Federal Court of Australia

Khan v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FCA 1768

File number:

SAD 21 of 2026

Judgment of:

CHARLESWORTH J

Date of judgment:

20 November 2026

Catchwords:

MIGRATION – application under s 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) for a writ of mandamus compelling the respondent to decide a visa application under s 47 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – whether visa application withdrawn under s 49 of the Migration Act – application withdrawn – relief denied

Legislation:

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 45, 47, 49, 65

Cases cited:

Gillera v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCA 1396

Gillera v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] HCASL 37

NACO v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2002] FCA 474

Nguyen v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FCA 1424

Division:

General Division

Registry:

South Australia

National Practice Area:

Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights

Number of paragraphs:

40

Date of hearing:

21 May 2026

Counsel for the Applicant:

S Kikkert

Counsel for the Respondent:

O Morris

Solicitor for the Respondent:

Sparke Helmore Lawyers

ORDERS

SAD 21 of 2026

BETWEEN:

MOHAMMED RAFI YUNUSKHAN KHAN

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP

Respondent

order made by:

CHARLESWORTH J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 NOVEMBER 2026

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.    The further amended originating application is dismissed.

2.    The applicant is to pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the further amended originating application.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

CHARLESWORTH J:

INTRODUCTION

1    On 2 February 2021 the applicant, Mohammed Rafi Yunuskhan Khan, made an application for a Skilled Regional (Class VB, subclass 887) visa under s 45 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The visa application named Mr Khan as the primary applicant and his then wife as the secondary applicant.

2    Section 47(1) of the Act imposes an obligation on the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship to decide the application. The obligation to consider the application continues until (relevantly) the application is withdrawn: s 47(2)(a).

3    Section 49(1) of the Act provides that an applicant for a visa may, by written notice given to the Minister, withdraw the application. Once withdrawn, a visa application is taken to have been disposed of: s 49(2).

4    The visa application was made on behalf of Mr Khan and his then wife by a registered migration agent. The migration agent communicated on their behalf with the Department responsible for administering the Act.

5    On 1 August 2024, the migration agent lodged a notice titled “Withdrawal of a visa application” in a form provided by the Department for that purpose. Part C, item 7 of the form is headed “Details of the visa applicant(s) withdrawing the visa application”. Beneath that heading, the migration agent separately named both Mr Khan and his former wife, providing each of their details as prompted by the form. Elsewhere the notice included the visa application lodgement date and its identification number. I will refer to that as the Withdrawal Notice.

6    Notwithstanding the Withdrawal Notice, Mr Khan alleges that the visa application of his former wife has been withdrawn, but that his own application remains on foot. By his further amended originating application he seeks declaratory relief together with a writ of mandamus compelling the Minister to discharge the obligation to decide the visa application in accordance with the requirements of s 65 of the Act.

7    I have concluded that Mr Khan’s visa application was withdrawn within the meaning of s 49 of the Act on 1 August 2024. The Minister therefore has no obligation to determine it.

Jurisdiction

8    Mr Khan invokes this Court’s judicial review jurisdiction under s 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). Following amendments to the originating application, the Minister withdrew a contention that the Court lacked jurisdiction. The principles are discussed by Thomas J in Gillera v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCA 1396 (special leave to the High Court refused: Gillera v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] HCASL 37 (Gordon and Edelman JJ)). See also NACO v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2002] FCA 474 (Hely J) at [21].

Grounds

9    Following amendments, there are two grounds contained in Mr Khan’s originating application. The first is that “[t]he Department, or a delegate of the Minister, erred in determining that the applicant’s visa application was validly withdrawn”. The second is as follows:

The presence of a valid notice of withdrawal is an objective fact, and it is a factual matter that can be reviewed and determined based on contextual evidence, including by having regard to the Department’s concession that the notice of withdrawal was flawed and defective, and having regard to the Department requesting “additional information … to assist with confirming [the] request to withdraw [the] application”.

10    I have considered Ground 2 in the context of some factual particulars to Ground 1 and the written and oral submissions. The central contentions are that:

(1)    there is no prescribed form by which a person is to withdraw a visa application;

(2)    the standard form completed by the migration agent was one created by the Department for its own administrative convenience and has no greater legal effect than a written notice given by other means;

(3)    the content of the Withdrawal Notice should not be considered in isolation but must be understood as forming a part of other correspondence passing between the migration agent and the Department before and after the Withdrawal Notice was lodged;

(4)    considered collectively, the correspondence should not be understood to mean that Mr Khan had withdrawn his visa application (as opposed to withdrawing the application made by his former wife as the secondary applicant); and

(5)    when determining the objective question, the Court may have regard to correspondence from the Department which asserted that the visa application was still on foot.

Ground 1

11    This ground may be shortly disposed of.

12    In cases where the Minister has wrongly formed the view that a visa application has been withdrawn, mandamus may lie to compel the performance of the statutory obligation under s 47 of the Act.

13    However, the question of whether or not a visa application has been withdrawn does not depend upon a decision to that effect being made by the Minister or any other person. It is an objective question, to be answered by applying s 49 of the Act to the facts: Gillera at [32]; Nguyen v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FCA 1424 at [23] – [24] (Lee J). The objective question is addressed in Ground 2.

Ground 2

14    The undisputed facts underpinning this ground are as follows.

15    Mr Khan separated from his wife in July 2021.

16    Three years later, the migration agent lodged with the Department a standard form titled “Notification of Changes in Circumstances”. Where prompted to provide details of the changes in circumstances, the migration agent wrote:

Both applicants are living separately since 27/07/2021. they [sic] never lived as husband and wife since 27/07/2021. Thier [sic] marriage is dissolved as per the Islamic Sharia law and they do not continued [sic] to be as husband and wife. An affidavit has been enclosed in documents. So here primary [sic] applicant wants to withdraw the secondary applicant from the application.

17    The accompanying affidavit included brief details of the marital separation and supporting documents.

18    The Withdrawal Notice was set out in five parts. Part A contained details of the visa application being withdrawn, including the visa application lodgement date and its identification number. Part B of the form is titled “Authority to withdraw”. The questions in that part were left unanswered, including the question “Are you applying to withdraw the visa application on behalf of another person(s)?”. Part C contained details of both Mr Khan and his former wife as the visa applicants. As I have mentioned, those details appeared in the part of the form prompting “Details of the visa applicant(s) withdrawing the visa application”. Details of both Mr Khan and his former wife were provided. Part D is headed “Reason(s) for withdrawal”. The response given was as follows:

We are living separately since July 27 2021. We never lived as Husband and wife since then. Our marriage is dissolved as per the Islamic Sharia Law.

19    Part E is headed “Declaration”. The form was signed by Mr Khan above the incorrect date of 1 August 2014. It is common ground that the Withdrawal Notice was lodged on 1 August 2024, the day following the lodgement of the Notification of Changes in Circumstances form.

20    On 7 April 2025, Mr Khan sent an email to the Department seeking an update on his visa application.

21    On 26 May 2025, the Department sent a letter to Mr Khan concerning the Withdrawal Notice, together with a request checklist for further information. The checklist stated:

WITHDRAWAL – Withdrawal Consent request

The Department received notification to withdraw your Skilled - Regional (VB 887) visa application on 1 August 2024, however it is noted that the Form 1446 has been signed by Mohammed Rafi Yunushkan Khan only and the date the form was signed is declared to be 1 August 2014. Please find additional information below to assist with confirming your request to withdraw your application and further information that is required to be undertaken in regards to withdrawing your VB 887 visa application.

22    By way of the checklist, the Department sought additional information because the form had been signed by Mr Khan but the Department had not received notification of the consent of Mr Khan’s former wife to the withdrawal of her application. The Department stated:

Consequently, the withdrawal notification received on 1 August 2024 will be effective for [Mr Khan] (the primary applicant) only.

23    The Department stated that for the withdrawal to also be effective for Mr Khan’s former wife, an additional form should be lodged. At the end of the document, there appeared the heading “Police certificates”. There followed five paragraphs about a requirement to provide police certificates “as evidence that you satisfy the character requirements”, including a statement to the effect that if police certificates were not provided, “your application may be refused”.

24    Later on 26 May 2025, Mr Khan lodged the Withdrawal Notice in the same form and with the same content as that originally lodged on 1 August 2024, only this time containing the signature of his former wife. An additional withdrawal notice was lodged at the same time, naming only Mr Khan’s former wife as the person withdrawing the visa application.

25    The next day, Mr Khan responded to the request to provide a police certificate.

26    Mr Khan also filed a new Notification of Changes in Circumstances form. It contained the following assertion:

The department has asked for a Withdrawal form 1446 to withdraw the secondary applicant. The Primary applicant would like to withdraw only the secondary applicant, Ms. Farheenjahan Mohammed Rafi. The primary applicant wants to remain in the existing 887 (skilled visa application). The applicant entered both details in the application form by mistake. We have uploaded two Form 1446 dated 27/05/2025, and either one is correct, and the other is incorrect. Sorry for any inconvenience this may cause the department.

27    On 10 June 2025, the Department wrote to Mr Khan stating:

Your application for a Skilled – Regional (subclass 887) visa was withdrawn on 1 August 2024.

We cannot consider an application after it has been withdrawn.

If you want to apply for another visa, you will need to lodge a new application.

28    There followed a series of emails from the migration agent to the Department, remonstrating that Mr Khan’s visa application should be “reinstate[d]” and that the “deemed withdrawal” of Mr Khan’s visa application should be “set aside”.

Consideration

29    The evidence supports a finding that the migration agent made a mistake when he lodged the Withdrawal Notice on 1 August 2024. On the balance of probabilities, the subjective intention was to withdraw the visa application of Mr Khan’s former wife in her capacity as the secondary applicant, but to leave Mr Khan’s application on foot.

30    However, there is nothing ambiguous about the Withdrawal Notice. For the purpose of s 49(1) of the Act, it constitutes a written notice given to the Minister withdrawing the application that had been made by Mr Khan as the primary applicant. As an aside, it was ineffective to withdraw the application of Mr Khan’s former wife because the notice did not evidence her consent, however, that consent was later evidenced in May 2025.

31    Mr Khan submitted that the Withdrawal Notice was itself defective and therefore “invalid”. The defects were said to include the inclusion of the incorrect date (1 August 2014 rather than 1 August 2024), the absence of his former wife’s signature and the absence of any information under the heading “Part B – Authority to withdraw”. Those features do not alter my conclusion that Mr Khan had given written notice to the Minister withdrawing his own application. The inclusion of an incorrect date is immaterial to that question. The other “defects” meant that the Withdrawal Notice was ineffective to withdraw the visa application of Mr Khan’s former wife as the secondary applicant. They do not render the Withdrawal Notice ineffective to withdraw Mr Khan’s application. More importantly, the Act does not prescribe the manner or form in which written notice withdrawing a visa application may be given to the Minister. A communication will either meet the description in s 49 of the Act or not. No question of “validity” arises.

32    Next, it was submitted that the reason stated on the face of the Withdrawal Notice clearly indicated that it was only the application of Mr Khan’s former wife that was intended to be withdrawn. That was said to arise because the end of the marriage was a changed circumstance that could affect her (and only her) immigration status. I do not accept that submission. The inclusion of a reason for withdrawing an application is not a requirement for the giving of a written notice under s 49 of the Act. Nor is the end of the marriage a factual circumstance that changes the objective meaning of the other information contained in the form. Nor is it a factual situation uniquely and exclusively explaining the withdrawal of the application that had been made by Mr Khan’s former wife.

33    Mr Khan further submitted that the Withdrawal Notice could not be understood to mean that he had withdrawn his application given the content of the correspondence sent on his behalf to the Department the previous day. I do not accept that submission. The correspondence of 31 July 2024 supports a conclusion that on that day there existed a subjective intention to withdraw the application of Mr Khan’s wife but to keep his own application on foot. It also forms a part of my conclusion that the Withdrawal Notice was sent in error. However, the question of whether a visa application has been withdrawn requires no examination of the subjective intention of the visa applicant: Gillera at [55] – [62] (Thomas J). The Withdrawal Notice was clear in its meaning. It was sent by a person having authority to act as Mr Khan’s migration agent and he is bound by the migration agent’s actions irrespective of the subjective intentions of either of them.

34    The effect of those findings is that as and from 1 August 2024, the Minister had no obligation to decide Mr Khan’s visa application.

35    Mr Khan’s reliance on the subsequent correspondence is misplaced for three reasons.

36    First, there is nothing in the Act that enables a visa applicant (or the Minister for that matter) to re-enliven the obligation under s 47 of the Act to decide an application.

37    Second, to the extent that Mr Khan asserted that the subsequent correspondence gave rise to an estoppel precluding the Minister from denying the obligation to decide the application, the equitable principles of estoppel are inapplicable.

38    Third, if a representative of the Department later made an express or implied representation to the effect that Mr Khan’s visa application remained on foot, the subjective views of that person do not affect the question that arises under s 49 of the Act. In any event, I consider that the request for further information made on 26 May 2025 made it very plain that the requested information related to the then extant application of Mr Khan’s former wife. The communication contained an unequivocal statement that the Withdrawal Notice was effective to withdraw the application of Mr Khan.

39    Ground 2 has no merit.

40    It follows that the further amended originating application should be dismissed.

I certify that the preceding forty (40) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Justice Charlesworth.

Associate:

Dated:    20 November 2026