Federal Court of Australia

Appleton and Cooper, in the matter of EV Metals Group PLC (Administrators Appointed) [2026] FCA 1726

File number:

WAD 276 of 2026

Judgment of:

JACKSON J

Date of judgment:

13 November 2026

Date of publication of reasons:

16 November 2026

Catchwords:

BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY – cross-border insolvency – application under the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency for recognition of the administration of the defendant in the United Kingdom as a foreign main proceeding and for plaintiffs to be recognised as foreign representatives of the defendant within the meaning of Art 2(b) and 2(d) of the Model Law –proceeding satisfies requirements to be recognised as a foreign proceeding – insufficient evidence to displace the rebuttable presumption that the United Kingdom is the defendant’s centre of main interests – proceeding satisfies requirements to be recognised as a foreign main proceeding – orders made recognising proceeding in High Court of England and Wales as the foreign main proceeding – order made recognising the plaintiffs as foreign representatives

Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth)

Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth) ss 6, 10, 13, 16

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 9, 416, 601CL

Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) rr 15A.3,

15A.6

Insolvency Act 1986 (UK) Sch B1

Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law Arts 2, 4, 15, 17, 20

Cases cited:

Ackers (as Joint Foreign Representative) v Saad Investments Co Ltd (in Official Liquidation) (a Co Registered in the Cayman Islands) [2010] FCA 1221; (2010) 190 FCR 285

Bankruptcy Office of Canton of Geneva (Trustee) v Amoma SARL (In Liq), Amoma SARL (No 2) [2023] FCA 1379

Bradley, Re Astora Women’s Health, LLC v Astora Women’s Health, LLC (No 2) [2022] FCA 1268

De’ath (liquidator) v Digital Fuel Marketing Limited (in administration), Re Digital Fuel Marketing Limited (in administration) [2022] FCA 470

Gainsford v Tannenbaum [2012] FCA 904; (2012) 216 FCR 543

Kapila, Re Edelsten [2014] FCA 1112

Kellow, Re Advanced Building & Construction Limited (in liq) v Advanced Building & Construction Limited (in liq) (No 2) [2022] FCA 781

King, Re Zetta Jet Pte Ltd [2018] FCA 1932

Laverty v Greensill Capital (UK) Limited (in administration), Re Greensill Capital (UK) Limited (in administration) [2023] FCA 721

Moore as Debtor-in-Possession of Australian Equity Investors v Australian Equity Investors [2012] FCA 1002

Re Aero Inventory (UK) Limited (No 2) [2009] FCA 1481; (2009) 181 FCR 674

Re Eurofood IFSC Ltd [2006] Ch 508

Wood v Astra Resources Ltd (UK Company No 07620218) [2016] FCA 1192

Young, Jr, Re Buccaneer Energy Limited v Buccaneer Energy Limited [2014] FCA 711

Division:

General Division

Registry:

Western Australia

National Practice Area:

Commercial and Corporations

Sub-area:

Corporations and Corporate Insolvency

Number of paragraphs:

66

Date of hearing:

20 October 2026

Counsel for the Plaintiffs:

Mr T Darbyshire with Ms R Carpenter

Solicitor for the Plaintiffs:

Anderson James

Counsel for the Defendant:

The defendant did not appear

ORDERS

WAD 276 of 2026

IN THE MATTER OF EV METALS GROUP PLC

BETWEEN:

PAUL ROBERT APPLETON AND PAUL STEVEN COOPER IN THEIR CAPACITIES AS THE JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF EV METALS GROUP PLC

Plaintiffs

AND:

EV METALS GROUP PLC

Defendant

order made by:

JACKSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

13 NOVEMBER 2026

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.    Pursuant to s 17(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and r 1.36 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), these orders and reasons for judgment are made and published from Chambers.

2.    Pursuant to Art 15 and Art 17(2)(a) of the Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (Model Law), proceeding CR-2026-004256 in the High Court of Justice (Business and Property Courts of England and Wales) is recognised as a foreign main proceeding within the meaning of Art 2(b) of the Model Law, by reason of which:

(a)    commencement or continuation of individual actions or individual proceedings concerning the defendant’s assets, rights, obligations or liabilities is stayed;

(b)    execution against the defendant’s assets is stayed; and

(c)    the right to transfer, encumber or otherwise dispose of any assets of the defendant is suspended.

3.    The scope of the stay referred to in paragraph 2 above is the same as would apply if the defendant were a company under administration pursuant to Part 5.3A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

4.    Paul Robert Appleton and Paul Steven Cooper are recognised as the foreign representatives of the defendant within the meaning of Art 2(d) of the Model Law.

5.    Liberty to apply.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JACKSON J:

1    The plaintiffs, Paul Robert Appleton and Paul Steven Cooper, are the administrators of the defendant, EV Metals Group PLC, appointed under the Insolvency Act 1986 (UK). They apply under the Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (Model Law) for orders recognising that United Kingdom administration as a foreign main proceeding for the purposes of Art 2(b), Art 15 and Art 17(2)(a) of the Model Law. In broad terms, the principal effect of such recognition will be to stay claims and proceedings against EV Metals in Australia. The Model Law has force of law in Australia by reason of s 6 of the Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth) (CBI Act). The plaintiffs also seek orders that, as administrators of EV Metals in the United Kingdom, they be recognised as the foreign representatives of the company in Australia within the meaning of Art 2(d), pursuant to Art 15 and Art 17(2)(b).

2    EV Metals is a company incorporated in the UK, and is registered as a foreign company in Australia. The plaintiffs were appointed as its administrators on 1 June 2026, pursuant to a resolution of the directors of the company under Schedule B1 of the Insolvency Act.

3    Section 10 of the CBI Act provides that the Federal Court of Australia (among others) is taken to be specified in Art 4 of the Model Law as a court competent to perform the functions relating to the recognition of foreign proceedings.

4    For the following reasons, orders as sought by the plaintiffs will be made.

The EV Group

5    EV Metals is the parent company of a corporate group (EV Group). Among its subsidiaries are Riwaq Al Mawarid Company for Mining and EV Metals Arabia Company for Industry, which are corporations located and registered in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. EV Metals holds 90% and 100% of the shares in those companies respectively. It also has Australian subsidiaries, eight of which are currently under administration pursuant to Part 5.3A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Australian Companies). Clifford Rocke and Jimmy Trpcevski of WA Insolvency Solutions are the administrators of the Australian Companies. EV Metals is the sole shareholder and a substantial creditor of each of the Australian Companies.

6    The plaintiffs describe the EV Group as being involved in the production and processing of minerals required for the manufacturing of rechargeable batteries. Prior to the administrations of EV Metals and the Australian Companies, the EV Group was also engaged in the development of a lithium processing plant in Saudi Arabia, to which I will return below.

7    According to the plaintiffs, the principal purpose of seeking recognition in Australia of the UK administration is to ensure a coordinated approach between the UK administrators, the Australian administrators and the Saudi subsidiaries, in order to protect the assets of EV Metals for the benefit of the creditors and other stakeholders of the EV Group.

8    The plaintiffs have also undertaken a sale campaign for the assets of EV Metals. An affidavit of Benjamin Edward Darbyshire affirmed on 9 November 2026 says that a sale agreement has been executed and proceeds received into a trust account managed by the plaintiffs for the purpose of the administration of the defendant.

Service on potentially interested parties

9    On 26 August 2026, I made ex parte orders addressing the requirements for service of the originating process and supporting affidavit pursuant to r 15A.3(4) of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) (Corporations Rules). Those orders dispensed with the requirement for service on the defendant, and required the plaintiffs to serve the originating documents on Mr Rocke and Mr Trpcevski as the administrators of the Australian Companies, as well as each of the directors of EV Metals who currently reside in Australia.

10    The plaintiffs have established that they have complied with those orders relating to service of the originating documents. The steps taken by the plaintiffs are set out in a previous affidavit of Mr Darbyshire affirmed on 13 November 2026, and it is not necessary to repeat them here.

11    Pursuant to r 15A.6 of the Corporations Rules, the plaintiffs were also required to send notice of the originating documents to each creditor of EV Metals known to them, as well as publish a notice of the filing of the originating documents in a daily newspaper circulating generally in the Australian State or Territory where EV Metals has its principal place of business.

12    The plaintiffs have also put on evidence confirming compliance with those requirements. The affidavit of Mr Cooper sworn on 9 October 2026 states that a notice in the form prescribed by the Corporations Rules was published in The West Australian newspaper on 25 September 2026, and sent to each of the creditors of EV Metals at their last known email address on 11 September 2026. Following that notice, the plaintiffs’ evidence is that 23 of the creditors responded indicating that they consented to receiving the notification via email. On 21 September 2026, the notice was then sent to each of the 50 creditors who did not respond to the email notice by post to their last known address, and subsequently no correspondence has been received by the plaintiffs from these remaining creditors in relation to the application.

13    As such, I am satisfied that the relevant service and notice requirements contained in the orders made on 26 August 2026 and the Corporations Rules have been satisfied.

14    Other than the plaintiff, no person appeared on the application for recognition.

Recognition as a foreign proceeding under the Model Law

15    As mentioned, the Model Law, with the modifications set out in Part 2 to the CBI Act, has force of law in Australia: s 6 of the CBI Act; see also Kellow, Re Advanced Building & Construction Limited (in liq) v Advanced Building & Construction Limited (in liq) (No 2) [2022] FCA 781 at [6] (Derrington J).

16    Article 17 of the Model Law relevantly provides:

Decision to recognize a foreign proceeding

1.    Subject to article 6, a foreign proceeding shall be recognized if:

(a)    The foreign proceeding is a proceeding within the meaning of subparagraph (a) of article 2;

(b)    The foreign representative applying for recognition is a person or body within the meaning of subparagraph (d) of article 2;

(c)    The application meets the requirements of paragraph 2 of article 15; and

(d)    The application has been submitted to the court referred to in article 4.

2.    The foreign proceeding shall be recognized:

(a)    As a foreign main proceeding if it is taking place in the State where the debtor has the centre of its main interests; or

(b)    As a foreign non-main proceeding if the debtor has an establishment within the meaning of subparagraph (f) of article 2 in the foreign State.

3.    An application for the recognition of a foreign proceeding shall be decided upon at the earliest possible time.

…

17    Article 15 provides that a foreign representative may apply for recognition of the foreign proceeding and sets out the procedural requirements for such an application.

18    To determine whether the UK administration should be recognised as a foreign main proceeding, it is necessary to first determine whether the UK administration should be recognised as a foreign proceeding. As will be seen, part of this exercise is to determine whether the plaintiffs are foreign representatives within the meaning of Art 2(d).

19    For the reasons that follow, I am satisfied that the criteria for the recognition of the UK administration as a foreign proceeding under the Model Law and the CBI Act have been met. It follows that, subject to Art 6 of the Model Law, the UK administration must be recognised as a foreign proceeding for the purposes of the Model Law: Kapila, Re Edelsten [2014] FCA 1112 at [22] (Beach J). Art 6 provides that the court may refuse to take an action governed by the Model Law if the action would be ‘manifestly contrary’ to the public policy of the State in which assistance is sought. No question of that kind arises in this matter.

Foreign proceeding

20    In order for the UK administration to be a ‘foreign proceeding’ within the meaning of Art 2(a) of the Model Law, it must be:

a collective judicial or administrative proceeding in a foreign State, including an interim proceeding, pursuant to a law relating to insolvency in which proceeding the assets and affairs of the debtor are subject to control or supervision by a foreign court, for the purpose of reorganization or liquidation[.]

21    I accept the plaintiffs’ submission that the UK administration meets this criterion. EV Metals is under administration pursuant to the Insolvency Act. Although the plaintiffs were appointed by the directors of the company, the High Court of England and Wales has supervisory jurisdiction in respect of the administration. Paragraph 5 of the Schedule B1 of the Insolvency Act provides that an administrator is an officer of the court, ‘whether or not he or she is appointed by the court’. Paragraphs 74 and 75 further provide that the court may review the conduct of the administrators in certain circumstances: see Laverty v Greensill Capital (UK) Limited (in administration), Re Greensill Capital (UK) Limited (in administration) [2023] FCA 721 at [30] (Halley J). The appointment of an administrator in the UK under Schedule B1 has previously been found to be a foreign proceeding for the purposes of Art 2(a) by this Court, including in circumstances where the administrators were appointed by a directors’ resolution: see De’ath (liquidator) v Digital Fuel Marketing Limited (in administration), Re Digital Fuel Marketing Limited (in administration) [2022] FCA 470 at [17] (Anastassiou J).

Foreign representatives

22    To be recognised as foreign representatives within the meaning of Art 2(d), the plaintiffs must be authorised in a foreign proceeding to administer the reorganisation or the liquidation of the debtor’s assets or affairs or to act as a representative of the foreign proceeding. A foreign representative may apply to the court for recognition of the foreign proceeding in which the foreign representative has been appointed: Art 15(1).

23    As has been mentioned, the plaintiffs were appointed the administrators of EV Metals in the UK on 1 June 2026; as such they are authorised under Schedule B1 of the Insolvency Act to administer the reorganisation of EV Metals. The notice of their appointment is sealed by the High Court of England and Wales, and, as above, Schedule B1 makes it plain that they are under the supervisory jurisdiction of the court. I therefore accept the plaintiffs’ submission that they are foreign representatives for the purposes of the Model Law. While not strictly necessary or expressly contemplated by the Model Law, it is appropriate to accede to the plaintiffs’ request that their status as such be recognised in an order of the Court: see Laverty.

Procedural requirements

24    In making the application for recognition, the plaintiffs have satisfied the procedural requirements in Art 15(2) of the Model Law. The affidavit of Mr Appleton affirmed on 4 August 2026 annexes a certified copy of the notice of the decision commencing the UK administration and appointing the plaintiffs as the UK administrators. In addition, the plaintiffs have satisfied the procedural requirements of Art 15(3) of the Model Law and s 13 of the CBI Act, as the affidavit of Mr Appleton contains a statement that he has no knowledge of:

(a)    any foreign proceedings in respect of EV Metals, save for those the subject of this application;

(b)    any proceedings under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) in respect of EV Metals;

(c)    any receiver, controller or managing controller appointed over EV Metals, within the meanings in s 416 or s 9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth); and

(d)    any proceedings under Chapter 5, s 601CL or Schedule 2 of the Corporations Act in respect of EV Metals.

Recognition as a foreign main proceeding under the Model Law

25    As has been said, I am satisfied that the requirements in Art 17(1) are satisfied and the proceeding should be recognised as a foreign proceeding for the purposes of the Model Law. As a foreign proceeding, it must be recognised as a foreign main proceeding if it is taking place in a State where the debtor has the centre of its main interests (COMI): Art 17(2)(a).

Centre of Main Interests

26    The registered office of EV Metals is located in London, UK. Article 16(3) of the Model Law provides that, in the absence of proof to the contrary, the location of the debtor’s registered office is presumed to be the debtor’s COMI. If the presumption applies, it follows that the UK administration must be recognised as a foreign main proceeding pursuant to Art 17(2)(a). However, the presumption can be rebutted if there are factors that are objective and ascertainable by third parties (including creditors), which warrant a conclusion that there is an ‘actual situation’ where the debtor’s COMI is located at a place other than its registered office: Bradley, Re Astora Women’s Health, LLC v Astora Women’s Health, LLC (No 2) [2022] FCA 1268 at [19] (Lee J), citing Kapila at [53] (Beach J) and Wood v Astra Resources Ltd (UK Company No 07620218) [2016] FCA 1192 at [14] (White J).

27    In a contested application the burden of persuasion is on the party seeking to rebut the presumption: Young, Jr, Re Buccaneer Energy Limited v Buccaneer Energy Limited [2014] FCA 711 at [14] (Jagot J). However, counsel for the plaintiffs properly accepted that, in circumstances where there is no contradictor and the matter is effectively proceeding ex parte (albeit after giving notice), there was a duty on his clients to frankly bring to the Court’s attention all factors that might be reasonably thought to bear on the location of the COMI, and that it is ultimately the duty of the Court to satisfy itself on the basis of all the material as to whether the presumption should apply.

28    As Rares J observed in Ackers (as Joint Foreign Representative) v Saad Investments Co Ltd (in Official Liquidation) (a Co Registered in the Cayman Islands) [2010] FCA 1221; (2010) 190 FCR 285, the purpose of the presumption as to the COMI is to promote efficiency in insolvency administrations. At [50]-[51] his Honour said:

The purpose of the presumption in Art 16(3) is to facilitate the decision of an application under the Model Law for recognition at the earliest possible time in accordance with Art 17(3). It will often be the case that the debtor’s activities leading up to his, her or its insolvency, will have occurred in a variety of locations, and that more than one of these might be capable of being found to be the debtor’s centre of main interests. The more complex the debtor’s transnational dealings and the place or places from which the debtor engaged in them, the more difficult the task of the Court would be in untangling where the debtor’s COMI is, were it not for the facultative presumption in Art 16(3).

That presumption is intended, in the absence of proof of its displacement, to avoid the Court having to spend, perhaps, years in trying to weigh the various transactions and commercial activities that the debtor undertook in various places throughout the world. There would be uncertainty, and indeed a great deal of potentially unnecessary distraction, created by that effort. Untangling the consequences of a cross-border insolvency in respect of a group of companies or a company that traded in many jurisdictions, is in itself, as experience has shown, a time-consuming and difficult exercise.

29    Subject to the presumption, the COMI should correspond to the place where the debtor conducts the administration of its interests on a regular basis and which is therefore readily ascertainable by third parties: see Ackers at [42] citing Re Eurofood IFSC Ltd [2006] Ch 508 at [33]-[34]. For the presumption to be displaced, the Court has to be satisfied that the COMI is not in the State in which its registered office is located: Ackers at [43].

30    A non-exhaustive list of additional factors that may be relevant to the question of where a debtor’s COMI is located are set out in the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency with Guide to Enactment and Interpretation, published by the United Nations in January 2014, at [147]. The Guide explains (at [146]) that these factors may be considered on a holistic basis where there is no ready answer to the location of a debtor’s COMI, and that the factors may need to be weighed differently on a case by case basis. The factors, which have been adopted in this Court by McEvoy J in Bankruptcy Office of Canton of Geneva (Trustee) v Amoma SARL (In Liq), Amoma SARL (No 2) [2023] FCA 1379 at [20] and Beach J in Kapila at [54], may include:

the location of the debtor’s books and records; the location where financing was organized or authorized, or from where the cash management system was run; the location in which the debtor’s principal assets or operations are found; the location of the debtor’s primary bank; the location of employees; the location in which commercial policy was determined; the site of the controlling law or the law governing the main contracts of the company; the location from which purchasing and sales policy, staff, accounts payable and computer systems were managed; the location from which contracts (for supply) were organized; the location from which reorganization of the debtor was being conducted; the jurisdiction whose law would apply to most disputes; the location in which the debtor was subject to supervision or regulation; and the location whose law governed the preparation and audit of accounts and in which they were prepared and audited.

31    There has been some divergence as to the time as at which the COMI is to be decided.

32    In Gainsford v Tannenbaum [2012] FCA 904; (2012) 216 FCR 543 at [45] Logan J adopted the assumption that the question is to be answered at the time the recognition proceeding is filed. In Moore as Debtor-in-Possession of Australian Equity Investors v Australian Equity Investors [2012] FCA 1002 at [18] Emmett J held that the appropriate time is the date the court is called on to make the decision under Art 17(2) (see too Wood at [12] (White J)).

33    Both approaches leave open the possibility that the acts of administrators may influence the selection of the COMI. Beach J reasoned in Kapila that, although he did not consider either Gainsford or Moore to be plainly wrong, the best approach was to decide the COMI as at the date of commencement of the foreign proceeding: see [35]-[39]. His Honour considered that this approach is justified by the language and requirements of Art 15 and injects certainty and uniformity into the court’s determination, doubting at [38] that an outcome influenced by ‘ephemeral debtor movements and activities, in essence after the event’ would promote the objectives of the Model Law. Perram J preferred Beach J’s approach in King, Re Zetta Jet Pte Ltd [2018] FCA 1932 at [11]-[12].

34    So, with respect, do I. Kapila is the only considered treatment of this issue and is consistent with the Guide’s recommendation at [157]-[159]. However, it is also possible to see a basis for saying that the Model Law contemplates that the location for debtor’s COMI may be affected by the course of an insolvency administration and, since nothing turns on it in this case, the point is not yet foreclosed.

The plaintiffs’ position

35    At the hearing, counsel for the plaintiffs accepted that the operations of EV Metals spanned a number of locations. While its registered office is in the UK, it has directors in Australia and Saudi Arabia, its major project is in Saudi Arabia, and its only employee is in Perth, Australia, that employee being its Chief Executive Officer, Luke Fitzgerald.

36    In those circumstances, the plaintiffs’ primary submission is that, since there are indicators that each of the UK, Australia and Saudi Arabia could be EV Metals’ COMI, it is not possible to determine a single operational seat of the company and, as such, there is insufficient proof to overcome the presumption. The result, they submit, should be that the UK is the COMI, as it is the location of EV Metals’ registered office.

37    For the following reasons, I accept that submission. In reaching that conclusion, I have had regard to the factors set out in the UN Guide and adopted by this Court in Kapila and Wood, and to the underlying purpose of the presumption as explained in Ackers. Where any of those factors are not mentioned below, that is because there is no evidence pertaining to them.

Location of debtor’s books and records

38    While a Statement of Affairs dated 21 July 2026 annexed to the affidavit of Mr Cooper states that information has been sought from directors of EV Metals regarding the extent and whereabouts of the company’s physical and electronic records, it is not clear on the evidence before the Court where these books and records are located.

39    The plaintiffs submit that the management and operational tasks of EV Metals are undertaken by persons located in the UK, Australia and Saudi Arabia, with four senior management personnel located in each of Australia and Saudi Arabia, and one in the UK. This does not shed light on the location of the company’s books and records.

40    EV Metals appears to have complied with regulatory filing obligations in the UK until 22 April 2026, which seems to be the date of the last filings made with Companies House (which maintains a record of company information in the UK) before the company entered administration. It can be inferred from this fact that at least some books and records pertaining to the company’s finances are located in the UK, but it is not possible to be more definitive than that.

Organisation or authorisation of financing and location of cash management system

41    The primary role of EV Metals within the EV Group was to manage the operational and funding requirements of the EV Group, for the lithium plant and other multi-national projects. But consistently with the above, the evidence indicates that this function involved directors and personnel from each of the UK, Australia and Saudi Arabia. The company’s CEO and sole employee, Mr Fitzgerald, lives in Perth and worked from the company’s office premises on St Georges Terrace, Perth, or from his home. Four of the company’s directors reside in Saudi Arabia and three in Australia, with the company’s two secretaries (one of which is a corporation) based in the UK.

42    Counsel for the plaintiffs submitted that EV Metals conducted various operational tasks in the UK, including filing documents with the Companies House, issuing shares and maintaining the records with the UK Share Register, as well as conducting meetings of the board of directors via video conference, with attendees attending from a variety of different locations. Although those meetings were run from the company’s office premises in Perth, Mr Appleton’s affidavit says that personnel rarely attended that office premises for such meetings physically, due to their varied locations.

43    As such, similarly to the location of the company’s books and records, the evidence does not clearly establish one central location at which financing was authorised, organised or run.

Location of the debtor’s principal assets or operations

44    Counsel for the plaintiffs submitted that EV Metals’ major project is the lithium production plant in Saudi Arabia. While construction is yet to commence for this project, counsel submitted that the relevant commitments have been made and land located in Saudi Arabia for the project to be built and the relevant approvals obtained. The evidence before the Court does not indicate how far the development is advanced. Rather, counsel submitted that steps have been taken to locate a physical asset in Saudi Arabia and that the project is sufficiently advanced to make it a valuable asset for the administrators to sell.

45    Most of the employees involved in the development of the lithium plant are described as being employed by EV Metals Australia Pty Ltd, one of the Australian Companies for which administrators have been appointed.

46    The plaintiffs submit that a substantial portion of the assets of the EV Group are in the form of intellectual property rights in relation to the development and construction of the lithium plant and that they are largely held by EV Metals. These rights are largely comprised of trade secrets and confidential know how. To the extent that they are not held in employees’ personal knowledge, they are stored on computers in a manner that does not permit a clear physical location to be assigned.

47    The Australian Companies are described as also having assets relating to interests in the lithium plant, but it is uncertain the extent, if any, of their interest in the intellectual property. In his affidavit, Mr Appleton gives evidence that there is a connection between the intellectual property generated by EV Metals and the Australian Companies. He says this connection arises because EV Metals is a party to the contract pursuant to which the majority of the intellectual property was developed, and the employees of EV Metals Australia were responsible for dealing with the intellectual property and advancing the construction of the lithium plant. Mr Appleton also says that EVM Lithium Chemicals Pty Ltd, another of the Australian Companies for which administrators have been appointed, entered into various supplementary contracts in relation to the development of the plant, pursuant to which additional intellectual property appears to have been created. Prior to that company entering administration, Mr Appleton says that this intellectual property was transferred to EV Metals in consideration for the forgiveness of intercompany loans.

48    Be that as it may, the evidence does not point to any one physical location for the largely intangible and unregistered intellectual property assets.

Creditors

49    While this is not listed as a separate factor in the Guide to the Model Law, those factors are non-exclusive and the location of the creditors of the company is potentially relevant: see also Kapila at [54]. The creditors of EV Metals are located in various jurisdictions, including the UK, Australia and Saudi Arabia. From the evidence in Mr Appleton’s affidavit, the majority of the creditors appear to be located in Saudi Arabia and Australia.

Location of debtor’s primary bank

50    A Statement of Proposals dated 22 July 2026, annexed to Mr Cooper’s affidavit, describes a monetary figure as ‘Cash at Bank’, but does not identify the details or location of that bank. The amount is designated in pounds sterling, but that is a slender reed on which to base any conclusion that its bank was located in the UK.

51    The plaintiffs have undertaken a sale campaign for the sale of EV Metals. Pursuant to the sale agreement, on 22 October 2026 the plaintiffs received approximately US$2.3 million into a trust account they describe as being maintained for the purposes of the administration. This trust account appears to be set up in the UK. However I put no weight on this factor, in view of the approach to the time as at which the COMI is to be decided, as set out above.

Location of employees

52    As mentioned above, EV Metals’ sole employee is the company’s CEO, Mr Fitzgerald, who resides in and works from Perth.

Location in which commercial policy was determined

53    As mentioned above, board meetings were generally held via video conference, with directors attending from various locations. For example, the minutes of the board meeting that took place by video conference on 29 May 2026, at which it was resolved that the company be placed into administration and the plaintiffs appointed as administrators, appears to have been attended by participants in the UK, Saudi Arabia and Australia. As such, it appears that commercial policy and other formal matters were not decided at one physical location.

Law governing the company’s main contracts and most disputes

54    The evidence records that the various lenders who advanced funds to EV Metals pursuant to loan agreements constitute a large number of EV Metals’ creditors. While these creditors are located primarily in Australia and Saudi Arabia, each of the loan agreements (with three exceptions) contain an express term that they are governed by the laws of England and Wales and are subject to the non-exclusive jurisdiction of the English courts. There are also a number of convertible loan agreements between lenders and EV Metals which are subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of the courts of England.

55    The exceptions are that there is a loan agreement between the EV Metals and a creditor governed by the laws of Western Australian and the exclusive jurisdiction of the Western Australian courts; a deed of settlement between EV Metals and a creditor governed by the laws of Western Australia; and a services contract with an Australian company to which Western Australian jurisdiction applies. However, all in all, the law governing the company’s main contracts is that of England and Wales. It follows that the law of England and Wales most likely applies to the majority of the contracts and financing documents entered into by EV Metals.

Management of purchasing and sales policy, staff, accounts payable and computer systems

56    Other than as mentioned above, there is no specific evidence as to the location of these aspects of the company’s operations. While the registered office of EV Metals is located in the UK, the company also leased the Perth office premises for use by the Australian Companies and, prior to the appointment of the plaintiffs as administrators, was also ‘in the process’ of establishing a corporate office in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, although there is no evidence as to how advanced that initiative was. But, once again, nothing turn on it anyway.

Location from which reorganisation of the debtor was being conducted

57    The reorganisation of EV Metals appears to be largely conducted from the UK. The plaintiffs, as the administrators of the company, administered creditors’ communications and conducted the sale process from their office in London. This involved producing and circulating to creditors a Statement of Proposals for achieving the purpose of the administration and negotiating the terms in relation to the sale of EV Metals’ assets. As has been said, I have adopted the position that the appropriate time to determine the COMI as at the time the at the date of the commencement of the foreign proceeding, and therefore put no weight on this factor.

Location in which debtor is subject to supervision or regulation

58    EV Metals is a UK public limited company registered with the Companies House and was placed into administration pursuant to Sch B1 to the Insolvency Act. The plaintiffs were authorised to act by the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales. EV Metals is subject to supervision and regulation in the UK, but also in Australia to the extent that it is registered as a foreign company and as a foreign resident for tax purposes with the Australian Tax Office.

Location of and law governing the preparation and audit of accounts

59    The evidence before me does not clearly establish the location of and law governing the preparation and auditing of accounts, however the Statement of Proposals annexed to Mr Cooper’s affidavit records that EV Metals’ auditor is HGA Chartered Accounts, based in London, UK. And, as has been said, it can also be inferred from the filings with Companies House that these functions have been located in the UK.

The rebuttable presumption is not displaced

60    It is readily apparent from the above that the evidence does not permit a conclusion that any one country served as the location for the majority of the policy and decision making activities, operational activities, assets, financing or administrative and compliance functions of EV Metals. Therefore, I am not satisfied that the presumption provided in Art 16(3) (that the COMI was in the UK, as the location of the company’s registered office) has been displaced.

Recognition as a foreign main proceeding

61    Art 20(1) of the Model Law provides that the effect of recognition of the UK administration as a foreign main proceeding is:

(a)    Commencement or continuation of individual actions or individual proceedings concerning the debtor’s assets, rights, obligations or liabilities is stayed;

(b)    Execution against the debtor’s assets is stayed; and

(c)    The right to transfer, encumber or otherwise dispose of any assets of the debtor is suspended.

62    Art 20(2) provides that the scope, and the modification or termination, of the stay and suspension referred to in Art 20(1) are subject to any provision of law of the enacting State relating to insolvency that apply in such circumstances.

63    Section 16 of the CBI Act determines the content and scope of any stay which arises under Art 20(1) and provides:

For the purposes of paragraph 2 of Article 20 of the Model Law (as it has the force of law in Australia), the scope and the modification or termination of the stay or suspension referred to in paragraph 1 of that Article, are the same as would apply if the stay or suspension arose under:

(a)    the Bankruptcy Act 1966; or

(b)    Chapter 5 (other than Parts 5.2 and 5.4A) of the Corporations Act 2001;

as the case requires.

64    I am satisfied that the regime under Part 5.3A is the closest analogy to an English law administration, and the scope of the stay and suspension referred to in Art 20(2) of the Model Law is substantially the same as that which applies to an Australian corporation under Part 5.3A of the Corporations Act: see Laverty at [42]-[43] (Halley J); Re Aero Inventory (UK) Limited (No 2) [2009] FCA 1481; (2009) 181 FCR 674 at [16] (Lindgren J).

65    Whilst the effect of s 16 of the CBI Act is that upon recognition any stay operates as if it arose under the Corporations Act (that is, automatically by force of law), it is appropriate and has been the practice of the Court to make an order giving explicit effect to Art 20 of the Model Law and s 16 of the CBI Act: see Laverty at [44] (Halley J).

66    As has been said, I am satisfied the UK administration should be recognised as a foreign proceeding within the meaning of Art 2(b) for the purposes of Art 17(1) of the Model Law. It follows that the plaintiffs are the foreign representatives of EV Metals within the meaning of Art 2(d) of the Model Law. On the evidence before me, I am also satisfied that EV Metals’ COMI for the purposes of Art 17(2) is the UK. It follows that the UK administration conducted by the plaintiffs must be recognised as a foreign main proceeding. Orders to that effect will be made.

I certify that the preceding sixty-six (66) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Justice Jackson.

Associate:

Dated:    16 November 2026