Federal Court of Australia
Peet Limited, in the matter of Peet Limited [2026] FCA 1741
File number: | WAD 399 of 2026 |
Judgment of: | COLVIN J |
Date of judgment: | 3 November 2026 |
Date of publication of reasons: | 16 November 2026 |
Catchwords: | CORPORATIONS - scheme of arrangement – first court hearing - application under s 411(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for company to convene a meeting to consider a scheme of arrangement – consideration of factors relevant to the exercise of Court's discretion to order a meeting – consideration of aspects of scheme that contemplate establishment of a joint venture between bidder and an associate of a shareholder in Peet to be known as Flagstone joint venture – orders made in terms sought for convening of shareholders' meeting – supplementary disclosure regularised by order |
Legislation: | Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 411, 411(2), 411(17) |
Cases cited: | Allkem Limited, in the matter of Allkem Limited [2023] FCA 1397 Amcom Telecommunications Limited, in the matter of Amcom Telecommunications Limited (No 2) [2015] FCA 410 DDH1 Limited, in the matter of DDH1 Limited [2023] FCA 982 Essential Metals Limited, in the matter of Essential Metals Limited [2023] FCA 1101 OreCorp Limited, in the matter of OreCorp Limited [2023] FCA 1359 |
Division: | General Division |
Registry: | Western Australia |
National Practice Area: | Commercial and Corporations |
Sub-area: | Corporations and Corporate Insolvency |
Number of paragraphs: | 20 |
Date of hearing: | 3 November 2026 |
Counsel for the Plaintiff: | Mr SK Dharmananda SC |
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: | Clayton Utz |
Counsel for the Interested Party: | Mr A Papamatheos SC |
Solicitor for the Interested Party: | Gilbert + Tobin |
ORDERS
IN THE MATTER OF PEET LIMITED | WAD 399 of 2026 | |
| ||
BETWEEN: | PEET LIMITED ACN 008 665 834 Plaintiff INGENIA COMMUNITIES HOLDINGS LTD ABN 154 444 925 Interested Party | |
order made by: | COLVIN J |
DATE OF ORDER: | 3 November 2026 |
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1. Pursuant to section 411(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act), the plaintiff is to convene and hold a meeting of its shareholders (Scheme Meeting):
(a) for the purpose of considering and, if thought fit, agreeing (with or without amendment) to a scheme of arrangement (Scheme) proposed to be made between the plaintiff and its shareholders (Shareholders), substantially in the form of annexure "SN-16" at pages 369 – 401 to the second affidavit of Stephen Wei Liang Neale sworn on 30 October 2026 (Second Neale Affidavit); and
(b) to be held in person at 9.00 am AWST on Monday 7 December 2026 at the Parmelia Hilton Perth Hotel, 14 Mill Street, Perth, Western Australia.
2. Pursuant to section 411(1) of the Corporations Act, the Scheme Booklet, which contains the explanatory statement required by section 412(1)(a) of the Corporations Act, is approved for distribution to Shareholders, substantially in the form of annexure "SN-13" to the Second Neale Affidavit, together with annexures "SN-15" and "SN-16", and annexure "SN-17" to the third affidavit of Stephen Wei Liang Neale sworn on 2 November 2026, subject to:
(a) correction of any typographical or grammatical errors and final typesetting, formatting and page numbering;
(b) any minor amendments requested or approved by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) for registration under subsection 412(6) of the Corporations Act;
(c) the correction or update of relevant dates or market price references and consequential amendments; and
(d) effecting any other amendments approved by the Court.
3. Subject to these orders and pursuant to section 1319 of the Corporations Act, the Scheme Meeting is to be:
(a) convened, held and conducted in accordance with the provisions of Part 2G.2 of the Corporations Act that apply to members of a company and the provisions of the plaintiff's constitution, provided at annexure "DS-1" to the affidavit of Domenico Scafetta sworn on 23 October 2026 (Scafetta Affidavit), that apply to meetings of members that are not inconsistent with Part 2G.2 of the Corporations Act;
(b) convened using the notice of scheme meeting substantially in the form of the Notice of Scheme Meeting contained in Annexure E of the Scheme Booklet, being part of annexure "SN-13" to the Second Neale Affidavit at pages 205 – 209 (with any necessary amendments contemplated by paragraph 2 above) (Notice of Scheme Meeting);
(c) held and conducted pursuant to the arrangements for attending, participating and voting described in the Notice of Scheme Meeting and in accordance with the provisions of Part 2G.2 of the Corporations Act (Meeting Arrangements); and
(d) convened, held and conducted as if rule 2.15 of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) (Rules) does not apply.
4. Pursuant to section 1319 of the Corporations Act:
(a) Gregory Wall AM, Independent Non-Executive Chairman of the plaintiff, or failing him, Margaret Kennedy, Independent Non-Executive Director of the plaintiff, is the chairperson of the Scheme Meeting (Chairperson);
(b) the Chairperson have power to adjourn or postpone the Scheme Meeting in the Chairperson's absolute discretion for such time, date and place that the Chairperson thinks appropriate;
(c) at the Scheme Meeting, five or more Shareholders entitled to vote, present in person or by proxy or by attorney, or by a corporate representative (if applicable), shall constitute a quorum;
(d) at the Scheme Meeting, each Shareholder, present and entitled to vote, is entitled to one vote for each fully paid ordinary share in the capital of the plaintiff, that the Shareholder is registered as holding at 4.00 pm AWST on 5 December 2026; and
(e) at the Scheme Meeting, voting on the resolution on whether to approve the Scheme is to be conducted by way of a poll (declared by the Chairperson).
5. Subject to registration of the Scheme Booklet with ASIC pursuant to sections 412(6), 411(1) and 1319 of the Corporations Act, the Scheme Meeting must be convened by the plaintiff sending on or before Thursday 5 November 2026 the following materials to each Shareholder who appears on the plaintiff's register of members as at 4.00 pm AWST on 30 October 2026 (Register Time):
(a) in the case of each Shareholder who has elected to receive shareholder communications from the plaintiff electronically (Email Shareholders), an email which includes access by embedded links to:
(i) an electronic copy of the Scheme Booklet (which contains a copy of the Notice of Scheme Meeting); and
(ii) an electronic copy of the proxy form and the election form, substantially in the form annexed to the first affidavit of Stephen Wei Liang Neale sworn on 12 October 2026 (First Neale Affidavit) as annexure "SN-9" at pages 706 – 711;
(b) in the case of each Shareholder who has elected to receive shareholder communications from the plaintiff by post (Postal Shareholders), using the methods of service set out in paragraph 6 of these orders, the following documents by post:
(i) a hard copy of the Scheme Booklet (which contains a copy of the Notice of Scheme Meeting);
(ii) an access letter containing instructions on how to access a copy of the Scheme Booklet, the proxy form and the election form (Notice of Access);
(iii) a personalised proxy form;
(iv) a personalised election form; and
(v) a reply paid envelope for Australian Shareholders and a self-addressed envelope for Shareholders outside of Australia; and
(c) in the case of each Shareholder who is not an Email Shareholder or a Postal Shareholder (Non-Electing Shareholders), using the methods of service set out in paragraph 6 of these orders:
(i) the Notice of Access;
(ii) a personalised proxy form;
(iii) a personalised election form; and
(iv) a reply paid envelope for Australian Shareholders and a self-addressed envelope for Shareholders outside of Australia.
6. The plaintiff must dispatch the documents identified in paragraphs 5(b) and 5(c) above:
(a) to each Shareholder who has a registered address in Australia, by pre-paid ordinary post to their registered address as recorded at the Register Time; and
(b) to each other Shareholder who has a registered address outside Australia, by pre-paid international airmail to their registered address as recorded at the Register Time.
7. If it comes to the attention of the plaintiff (through its share registry services provider, Computershare) that any email dispatched in accordance with paragraph 5(a) results in the return of a receipt or notice that the email was undelivered, then the plaintiff must dispatch to that Shareholder within a reasonable time thereafter the documents referred to in paragraph 5(c) of these orders.
8. The plaintiff shall, on or before the date of dispatch referred to in paragraph 5, make the Scheme Booklet available on its website at www.peet. com.au and lodge a copy of the Scheme Booklet with ASX for release on the ASX market announcements platform.
9. Dispatch of the documents referred to above, in accordance with the terms of these orders, shall be taken to be sufficient notice of the Scheme Meeting.
10. The plaintiff is not obliged to send documents in relation to the Scheme to any person who becomes a Shareholder after the Register Time.
11. The time by which Shareholders must return their proxy form (or lodge an electronic proxy) in respect of the Scheme Meeting is 9.00 am AWST on 5 December 2026.
12. The plaintiff is to give notice of the hearing of any application pursuant to section 411(4) and, if necessary, section 411(6) of the Corporations Act for orders approving the Scheme (Second Court Hearing), by publishing notice of the hearing via the ASX market announcements platform, substantially in the form of annexure "SN-12" to the Second Neale Affidavit, which announcement is to be published on the plaintiff's website at www.peet.com.au, with such announcement to be released at least five days before the Second Court Hearing, and the plaintiff is otherwise relieved from compliance with rule 3.4 of the Rules.
13. The proceeding is adjourned to 15 December 2026 at 10.15 am AWST.
14. The plaintiff have liberty to apply upon giving 24 hours' notice to ASIC.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
COLVIN J:
1 Peet Limited is a public company listed on the ASX. It sought orders to convene a meeting for its shareholders to consider a scheme of arrangement by which Ingenia Communities Holdings Limited would acquire all of the shares in Peet. I determined that orders as sought should be made. As is usual, those orders provide for a further hearing to be conducted after a meeting of shareholders has been convened in accordance with those orders (Second Hearing) at which time the Court will consider whether to approve the scheme. These are my reasons for the making of the orders to convene a meeting of the shareholders in Peet.
The Court's discretion
2 The Court has a discretion conferred by s 411 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to order that a meeting be convened to consider a scheme. The operation of s 411 was explained by Jackson J in Essential Metals Limited, in the matter of Essential Metals Limited [2023] FCA 1101 at [8]-[13] in terms that I respectfully adopt. I summarised the Court's role when considering the exercise of the discretion in OreCorp Limited, in the matter of OreCorp Limited [2023] FCA 1359 at [10]‑[13]. As Banks‑Smith J stated in Allkem Limited, in the matter of Allkem Limited [2023] FCA 1397 at [27]:
In summary, the standard of review is whether the proposed scheme is not inappropriate and is one that sensible business people might consider is of benefit to its members. It is not necessary for the Court to descend into the commercial merits of the proposed scheme. If the proposed arrangement is one that seems fit for consideration by a meeting of members and is a commercial proposition likely to gain the Court's approval if passed by the necessary majority, then leave should be given to convene the meeting.
Key features of Peet and of the proposed Scheme
3 Peet is a property and land development company. It holds parcels of land at locations across Australia. Some are in the process of active development with individual lots for sale. One such development in Queensland is known as Flagstone. It appears to account for a significant part of the overall shareholder value within Peet.
4 Insignia is an integrated owner, operator and developer of residential communities and holiday parks. It too is listed on the ASX.
5 The scheme proposes a 'mix-and-match facility' by which shareholders may elect to receive cash consideration of $0.68 per share or scrip consideration of 0.3367 new Insignia securities per share. There are caps that apply to the share and scrip consideration such that not all shareholders can accept on an all share or all scrip consideration basis. If elections exceed either cap then the elections will be scaled back on a pro rata basis. Also, the cash consideration may be reduced by the extent to which any half-year dividend exceeds a specified cap. The new Insignia securities will be fully paid and rank equally with existing securities on issue.
6 Kroll Australia, an independent expert has concluded that the scheme is fair and reasonable and in the best interests of Peet shareholders, in the absence of a superior proposal. The scheme is unanimously supported by the directors of Peet.
7 On the evidence, there is no reason to expect that the conditions precedent to the scheme will not be met. One of those conditions precedent concerns the entry into a document described as the Flagstone JV Implementation Deed. It concerns a proposal to be implemented if the scheme proceeds. It is a proposal for the establishment of a joint venture in respect of the Flagstone development. Under the terms of the proposal, Insignia will enter into a joint venture with Bechel Pty Ltd. The joint venture will provide for a 50/50 distribution of profits, although Insignia will have marginally more than a 50% joint venture interest (and Bechel marginally less). Bechel will make a financial contribution to Insignia as part of the establishment of the joint venture and will assume joint responsibilities for financing associated with the joint venture. In consequence, the debt exposure of the merged entity associated with the development will be reduced.
8 Bechel's financial contribution to the Flagstone joint venture is based upon an agreed inventory value of $615 million for the land that is to be sold to buyers as part of the Flagstone development. The inventory value is greater by approximately $368 million over Peet's book value for that land. Based on that inventory value, Bechel will contribute $187.1 million in cash to the joint venture and assume its share of liability to fund the venture (and risk associated with the Flagstone project). These matters are disclosed in the scheme booklet to be dispatched to the shareholders in Peet before the meeting to consider the scheme.
Hurose Pty Ltd and Flagstone
9 Hurose, an entity controlled by Mr Garry Brown-Neaves holds approximately 2.18% of Peet shares. Bechel is also controlled by Mr Brown-Neaves. Therefore, by reason of Bechel's interest in the proposed Flagstone joint venture to be established if the scheme proceeds, there is a commercial interest in the scheme proceeding on the part of an associate of Hurose, namely Bechel. However, Hurose's rights and interests as a shareholder in Peet are the same as any other shareholder. In those circumstances, I accepted the submission for Peet that there were no class issues raised by the arrangements to establish the proposed Flagstone joint venture. I did so on the basis that Peet intended to identify in the report from the chairperson of the outcome of the meeting to be convened to consider the scheme, how the shares held by Hurose (and any other entity associated through Mr Brown-Neaves) were voted. This was to be done for the purpose of having that evidence before the Court at the Second Hearing for consideration as to whether it might bear upon whether the Court should approve the scheme, assuming the scheme receives the support of a majority of shareholders.
10 On the hearing of the application, senior counsel for Peet confirmed that Hurose did not have any association with Peet or its officers.
Matters established on the application
11 Having reviewed the affidavits, particularly the draft scheme booklet, and written submissions in support of the application I was satisfied that:
(1) Peet is a Part 5.1 body;
(2) the Scheme is proposed between Peet and its shareholders;
(3) the required company search had been undertaken;
(4) the Scheme can be properly described as an arrangement;
(5) the Scheme is bona fide and properly proposed;
(6) the 14 day notice period to ASIC under s 411(2)(a) of the Corporations Act of the court hearing was satisfied;
(7) having regard to the matters I described in DDH1 Limited, in the matter of DDH1 Limited [2023] FCA 982 at [17]-[22], the scheme booklet provides adequate disclosure and contains the prescribed information and, on the evidence, appropriate steps appear to have been taken to ensure that the information has been properly verified;
(8) as I explain below, no issues arise which require votes to be taken on the basis of separate classes of shareholders;
(9) ASIC has had a reasonable opportunity to examine the terms of the Scheme and the scheme booklet, and to make any submissions to the Court;
(10) ASIC did not make submissions or intervene to oppose the scheme at the hearing, noting that the letter from ASIC that was before the Court stated that ASIC will provide a statement for the purposes of s 411(17)(b) of the Corporations Act at the Second Hearing;
(11) the required matters have been proven in respect of the proposed chair and alternative chair for the shareholder meeting to consider the Scheme;
(12) issues in relation to performance risk were addressed by mechanisms that are usual and appropriate; and
(13) on the basis explained below, the Scheme was of a kind that was fit for consideration in the sense that if it received the requisite majorities the Court was likely to approve the scheme at a further hearing.
Particular matters for consideration in the present case
12 In deciding whether to exercise the discretion to approve the Scheme, I considered the following particular matters.
13 Senior Counsel for Peet identified matters of significance as to the terms of the scheme booklet that had been raised by ASIC and the respects in which the booklet had been amended to deal with those matters. Having considered those matters, I formed the view that they did not give rise to any reason as to why the orders to convene the meeting of shareholders on the basis of the scheme booklet should not be made.
14 The scheme booklet included information in respect of the status of current competing takeover bids for shares in Ingenia. Although market announcements had been made by Ingenia as to the course of those events, summaries were included in the scheme booklet. At the time of the hearing there had been further developments. I made orders on the basis that those orders contemplated that the most recent information at the time of the hearing would be included in the scheme booklet (by way of further amendment to the version before the Court at the hearing).
15 At the hearing, I raised an issue as to whether the expert report by Kroll Australia had been prepared on the basis of a value for the Flagstone development that was consistent with the terms of the agreement to be entered into between Ingenia and Bechel. I did so on the basis that, in broad terms, the Flagstone development appeared to account for a considerable part of the shareholder value in Peet. It appeared that the Kroll Australia report had been prepared on the basis of a discounted cash flow basis that did not consider separately the value of each development that formed part of the portfolio of land assets held by Peet. Further, it was submitted that the information in the scheme booklet enabled shareholders in Peet to see the importance of the Flagstone joint venture and gave Peet's interest a measurable value by reason of the information as to the valuation of the inventory and the cash amount to be contributed by Bechel to obtain a 50% share in the profits to be derived. However, it was explained that the Kroll Australia report did not enable a comparison with some assessment of value of the Flagstone development in the hands of Peet because that specific valuation task was not the subject of report. Nevertheless, the submission was advanced that Kroll Australia had undertaken the whole of business analysis and was satisfied that the offer from Ingenia was fair and reasonable and in the best interests of Peet shareholders, in the absence of a superior proposal.
16 In the result, I determined to proceed on the basis that further information would be provided at the Second Hearing that addressed specifically whether the available information as to the nature and terms of the Flagstone transaction between Bechel and Ingenia called into question in any material respect the whole of business valuation approach undertaken by Kroll Australia. I did so on the basis that, in substance, the scheme booklet was presenting the proposed scheme to shareholders on the basis that there was nothing about the characteristics of the Flagstone transaction that called into question the conclusion reached by Kroll Australia.
Other matters to be addressed at the Second Hearing
17 I noted that the written submissions for Peet also identified the following matters which may be addressed at the Second Hearing:
(1) How the Peet shares held by Hurose (and any other Brown-Neaves Investments entity) were voted at the meeting to consider the proposed scheme;
(2) Updates to the market as to the progress of satisfaction of conditions precedent; and
(3) Noting that scripts had been prepared to deal with inquiries and a decision had not been made on whether to engage with proxy advisors, material departures from scripts and any other relevant events concerning the procedures for dealing with shareholding inquiries would be updated.
A further order
18 On 13 November 2026, I made a further order approving the dispatch of a short letter to shareholders referring to an ASX announcement made on 6 November 2026. The announcement confirmed that Ingenia, Bechel and Hurose (as Bechel's guarantor) had entered into an implementation deed for a joint venture over the Flagstone development. The notice was consistent with the information in the scheme booklet. It contained an additional piece of information which was to the effect that Peet had agreed to contribute an amount of $1 million to Bechel for its costs in negotiating and committing to the Flagstone joint venture. It stated that the contribution was to be paid if the scheme was terminated in circumstances where Ingenia was liable to pay an agreed break fee to Peet and the Flagstone joint venture agreement had not been terminated.
19 It was proposed that the information would be provided to shareholders in the same manner as provided by the orders for the scheme booklet and that would be done on or before 16 November 2026, being at least 10 days before the shareholder meeting to be convened in accordance with the orders.
20 Having regard to the reasoning of McKerracher J in Amcom Telecommunications Limited, in the matter of Amcom Telecommunications Limited (No 2) [2015] FCA 410, I was persuaded that it was appropriate for the supplementary information to be provided by way of letter and that the nature of the information was such that it was unlikely that decisions that had been made to confer proxies would be invalidated by the fact that such information was provided. Further, there was sufficient time for the information to be considered by shareholders and for proxies to be withdrawn. Therefore, it was also appropriate to make an order as to the validity of proxy forms that had been provided to put the position beyond doubt.
I certify that the preceding twenty (20) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Justice Colvin. |
Associate:
Dated: 16 November 2026