Federal Court of Australia

He v DC Rd DC Pty Ltd [2026] FCA 1746

File number(s):

NSD 280 of 2026

Judgment of:

NESKOVCIN J

Date of judgment:

11 November 2026

Date of publication of reasons:

17 November 2026

Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to vary freezing orders to allow sale of property – application granted subject to conditions

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to vary order for security for costs – insufficient evidence of material change in circumstances and lack of capacity to pay – issues with disclosure and candour with the Court in relation to the appellant’s financial position – application dismissed

Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 56

Cases cited:

Cai v DC Rd DC Proprietary Limited [2026] FCA 763

DC Rd DC Proprietary Limited v Zhang [2026] FCA 16

Truth About Motorways Proprietary Limited v Macquarie Infrastructure Investments Management Limited [2001] FCA 1603

Division:

General Division

Registry:

New South Wales

National Practice Area:

Commercial and Corporations

Sub-area:

Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance

Number of paragraphs:

30

Date of hearing:

11 November 2026

Counsel for the Appellant:

Mr A W Smith

Solicitor for the Appellant:

Mitry Emerson Lewis Lawyers

Counsel for the First to Fourth Respondents:

Mr C Colquhoun SC with Mr B Dziubinski

Solicitor for the First to Fourth Respondents:

Corrs Chambers Westgarth

ORDERS

NSD 280 of 2026

BETWEEN:

FAN (JOHN) HE

Appellant

AND:

DC RD DC PTY LTD ACN 634 893 459

First Respondent

STANLEY XUE

Second Respondent

SIT FAMILY PTY LTD ACN 617 947 065 (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

order made by:

NESKOVCIN J

DATE OF ORDER:

11 NOVEMBER 2026

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.    The parties are to submit a minute of proposed orders, or competing minutes if not agreed, to give effect to the reasons for judgment delivered orally by Justice Neskovcin on 11 November 2026 in relation to the appellant’s interlocutory application filed on 6 November 2026.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered ex tempore, revised from the transcript)

NESKOVCIN J:

1    On 23 January 2026, Jackman J delivered judgment in DC Rd DC Proprietary Limited v Zhang [2026] FCA 16 (Trial Judgment or TJ) and made final orders on 23 January 2026 (Trial Orders).

2    On 22 June 2026, I made orders further varying the freezing orders made by Jackman J on 25 August 2025 (varied on 27 August 2025, 11 September 2025 and 27 November 2025) (Freezing Orders) to increase the legal costs cap to allow the appellant to fund the appeal and to pay security for the respondents’ costs, and I also required the appellant to pay security for the respondents’ costs of the appeal. My reasons for doing so were published in Cai v DC Rd DC Proprietary Limited [2026] FCA 763 (June Judgment). Capitalised terms not otherwise defined have the meaning given to them in the June Judgment.

3    By interlocutory application filed on 6 November 2026, the appellant seeks orders to vary the Freezing Orders to enable him to sell a property situated at 45 Cherry Street, Warrawee, New South Wales, 2074 (Warrawee Property), and to vary the orders for security for costs of the appeal made on 22 June 2026 to reduce the amount of the security for costs of the appeal payable by the appellant from $185,000 to $85,000.

4    The appellant relied on affidavits of Stefano Calabretta, solicitor, sworn on 28 October 2026, together with exhibit SC-4, and 9 November 2026 and an affidavit of the appellant sworn on 5 November 2026. In addition, the appellant relied on a written outline of submissions and a document setting out a comparison of his asset and liability position as at 31 March 2026 and 5 November 2026. The appellant also tendered a number of documents separately into evidence.

5    The first to fourth respondents (the respondents) do not oppose the relief sought in paragraph 2 of the interlocutory application, which would permit the sale of the Warrawee Property, provided it is made on the conditions set out in the schedule to their written outline of submissions. The respondents otherwise oppose the application to reduce the amount of security for costs of the appeal.

6    The respondents relied on affidavits of Andrew Korbel, solicitor, affirmed on 27 March 2026 and 10 November 2026, and an affidavit of Mr Korbel filed in proceeding NSD 247 of 2023, affirmed on 5 November 2026, together with exhibit AHJK-3. In addition, at the hearing, the respondents tendered two emails dated 7 September 2026 and 11 November 2026 regarding the payment of funds into Court by way of security for the respondents’ costs.

Variation of the Freezing Orders

7    As already mentioned, the respondents do not oppose the variation which the appellant seeks to the Freezing Orders, provided it is made on the conditions set out in the schedule to their written outline of submissions. The conditions relevantly include that the purchase price be not less than a specified sum, that the respondents receive prior notice of any offers, exchange of contract or settlement of the sale of the Warrawee Property and in relation to the disbursement of the proceeds of sale.

8    In relation to the first condition sought by the respondents, namely, that the purchase price be not less than a specified sum, there is no evidence before the Court that a sale at that price is achievable. The appellant relied on a confidential valuation of the property and has recently received an offer for less than the respondents’ suggested amount. It is in the appellant’s interest to achieve the highest possible price, and in light of the evidence regarding attempts to sell the property, the variation to the Freezing Orders should include a condition that the purchase price be not less than the sum suggested by the appellant.

9    After payment of disbursements relating to his mortgage to National Australia Bank (NAB) in relation to the Warrawee Property, agent’s commission and bona fide transaction costs, the respondents submitted that the balance of the proceeds of sale should be paid into an interest-bearing account with the Court, pending the determination of the appeal or further order.

10    The appellant, on the other hand, submitted that the proceeds of sale should also be applied towards payment of the appellant’s legal costs, which are owing and secured by the terms of charges contained in costs agreements which the appellant has entered into with his solicitors.

11    It is one thing for there to be an exception to a freezing order to permit a person to incur legal costs in connection with the proceeding in which the freezing order is made or in respect of an appeal. It is another thing whether there should be an exception to a freezing order to permit a person to sell or encumber property which is otherwise the subject of the freezing order.

12    There has been no consideration as to whether the costs agreements containing the charges to secure appellant’s legal costs should properly be excluded from, or the subject of an exception to, the Freezing Orders. To permit the proceeds of sale of the Warrawee Property to be disbursed in payment of the appellant’s legal costs seems to bypass that step, which, as I have already mentioned, has not been considered. I am therefore not satisfied that the proceeds of sale should be disbursed to pay the appellant’s legal costs, as opposed to being paid into Court.

Variation of the security for costs order

13    By orders made on 22 June 2026, the appellant was required to pay $185,000 in security for costs of the appeal in four monthly tranches commencing on 3 August 2026.

14    The appellant has paid $85,000 of that amount.

15    The appellant has filed written submissions, but has not filed reply submissions which were due on 30 August 2026. The appeal is listed for three days commencing on 17 November 2026. By reason of the appellant’s failure to provide security for costs as required on 3 October 2026 and 3 November 2026, the appeal has been stayed.

16    Section 56(3) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) provides that the Court or a judge may reduce or increase the amount of security ordered to be given and may vary the time at which, or manner or form in which, the security is to be given.

17    As Hely J stated in Truth About Motorways Proprietary Limited v Macquarie Infrastructure Investments Management Limited [2001] FCA 1603, at [11] – [13], an application to set aside, vary or discharge an order of a substantive nature made after a contested hearing in contemplation that it would operate until final disposition of the proceeding, must be founded on a material change of circumstances since the original application was heard, subject to the overriding principle that the Court should do whatever the interests of justice require in the particular circumstances of the case.

18    The appellant submitted that his financial position has deteriorated significantly since 31 March 2026, largely due to a decline in the estimated value of the Warrawee Property and other liabilities that were not disclosed at the time the security for costs orders were made on 22 June 2026.

19    Nevertheless, as submitted by the respondents, the appellant has simply asserted that his income has declined steeply. There is no evidence before the Court in support of that assertion, setting out what his income is and was, or that of his company, Q B I Service Australia Pty Ltd, notwithstanding that the respondents sought that evidence on 19 October 2026.

20    Harvest Land Group Pty Ltd, now known as Harvestland Construction Pty Ltd, is a company that the appellant and Tony established (see TJ at [247]) and of which they were, until recently, directors. Since March 2026, Harvestland has lent the appellant $43,000 on 16 March 2026, $50,000 on 21 April 2026, and $60,000 on 4 May 2026. In addition, Harvestland paid $8,800 for the valuation of the Warrawee Property on or about 3 September 2026.

21    Harvestland also paid the sum of $50,000 into Court on 4 September 2026 on behalf of the appellant and the sum of $50,000 into Court on 11 November 2026 on behalf of the Tony Corporate Parties, by way of security for the respondents’ costs.

22    There is no evidence before the Court regarding Harvestland’s financial position and no suggestion that Harvestland is unwilling or unable to lend a further sum to pay the remaining security for costs. Furthermore, the appellant has not explained the source of the first sum that was paid into Court by way of security for costs, being the sum of $35,000 paid on 3 August 2026.

23    The respondents submitted that on 5 October 2026, two days after the third tranche of security was to be paid, $35,000 was transferred from the appellant’s NAB offset account to a “linked account” that was not in evidence. The Court was told by the appellant’s counsel that that account is not in the appellant’s name. However, the Court was not told the name of the account holder of the “linked account”, and there was no explanation as to why, or whether, that sum was or was not available by way of security for costs.

24    There is also an issue regarding the appellant’s disclosure to and candour with the Court. I will give the appellant the benefit of the doubt regarding the $900,000 business loan and the guarantee in relation to Pleasant Land No 2 Pty Ltd’s debt, which were not previously disclosed to the Court.

25    On 8 September 2025, the appellant deposed (emphasis added):

I have not made the child support payments owing under the Child Support Agreement this year. I will need to make this payment before the end of November 2025. Subject to orders of this Court to make a lump sum payment of $100,000 I will make that payment immediately.

26    By order 4 made on 11 September 2025, by consent of the parties, the Freezing Orders were varied to allow the appellant to make a lump sum payment of $100,000 for child support. The appellant’s counsel told the Court that this order was sought to avoid the appellant breaching a child support agreement. However, in the appellant’s affidavit sworn on 5 November 2026, the appellant said that he is in arrears of child support in the sum of $200,000, being the amount owed over the last two years.

27    The second matter concerns the charges granted by the appellant to his solicitors under costs agreements made on 2 March 2026 and 14 May 2026 in respect of the appeal, which were only disclosed in the appellant’s affidavit of 5 November 2026. Counsel for the appellant (who was unaware of the charges until recently) also indicated that, to the best of his knowledge, the earlier costs agreement dated 30 January 2025 was not disclosed prior to Jackman J making the Freezing Orders.

28    As a result, I am not satisfied that it is in the interests of justice to vary the order for security for costs. As stated in the June Judgment at [115] – [117], the order for security for costs was to alleviate the unfairness, or the potential unfairness, to the respondents caused by the stay of the Trial Orders because of the potential deterioration in the appellant’s position and the respondents’ exposure to costs in the event that the appeal was unsuccessful. The appellant has not established that the order for security will stultify the appeal or that it is appropriate to vary the security for costs orders which were intended to remain in place until the completion of the appeal.

Conclusion

29    There will be an order varying the Freezing Orders, subject to the following conditions:

(i)    the Warrawee Property be sold for a purchase price of not less than $15,750,000;

(ii)    the appellant provide two working days’ notice to the first to fourth respondents prior to the exchange of any contract of sale of the Warrawee Property after 11 November 2026, including a copy of the proposed contract of sale;

(iii)    the appellant provide two working days’ notice to the first to fourth respondents prior to any amendment of any exchanged contract of sale of the Warrawee Property;

(iv)    the appellant provide two working days’ notice to the first to fourth respondents of any intention on his part to rescind or terminate any exchanged contract of sale of the Warrawee Property;

(v)    the appellant provide five working days’ notice to the first to fourth respondents of the anticipated date for settlement of any exchanged contract of sale of the Warrawee Property and provide a copy of the payment directions for settlement at least two working days prior to the scheduled settlement date;

(vi)    the proceeds of sale of the Warrawee Property be applied in the following manner, to pay:

(A)    the loan necessary to discharge the mortgage to NAB with dealing number AR250163, registered on the title for the Warrawee Property;

(B)    the commission and expenses of Ray White North Shore, the selling agent for the Warrawee Property; and

(C)    the bona fide expenses ordinarily and reasonably incurred on settlement of the Warrawee Property, including but not limited to PEXA fees, conveyancing fees of no more than $5,500 inclusive of GST, or such other amount as agreed by the parties or ordered by the Court, and outgoing adjustments for water rates, council rates and other similar expenses; and

(vii)    the balance of any sale proceeds from the sale of the Warrawee Property after payment of the amounts allowed for in paragraph (vi) are to be paid into an interest-bearing account with the Court, pending the determination of the appeal or further order.

30    The appellant’s interlocutory application will otherwise be dismissed. Subject to hearing from the parties, there is no reason why the appellant should not pay the respondents’ costs of the interlocutory application. Also subject to hearing from the parties, the only order I will make today will be that the parties submit a minute of order, or competing minutes if not agreed, to give effect to these reasons as there may need to be some consideration to the form of the order.

I certify that the preceding thirty (30) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Justice Neskovcin.

Associate:

Dated:    17 November 2026

SCHEDULE OF PARTIES

NSD 280 of 2026

Respondents

Fourth Respondent:

FAI KEUNG (PHILLIP) SIT

Fifth Respondent:

DONG (TONY) ZHANG

Sixth Respondent:

ZHENGJUN (BOB) CAI

Seventh Respondent:

CENTRAL ADVISORY GROUP PTY LIMITED ACN 163 958 843

Eighth Respondent:

CHARM TEAM DEVELOPMENT LIMITED CR NO. 2249958

Ninth Respondent:

LINK INVESTMENTS LIMITED CR NO. 2871791

Tenth Respondent:

CENTRAL ADVISORY CAPITAL PTY LTD ACN 621 169 015

Eleventh Respondent:

CENTRAL ADVISORY GROUP ASIA LIMITED CR NO. 2367749

Twelfth Respondent:

BELROSE COB PTY LTD ACN 640 327 153

Thirteenth Respondent:

CENTRAL ACCOUNTING AND TAXATION ADVISORY PTY LTD ACN 161 148 572

Fourteenth Respondent:

LIAN LI

Fifteenth Respondent:

SAIALA HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 648 681 930

Sixteenth Respondent:

CLARENCE 104 PTY LTD ACN 653 506 640

Seventeenth Respondent:

SMITHFIELD 40 PTY LTD ACN 654 991 063

Eighteenth Respondent:

DSZ ACCOUNTANTS PTY LTD ACN 161 148 545