposed. This does not represent a uniform approach. Some reconsideration is appropriate.

75     In Re NRMA Ltd (No 1) (2000) 156 FLR 349 Santow J drew a distinction between two lines of Australian authority regarding the proper approach of the court at the convening stage (at [32]-[40]). The first approach, which his Honour favoured, suggests the court should generally confine itself to ensuring that certain procedural and substantive requirements are met (for example, that there will be adequate disclosure), with limited consideration of issues of fairness. This was the approach adopted in Re Foundation Healthcare. The alternative approach (similar to that adopted in Re Central Pacific) is to look to the merits of the scheme to determine whether it is likely that the court will approve the arrangement when it comes back for approval.

76     In my view, the test propounded in Re T & N and, subject to one qualification, in Re Foundation Healthcare, should be applied. Such an approach properly reflects the two stage nature of the scheme hearing process, where convening hearings often take place on limited notice, and where issues and objectors regarding a scheme may only emerge after the scheme meeting. As such, instead of saving costs and court time, hearing the merits at the convening stage may achieve the opposite. Thus an inquiry into the merits at the convening stage will only be warranted if there is a clear indication that the scheme will not be approved. The indication may appear from the terms of the scheme. Or it may arise out of an incontrovertible fact (which is the basis upon which I would qualify what is said in Re Foundation Healthcare).

30    See too Re Signature Gold Ltd [2017] FCA 1481 at [20]–[24] (Markovic J); Re Chevron (TAPL) Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 220 at [17]–[20] (Banks-Smith J); Re Absolute Equity Performance Fund Ltd [2022] FCA 933 at [14] (Halley J).

31    The court’s discretion to make appropriate orders will be enlivened if:

(1)    the plaintiff is a Pt 5.1 body;

(2)    the proposed scheme is an “arrangement” within the meaning of s 411 of the Act;

(3)    the explanatory statement will provide proper disclosure to members;

(4)    the scheme is bona fide and properly proposed;

(5)    ASIC has had reasonable opportunity to examine the proposed scheme and the explanatory statement, has had reasonable opportunity to make submissions and has had 14 days’ notice of the hearing date of the first court hearing; and

(6)    any other procedural requirements have been met, such as r 3.2 of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) as to the nomination of a chairperson for the scheme meeting.

The Scheme Companies’ sole member

32    The two Scheme Companies are controlled by their mutual sole shareholder, E&P Financial Group. But the cases make it clear that it is necessary to hold the scheme meetings.

33    As Young J said in Re AGL Sydney Ltd (1994) 13 ACSR 597 (at 598):

Although this is not universally true, in most cases the only shareholder of the subsidiaries is a holding company. As the group has resolved on this policy, it is unlikely in the extreme that there would be any objection by any of the members. It is accordingly, in one sense a waste of time to actually hold the meetings, but the scheme of the Corporations Act seems to envisage meetings being held, and whilst it might be argued that it is possible to approve a scheme of arrangement in the present case without actually holding a meeting, it is convenient to follow the usual course laid down by the Corporations Act so as to alert various people, who might be interested, to what is going on.

34    See too SGIC Insurance Ltd v Insurance Australia Ltd [2004] FCA 1492 (Jacobson J) referring to Re Hastings Deering Pty Ltd (1985) 3 ACLC 474.

35    Since those cases, the approach of proponents of an internal reconstruction scheme in which s 413 orders have been proposed to be sought at the second court hearing has been to seek orders for the convening of a scheme meeting. See most recently Re Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd [2026] NSWSC 1010 (Black J).

The proposed date for the second hearing

36    The Scheme Companies sought an order at the first court hearing enabling the Scheme Meetings to be held on short notice. It is proposed that the second court hearing be scheduled for 10.15 am (Melbourne time) on 25 November 2026.

37    It was submitted that it is not inappropriate for the second court hearing to be held less than two weeks after the first court hearing (and one week after the Scheme Meetings) where both of the Scheme Companies have the same sole member. In Millennium CHPP Pty Ltd v Millennium Coal Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 1556, Stone J made orders convening scheme meetings on 7 December 2009 with approval orders being made on 16 December 2009. As to the short interval of time between the two court hearings, her Honour noted as follows:

Because most of the Scheme Companies are single member intra-group entities the meetings are more of a formality than would otherwise be the case. For this reason, the interval between the first hearing on 7 December and this second court hearing on 16 December in respect of approval under s 413 has been unusually short. This is not inappropriate where meetings involve members of the same corporate group; SGIC Insurance Ltd v Insurance Australia [2004] FCA 1492;51 ACSR 470.

38    See too Re Queensland Teachers’ Union Health Fund Limited [2025] FCA 481 (where the scheme meeting date was 18 June 2025 and the second court hearing was scheduled for 23 June 2025); Re Woolworths Group Limited [2019] FCA 1810 (where the scheme meeting date was 16 December 2019 and the second court hearing date was scheduled for 19 December 2019).

39    As to the notice of the second court hearing, r 3.4 of the Rules requires that notice of the second court hearing be published at least five days before the date of the second court hearing with the notice being in the form of Form 6 (addressed to members and creditors) to the Rules. It has been the court’s practice for some time (if requested by the scheme company) to dispense with the five-day requirement under r 3.4 to enable a shorter period to take place between the scheme meeting and the second court date on the basis that the notice of the second court hearing is published prior to the scheme meeting.

40    In the present case, it was proposed that a single notice of the second court hearing in respect of both Scheme Companies, addressed to all the creditors and the sole member of each Scheme Company, be published once in The Australian on or before 17 November 2026, the day prior to the Scheme Meetings and at least five days before the proposed second court hearing. That notice is a combined notice for both Scheme Companies, rather than an individual notice in the form of Form 6, and the Scheme Companies sought to be otherwise exempted from compliance with r 3.4 of, and Form 6 to, the Rules.

41    I accept the submission that the proposed date of each of the Scheme Meetings, the second court hearing, and notice and publication of those matters as proposed by EAP and E&P Ops is sufficient.

Section 411 jurisdiction

42    I am satisfied that the evidence upon which EAP and E&P Ops rely is sufficient to establish:

(1)    each of EAP and E&P Ops is a Pt 5.1 body;

(2)    each of the Schemes is bona fide and properly proposed;

(3)    each of the proposed Schemes is an arrangement for the purposes of s 411(1). See Re Perpetual Trustee at [14] and the authorities cited there, set out at [47] below;

(4)    ASIC has had reasonable opportunity to examine the proposed Schemes and the Explanatory Statement and to make submissions to the court. The affidavit evidence records that ASIC was given 14 days’ notice of the hearing date of the first court hearing and, on 11 November 2026, ASIC indicated, among other things, that it does not intend to intervene;

(5)    the information provided in the Explanatory Statement is sufficient and contains the prescribed information;

(6)    the procedural requirements of the Rules have been met or may be dispensed with; and

(7)    there is no apparent reason why the scheme should not, in due course, receive the court’s approval if the necessary majority of votes are achieved.

43    The procedural requirements in respect of the two Schemes are satisfied and the court’s discretion to make the orders sought by the Scheme Companies to convene the Scheme Meetings is enlivened.

Principles for exercise of discretion

44    While the proposed orders to be sought under s 413 to facilitate the proposed reconstruction of the two Scheme Companies are a matter for the second court hearing, the court in schemes of this nature has adopted the position that it is appropriate at the first court hearing to provisionally identify whether the proposed s 413 orders are capable of being made at or after the second court hearing.

45    Justice Halley set out the following summary of the relevant principles for the exercise of the court’s discretion to order the convening of a meeting to consider approving a proposed scheme of arrangement in Re Absolute Equity Performance Fund Ltd [2022] FCA 933 at [18]–[22]:

[18]     The Court will not ordinarily make orders for the convening of a scheme meeting unless the scheme is of such a nature and cast on such terms that if it receives the statutory majority at the meeting, the Court would be likely to approve it on the hearing of an application that was not opposed.

[19]     At the first court hearing, the Court exercises its supervisory jurisdiction in order to review the scheme and the explanatory statement and to raise any queries that it might have with the plaintiff. The Court needs to be satisfied that there are no obvious flaws in the scheme and that there is an adequate explanation provided to persons who have a financial interest in the proposed scheme.

[20]     The Court should consider at the first court hearing whether the proposed scheme is not inappropriate and whether it is one that sensible business people might consider is of benefit to its members.

[21]     The Court does not need to be satisfied that no better scheme could have been proposed and ultimately that is a question for the members themselves to determine at the scheme meeting.

[22]     Although the second court hearing is when the Court makes its final determination, in practice, the first court hearing is where the Court will typically intervene if it has concerns. A reason that has been advanced for this is that the market views the approval by the Court of the convening of scheme meetings as providing assurance that the scheme, at least in form and substance, has received a preliminary clearance by the Court and that trading in the company’s securities thereafter will proceed on that basis.

(Citations omitted.)

46    In Re Perpetual Trustee, Black J (at [15]) noted in the following terms that s 413 allowed the court to make orders to facilitate the reconstruction of a company if three requirements were satisfied:

I also recognise that s 413 of the Act allows the Court to make orders to facilitate the reconstruction of a company if three requirements are satisfied. Those requirements are that an application has been made under Pt 5.1 of the Act for the approval of a compromise or arrangement; the compromise or arrangement has been proposed for the purposes of, or in connection with, a scheme for, relevantly, the reconstruction of a Pt 5.1 body or bodies; and the whole or any part of the undertaking or property of a body concerned in the scheme is to be transferred to a company under the scheme: Re Application of AGL Sydney Ltd (1994) 13 ACSR 597; Barrick (Australia Pacific Exploration) Pty Ltd v Barrick (PD) Australia Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 998 at [81]; Re Ovato Print Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 1882 at [47]; Telstra at [27]ff.

47    In relation to the requirement that a scheme be a compromise or arrangement between the members and scheme company, Black J also relevantly said (at [14]):

The internal restructuring contemplated by the scheme also involves an element of compromise or arrangement between PTCo and Perpetual where, on implementation of the scheme, PTCo will cease to hold relevant assets, will cease to be subject to relevant liabilities and will cease to be a party to relevant litigation, and the economic value of the transferred part of its business will be transferred to the transferee: JP Morgan Operations Australia Ltd v JP Morgan Australia Group Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1131 at [18] …; Re Woolworths Group Ltd [2019] FCA 1810 at [20(6)] …; Re Anglo-Gaelic Investments Pty Ltd [2019] NSWSC 441 …; Re Telstra Corp Ltd (2022) 163 ACSR 429; [2022] NSWSC 1180 ….

48    I am satisfied that the internal restructuring contemplated by the proposed Schemes involves an arrangement between EAP and its sole member, and E&P Ops and its sole member, for the purposes of s 411(1) of the Act.

49    Given the ex parte nature of an application under s 411(1), the following matters were specifically drawn to my attention in the course of the Scheme Companies’ written and oral submissions:

(1)    the scheme consideration;

(2)    the single member class;

(3)    the proposed s 413(1)(g) orders;

(4)    ASIC’s relief from the requirement for an independent expert’s report;

(5)    the position of creditors;

(6)    the position of employees;

(7)    the conditions precedent;

(8)    the bifurcation of the Client Agreements and accounts;

(9)    s 411(17) of the Act; and

(10)    the proposed confidentiality orders.

50    Having had the benefit of the detailed written and oral submissions of Mr Ahern, and having read the evidence relied upon by the Scheme Companies, I am satisfied, for the reasons set out in those submissions, that each of the Schemes is fit for consideration by the respective sole member, and there is nothing in the terms or structure of the Schemes that gives rise to any apparent reason that, if agreed to at the Scheme Meetings, the court would not approve the Schemes at the second court hearing.

Disposition

51    For the foregoing reasons, I am satisfied that the proposed Schemes are an arrangement for the purposes of s 411 of the Act and that an order convening the Scheme Meetings, and ancillary orders as sought by EAP and E&P Ops, should be made.

I certify that the preceding fifty-one (51) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Justice O'Callaghan.

Associate:

Dated:    20 November 2026