Federal Court of Australia
Watson Webb Pty Ltd v Comino (No 3) [2026] FCA 1777
File number(s): | NSD 1335 of 2021 NSD 1337 of 2021 |
Judgment of: | HALLEY J |
Date of judgment: | 19 November 2026 |
Catchwords: | COSTS – applications for lump sum costs orders – whether to exercise discretion to make orders for lump sum costs – where respondents oppose lump sum costs orders – where delay in seeking lump sum costs orders – whether lump sum orders are in the interests of justice – applications allowed – Registrar to determine quantum of lump sums |
Legislation: | Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) |
Cases cited: | Fewin Pty Ltd v Burke (No 3) [2017] FCA 693 Hudson v Sigalla [2016] FCA 1204 Paciocco v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (No 2) (2017) 253 FCR 403; [2017] FCAFC 146 Short v Crawley (No 45) [2013] NSWSC 1541 Su v Australian Fisheries Management Authority (No 3) [2008] FCA 2018 Torc Solutions Pty Ltd v Unex Corporation (No 2) [2025] FCA 1648 |
Division: | General Division |
Registry: | New South Wales |
National Practice Area: | Intellectual Property |
Sub-area: | Copyright and Industrial Designs |
Number of paragraphs: | 22 |
Date of last submission: | 14 October 2026 |
Date of hearing: | On the papers |
Counsel for the applicant and appellant: | P Flynn SC |
Solicitors for the applicant and appellant: | Watson Webb |
Counsel for the respondent: | A Fox SC |
Solicitors for the respondent: | Bird & Bird |
ORDERS
NSD 1335 of 2021 | ||
| ||
BETWEEN: | WATSON WEBB PTY LTD (FORMERLY WATSON CHIARELLA PTY LTD) Appellant | |
AND: | JOHN ALEXANDER COMINO Respondent | |
order made by: | HALLEY J |
DATE OF ORDER: | 19 November 2026 |
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1. Pursuant to r 40.02(b) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the costs payable by the respondent to the appellant and All Valve Industries Pty Ltd pursuant to Order 1 made on 24 October 2025 be awarded in a lump sum, in an amount to be determined in accordance with the lump-sum costs procedure in the Costs Practice Note (GPN-COSTS).
2. Pursuant to s 35A(1)(f) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), the lump sum assessment, including the determination of any procedural steps, be referred to Registrar White, being the Registrar determining the lump sum costs of related appeals NSD 1656/2025, NSD 1998/2025 and NSD 2057/2025.
3. Within 21 days, the appellant and All Valve Industries Pty Ltd file and serve a costs summary (no more than 25 pages) in accordance with paragraphs 4.10 to 4.12 of GPN-COSTS, and the respondent file and serve any costs response (no more than 25 pages) in accordance with paragraphs 4.13 to 4.14 of GPN-COSTS within 21 days of receipt of the costs summary.
4. The costs summary referred to in order 3 is to be a single consolidated costs summary in respect of the costs in this proceeding and in NSD 1337/2021.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
ORDERS
NSD 1337 of 2021 | ||
BETWEEN: | ALL VALVE INDUSTRIES PTY LTD First Applicant | |
CAV. UFF. GIACOMO CIMBERIO S.P.A Second Applicant | ||
AND: | JOHN ALEXANDER COMINO First Respondent | |
STRONGCAST PTY LTD Second Respondent | ||
AND BETWEEN: | JOHN ALEXANDER COMINO First Cross-Claimant (First Cross-Claim) | |
STRONGCAST PTY LTD Second Cross-Claimant (First Cross-Claim) | ||
AND: | ALL VALVE INDUSTRIES PTY LTD Cross-Respondent (First Cross-Claim) | |
AND BETWEEN: | ALL VALVE INDUSTRIES PTY LTD Cross-Claimant (Second Cross-Claim) | |
AND: | JOHN ALEXANDER COMINO Cross-Respondent (Second Cross-Claim) | |
order made by: | Halley J |
DATE OF ORDER: | 19 November 2026 |
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1. Pursuant to r 40.02(b) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the costs payable by the respondents to the applicants pursuant to Order 1 made on 9 September 2025 be awarded in a lump sum, in an amount to be determined in accordance with the lump-sum costs procedure in the Costs Practice Note (GPN-COSTS).
2. Pursuant to s 35A(1)(f) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), the lump sum assessment, including the determination of any procedural steps, be referred to Registrar White, being the Registrar determining the lump sum costs of related appeals NSD 1656/2025, NSD 1998/2025 and NSD 2057/2025.
3. Within 21 days, the applicants file and serve a costs summary (no more than 25 pages) in accordance with paragraphs 4.10 to 4.12 of GPN-COSTS, and the respondents file and serve any costs response (no more than 25 pages) in accordance with paragraphs 4.13 to 4.14 of GPN-COSTS within 21 days of receipt of the costs summary.
4. The costs summary referred to in order 3 is to be a single consolidated costs summary in respect of the costs in this proceeding and in NSD 1335/2021.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
A. Introduction
1 The appellant and applicants seek orders that costs orders made in these proceedings after trial be determined by way of a lump sum process (application). The application is opposed by the respondents.
2 The costs orders in NSD1335/2021 were made on 24 October 2025 and provided that the respondent is to pay the costs of the appellant and All Valve Industries Pty Ltd with respect to the appeal and the proceeding before the Designs Office.
3 The costs orders in NSD1337/2021 were made on 9 September 2025 and provided that the respondents are to pay, on a party and party basis, 75% of the costs arising from and with respect to the originating application filed on 20 December 2021.
4 The respondents principally contend that the costs orders should not be determined on a lump sum basis due to the delay by the appellant and the applicants in bringing the application and because making the lump sum costs orders sought in the application would not be in the interests of justice.
5 The respondents also contend that there would be no efficiencies in referring any lump sum determination of the costs orders to the Registrar currently addressing lump sum costs orders in the appeals from NSD1335 and NSD1337 and they maintain that r 40.08 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (Rules) may subsequently be engaged after the quantum of any damages payable has ultimately been determined.
B. Relevant principles
6 Section 43(3)(d) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (Act) confers a discretion to award a party costs “in a specified sum”, and r 40.02(b) of the Rules permits a party entitled to costs to apply for a lump sum. The Court’s preference, wherever it is practicable and appropriate, is to make a lump sum costs order: GPN-COSTS (Costs Practice Note) at [4.1]; Torc Solutions Pty Ltd v Unex Corporation (No 2) [2025] FCA 1648 at [28]-[29] (Neskovcin J). The Costs Practice Note makes clear that the Court should proceed on the basis that taxation “should be the exception” and confined to matters which are unable to be determined otherwise: Costs Practice Note at [3.3]; Paciocco v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (No 2) (2017) 253 FCR 403; [2017] FCAFC 146 at [16].
7 The purposes of a lump sum costs order include the avoidance of the delay, expense, inconvenience, and aggravation attending taxation: Fewin Pty Ltd v Burke (No 3) [2017] FCA 693 at [7]-[14] (Markovic J). Such an order brings finality to the litigation efficiently, both in terms of the time and cost that parties might otherwise expend in the taxation process: Fewin at [49], applied in Torc at [30]. Nonetheless, a lump sum costs order is not mandated in all instances. In all cases it is a matter for the Court to exercise the discretion given to it by the Act and the Rules: Paciocco at [19].
C. Does Delay preclude making lump sum costs orders?
8 The respondents submit that (a) the application should have been made at the time that the costs orders were made, (b) no evidence has been led by the appellant or the applicants that any difficulty would otherwise arise in implementing the costs orders, and (c) there is no suggestion that there was any slip or error on the part of the Court in not providing for costs to be determined on a lump sum basis at the time the costs were made.
9 The Court’s power to order lump sum costs is discretionary. It is not confined and may be exercised whenever the circumstances warrant it: Su v Australian Fisheries Management Authority (No 3) [2008] FCA 2018 at [1] (Reeves J).
10 Nor is it relevant to look for any error or slip in the making of the costs orders. A lump sum costs order is “in the nature of a supplemental order that can be made in aid of and as an alternative mode of enforcing a costs order made earlier in a proceeding”: Fewin at [56], citing Short v Crawley (No 45) [2013] NSWSC 1541 at [27]-[33] (White J) and Hudson v Sigalla [2016] FCA 1204 at [51]–[58] (Katzmann J). Such an order is “simply a different method of implementing an earlier order for costs” and “there is no requirement as to when an application for a lump sum costs order should or can be made”: Short at [57]-[58], citing Hudson at [51]-[55].
11 Moreover, there is no suggestion that any costs have been incurred by the parties in commencing a taxation of the costs of the appellant and the applicants. Further, given the judgments delivered at first instance in both NSD1335 and NSD1337 were appealed, the delay in making any application for a lump sum procedure is at least partly explicable.
12 In the absence of any apparent prejudice, I do not consider that the delay in making the application should preclude the making of lump sum costs orders.
D. Are lump sum costs orders in the interests of justice?
13 The respondents contend that it is not in the interests of justice that the costs orders should proceed other than by way of a taxation. The respondents submit that the different percentage recoveries in the two proceedings give rise to potential injustice unless a “proper examination”, by way of a formal taxation, is undertaken to ensure that costs of the applicants are not improperly allocated to NSD1335 in order to obtain a 100% recovery rather than a 75% recovery in NSD1337. They submit that this issue is particularly problematic given that the appellant and the applicants have made a significant allocation of costs of $398,438 to NSD1335 in comparison to the $442,668 of costs allocated to NSD1337. They submit this stands in contrast to an estimate by their solicitor that 15% of the costs of both proceedings was attributable to the designs entitlement issue, which was the subject of NSD1335.
14 I accept that the allocation of costs between NSD1335 and NSD1337 will require careful scrutiny and attention. Nevertheless, I am satisfied given the interrelationship between the two proceedings and that the two proceedings travelled and were heard together, that a taxation would, in all likelihood, lead to false or illusory precision in the allocation of costs between the two proceedings. Rather, in my view, an evaluative approach applied through the lens of a lump sum procedure is more likely to provide for a more plausible and persuasive allocation of costs between the proceedings that is more consistent with the interests of justice. There is nothing in the lump sum procedure which would preclude that scrutiny.
15 I am otherwise satisfied, as submitted by the appellant and the applicants, that the scale and complexity of these proceedings makes them a “paradigm case” for the making of lump sum costs orders.
E. Referral to Registrar allocated appellate lump sum costs orders
16 Further, I consider that there would likely be material cost benefits in referring any lump sum determination of the costs orders to the Registrar who has been allocated the determination of the lump sum costs orders in the appeals from NSD1335 and NSD1337.
17 I accept that the appeal costs are discrete from the costs incurred in NSD1335 and NSD1337, but the subject matter and factual background are the same. As submitted by the appellant and the applicants, where proceedings and appeals are closely related, it “makes sense” for the lump sum cost determinations to be considered together, or at least by the same Registrar: Paciocco at [32]-[36].
F. The potential relevance of Rule 40.08
18 Rule 40.08 of the Rules for present purposes relevantly provides that, where an applicant has been awarded a money sum or damages in a sum of less than $100,000, a party may apply to the Court for an order that any costs and disbursements payable to another party in the proceeding be reduced by an amount to be specified by the Court.
19 The appellant and the applicants submitted that “the application under r 40.08 should not be entertained, because it seeks to reopen the Court’s determination of the costs entitlement question”.
20 The respondents, however, confirmed in their submissions that they were not presently advancing any application under r 40.08.
21 Given that confirmation, it is both unnecessary and undesirable to express any view on whether r 40.08 may be engaged after completion of the inquiry into the pecuniary relief to be awarded to the applicants in NSD1337. I decline to do so.
G. Disposition
22 Lump sum costs orders for the determination of the costs the subject of the costs orders in NSD1335 and NSD1337 are to be made substantially in the form sought by the appellant and the applicants.
I certify that the preceding twenty-two (22) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Justice Halley. |
Associate:
Dated: 19 November 2026
SCHEDULE OF PARTIES
NSD 1337 of 2021 | |
Applicants | |
First Applicant | ALL VALVE INDUSTRIES PTY LTD |
Second Applicant | CAV. UFF. GIACOMO CIMBERIO S.P.A |
Respondents | |
First Respondent | JOHN ALEXANDER COMINO |
Second Respondent | STRONGCAST PTY LTD |
Cross-Claimants (First Cross-Claim) | |
First Cross-Claimant | JOHN ALEXANDER COMINO |
Second Cross-Claimant | STRONGCAST PTY LTD |
Cross-Respondent (First Cross-Claim) | |
Cross-Respondent | ALL VALVE INDUSTRIES PTY LTD |
Cross-Claimants (Second Cross-Claim) | |
Cross-Claimant | ALL VALVE INDUSTRIES PTY LTD |
Cross-Respondent (Second Cross-Claim) | |
Cross-Respondent | JOHN ALEXANDER COMINO |