FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Top End (Default PBC/CLA) Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC v Northern Territory of Australia [2026] FCA 1723
File number: | NTD 9 of 2025 |
Judgment of: | CHARLESWORTH J |
Date of judgment: | 13 November 2026 |
Catchwords: | ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review of a decision of the Pastoral Land Board under the Pastoral Land Act 1992 (NT) to grant a permit to use land subject to a pastoral lease for the non-pastoral use of tourism – decision affected by multiple reviewable and material errors – decision set aside – judicial review of a decision of the Minister for Water Resources (NT) affirming a decision of the Controller to grant a water extraction licence under the Water Act 1992 (NT) – decision unaffected by reviewable error NATIVE TITLE – whether a purported but invalid decision to grant a non-pastoral use permit is a future act within the meaning of s 233 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) – whether, if validly made, the decision was covered by s 24GB of the Native Title Act – whether a decision to grant a water extraction licence validly affects non-exclusive native title rights and interests to take water from the same source – whether the decision to grant the water extraction licence is a future act to which s 24HA of the Native Title Act can apply |
Legislation: | Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cth) Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) ss 15AA, 15AB Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth) Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21 Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (Cth) s 9 Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 3, 24AA, 24GA, 24GB, 24HA, 24OA, 44H, 87, 223, 226, 227, 233, 237, 238, 239, 244, 248, 248B Native Title (Notices) Determination 2011 (No. 1) (Cth) items 4, 8 Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (NT) s 4 Land Title Act 2000 (NT) Northern Territory Aboriginal Sacred Sites Act 1989 (NT) Pastoral Land Act 1992 (NT) ss 3, 4, 5, 25, 28, 29, 38, 39, 40, 85A, 85B, 86, 87, 87A, 88, 89B, 89D, 89E Water Act 1992 (NT) ss 11, 30, 45, 71B, 71C, 71E, 90 Pastoral Land Regulations 1992 (NT) reg 4 |
Cases cited: | A v Corruption and Crime Commissioner [2013] WASCA 288; (2013) 306 ALR 49 Australian Conservation Foundation v Minister for the Environment [2021] FCA 550; (2021) 390 ALR 157 Banjima People v Western Australia (No 2) [2013] FCA 868; (2013) 305 ALR 1 Changshu Longte Grinding Ball Co Ltd v Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry, Innovation and Science (2019) 270 FCR 244 Commissioner for ACT Revenue v Alphaone Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 576 Environment Centre Northern Territory (NT) Incorporated v Minister for Land Resource Management (2015) 35 NTLR 140 Friends of the Gelorup Corridor v Minister for the Environment and Water (2023) 299 FCR 236 Hunter v Minister for Planning [2012] WASC 247 ICM Agriculture Pty Ltd v Commonwealth (2009) 240 CLR 140 Industrial Equity Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (1990) 170 CLR 649 Lardil Peoples v Queensland (2001) 108 FCR 453 LPDT v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (2024) 280 CLR 321 Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24 Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Bhardwaj (2002) 209 CLR 597 Narrier v Western Australia [2016] FCA 1519 Northern Territory v Griffiths (2019) 269 CLR 1 Plaintiff M1-2021 v Minister for Home Affairs (2022) 275 CLR 582 Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355 Riley v Northern Territory [2021] FCA 716 Snowy Monaro Regional Council v Tropic Asphalts Pty Ltd [2018] NSWCCA 202; (2018) 362 ALR 359 South Australia v Slipper (2004) 136 FCR 259 SZBEL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2006) 228 CLR 152 |
Division: | General Division |
Registry: | Northern Territory |
National Practice Area: | Native Title |
Number of paragraphs: | 391 |
Date of last submissions: | Applicant: 26 March 2026 |
First Respondent: 6 March 2026 | |
Date of hearing: | 15-17 December 2025 |
Counsel for the Applicant: | S Glacken KC with C Viney |
Solicitor for the Applicant: | Northern Land Council |
Counsel for the First Respondent: | H Blattman KC with L Spargo-Peattie and L Kruger |
Solicitor for the First, Second, Third and Fourth Respondents: | Ashurst Perkins Coie Australia |
Counsel for the Second, Third, Fourth, Fifth and Sixth Respondents: | The Second to Sixth Respondents submitted to the outcome |
Solicitor for the Fifth and Sixth Respondents: | Phelps Legal |
Solicitor for the Seventh Respondent: | The Seventh Respondent did not participate in the proceeding |
ORDERS
NTD 9 of 2025 | ||
| ||
BETWEEN: | TOP END (DEFAULT PBC/CLA) ABORIGINAL CORPORATION RNTBC Applicant | |
AND: | NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA First Respondent CHAIRPERSON, PASTORAL LAND BOARD Second Respondent MINISTER FOR WATER RESOURCES (NT) (and others named in the Schedule) Third Respondent | |
order made by: | CHARLESWORTH J |
DATE OF ORDER: | 13 November 2026 |
THE COURT DECLARES THAT:
1. The decision of the Pastoral Land Board to grant non-pastoral use permit NPU25/01 under s 85A of the Pastoral Land Act 1992 (NT) is invalid.
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1. The decision of the Pastoral Land Board to grant non-pastoral use permit NPU25/01 under s 85A of the Pastoral Land Act 1992 (NT) is set aside.
2. The Pastoral Land Board is to determine the application of the sixth and seventh respondents for a non-pastoral use permit according to law.
3. The originating application is otherwise dismissed.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
CHARLESWORTH J:
1 Lorella Springs is a working cattle station of about 3,840 km² (384,095 ha) situated on and inland from the coastline of the Gulf of Carpentaria. The boundaries of the station are defined by a pastoral lease (PL 757) governed by the Pastoral Land Act 1992 (NT). This application concerns decisions made by Northern Territory government agencies to permit the land comprising Lorella Springs to be used for the non-pastoral use of tourism, and for water to be extracted for a related purpose.
2 The sixth and seventh respondents are the Lessees under the pastoral lease. A pastoral business is conducted on the land by the fifth respondent, Lorella Spring’s Station Pty Ltd (LSS).
3 The land covered by PL 757 comprises traditional Aboriginal estates of the Burdal Riley, Murrungun Wunubari and Mambali Walangara estate groups. They are people for whom specific reservations are made under the Pastoral Land Act and the pastoral lease is expressly made subject to those reservations. In addition, living members of the estate groups possess non-exclusive native title rights and interests in relation to land and waters covered by PL 757, to the extent recognised and determined by this Court in a determination made pursuant to s 87 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth): Riley v Northern Territory [2021] FCA 716. The native title rights and interests include non-exclusive rights and interests to protect places, areas and things of traditional significance, to conduct and participate in cultural activities, to maintain places of traditional significance, and to take and use resources from the area (including water). The applicant, Top End (Default PBC/CLA) Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC, is the registered body corporate in relation to that native title.
4 Top End challenges two Decisions made or purportedly made under Northern Territory enactments, namely:
(1) a decision of the Pastoral Land Board to grant to the Lessees a Tourism Permit, being a non-pastoral use permit for the “approved purpose” of tourism under s 85A of the Pastoral Land Act (Tourism Decision); and
(2) a decision of the Minister for Water Resources, upholding a decision of the Controller of Water Resources to grant to LSS a Water Extraction Licence under s 45 of the Water Act 1992 (NT) (Water Decision).
5 References to the Minister in these reasons should be understood to mean the Minister responsible for administering the Water Act or the Pastoral Land Act, depending on the context.
6 The Decisions were each made in circumstances where the Lessees or associated entities had for many years operated a significant tourism enterprise at Lorella Springs, marketed as Lorella Springs Wildlife Park, whilst also allowing it to be used by external tourism operators. It is common ground that no permit had been issued to the Lessees in relation to those past activities. These reasons are not concerned with the legality of the past activities, however the prior uses form an important part of the factual background.
7 By its further amended originating application (OA), Top End applies for judicial review of the Decisions. It seeks declarations that the Decisions are invalid in accordance with administrative law principles, together with writs in the nature of certiorari and mandamus setting them aside and compelling the respective decision-makers to exercise their powers in accordance with the law.
8 The Court’s jurisdiction to hear the application for judicial review arises in part under s 9(3) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (Cth) and s 4(1) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (NT). It otherwise arises because the proceeding is one in which matters arise under a law of the Commonwealth (namely the Native Title Act): Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s 39B(1A).
9 In addition to relief on the application for judicial review, Top End seeks declarations under s 21 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) about the status and effect of the Decisions under the future act provisions contained in Pt 2, Div 3 of the Native Title Act. The proposed declarations are as follows:
1. A declaration that the grant of non-pastoral use permit NPU25/01 under s 85A of the Pastoral Land Act 1992 (NT), if validly granted under that law, is a future act that is not covered by a provision of Part 2 Div 3 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) and is invalid to the extent it affects native title.
2. A declaration that the grant of non-pastoral use permit NPU25/01 under s 85A of the Pastoral Land Act 1992 (NT) is invalid.
…
5. A declaration that the grant of water extraction licence 9061044 under s 45 of the Water Act 1992 (NT), if validly granted under that law, is a future act within s 24HA(2) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth).
6. A declaration that the decision of the Minister for Water Resources upholding the decision of the Controller of Water Resources under former s 30(3)(a)(i) of the Water Act 1992 (NT) is invalid.
(emphasis added)
10 As can be seen from the words I have emphasised, the issues arising under the Native Title Act each proceed from an assumption that the Decisions were validly made under the Pastoral Land Act and the Water Act respectively. If the Decisions were not validly made, it is common ground that they could not meet the description of future acts for the purposes of the Native Title Act: Lardil Peoples v Queensland (2001) 108 FCR 453 at [74] (Merkel J).
PARTIES
11 The native title holders are those persons mentioned in cll 5–8 of the Native Title Determination made in Riley. Their rights and interests (defined in cl 9 of the Determination) include the right to do the activities listed in cl 14(a)–(i), most relevantly to conduct and participate in cultural activities and cultural practices relating to birth and death, including burial rites, ceremonies and meetings: (cl 14(g)). As mentioned above, the determined rights include the right to maintain and protect sites and places on those areas that are of traditional significance (cl 14(i)) and to teach about their physical and spiritual attributes. The interests of the native title holders in this proceeding are represented by the sole applicant, Top End.
12 The Northern Land Council (NLC) is an Aboriginal/Torres Strait Islander representative body for the purposes of Pt 11 of the Native Title Act. It acts for Top End in this proceeding. It also acted for Top End and the native title holders for the purposes of opposing the Tourism Decision and the Water Decision. Whilst it is not a party, NLC will feature in the factual background set out in the pages to come.
13 The Board (by its Chairperson), the Minister and the Controller are joined as the second to fourth respondents. Each has submitted to the outcome of the proceeding, as have the Lessees.
14 The seventh respondent, Landmark Developments Pty Ltd, was duly served but filed no notice of address for service. Having satisfied myself that it was served, I proceed to judgment in its absence.
15 The first-named respondent is the Northern Territory. It is the only active contradictor in the proceeding, defending the decisions of the Board and the Minister.
SUMMARY OF OUTCOME
16 There are 12 Grounds, eight relating to the Tourism Decision and four relating to the Water Decision. There are Sub-Grounds within those Grounds giving rise to a multitude of issues. The issues will be summarised in the course of addressing each Ground.
17 I have decided the claims for relief in relation to the Tourism Decision as follows:
(1) The Tourism Decision was not a valid exercise of the power conferred by s 85A of the Pastoral Land Act by reason of the Board’s material non-compliance with several conditions on the exercise of its power.
(2) There will be orders setting the Tourism Decision aside and compelling the Board to determine the Lessees’ application for a non-pastoral use permit according to law.
(3) The act of granting the Tourism Permit was not a future act within the meaning of s 233 of the Native Title Act because it did not validly affect native title within the meaning of s 233(c)(i).
(4) If I am wrong in concluding that the Tourism Decision was not validly made under the Pastoral Land Act, I would have concluded that:
(a) the act of granting the Tourism Permit was a valid future act by reason of the coverage of s 24GB of the Native Title Act, which applied because of the operation of s 24GB(2) and the non-application of the exception in s 24GB(3); and
(b) accordingly, Top End’s application for a declaration that the act was not covered by s 24GB would have been denied.
18 The Territory did not submit that the rejection of the applicant’s claims with respect to the Tourism Permit would render it unnecessary to determine the claims for relief in relation to the Water Decision. I have therefore decided the claims for relief relating to the Water Decision on their merits as follows:
(1) The Water Decision was a valid exercise of the power granted under s 45 of the Water Act.
(2) On the evidence before me I am not satisfied that the Water Decision affects native title and hence I am not satisfied that it is a future act within the meaning of s 233 of the Native Title Act. It follows that there is no occasion to apply s 24HA of the Native Title Act.
THE TOURISM DECISION
19 I will begin by summarising the statutory regime before describing in some detail the processes culminating in the Tourism Decision. The Water Decision will be considered later in these reasons.
Native Title Act
20 An object of the Native Title Act is “to establish ways in which future dealings affecting native title may proceed and to set standards for those dealings”: s 3(b). This proceeding concerns the “future act” provisions contained in Div 3 of Pt 2. Subdivision G deals with future acts and primary production on non-exclusive agricultural and pastoral leases.
21 Section 233(1) defines a “future act” as follows:
(1) Subject to this section, an act is a future act in relation to land or waters if:
(a) either:
(i) it consists of the making, amendment or repeal of legislation and takes place on or after 1 July 1993; or
(ii) it is any other act that takes place on or after 1 January 1994; and
(b) it is not a past act; and
(c) apart from this Act, either:
(i) it validly affects native title in relation to the land or waters to any extent; or
(ii) the following apply:
(A) it is to any extent invalid; and
(B) it would be valid to that extent if any native title in relation to the land or waters did not exist; and
(C) if it were valid to that extent, it would affect the native title.
(emphasis added)
22 An act affects native title if it extinguishes the native title rights and interests or if it is wholly or partly inconsistent with their continued existence, enjoyment or exercise: s 227.
23 To the extent that a future act affects native title, it will be valid if it is covered by certain provisions within Div 3 of Pt 2, but invalid if it is not so covered: ss 24AA(2), 24OA.
24 For the purposes of the future act regime, the word “act” encompasses the grant or issue of a licence, permit or authority: s 226(2)(b). The grant of the Tourism Permit and the Water Extraction Licence meet that description. Each is an act attributable to the Territory: s 239(c). Relevantly for present purposes, each of those acts will be a “future act” in relation to land or waters if it takes place after 1 January 1994 and, apart from the Native Title Act, it validly affects native title in relation to the land or waters to any extent: s 233(1)(a)(ii) and (c)(i). A decision purportedly made under a Northern Territory enactment could not validly affect native title if it is void and of no legal effect, as only a valid act can affect native title: Lardil Peoples at [74] – [75] (Merkel J), [133] – [134] (Dowsett J).
25 Accordingly, ascertaining the validity of the Decisions made or purportedly made under the laws of the Northern Territory is an essential step in determining whether the grant of the Tourism Permit and the Water Extraction Licence are future acts.
26 The allegation of invalidity in the context of the application for judicial review is different from the concept of “validity” as employed for different purposes in the provisions of the Native Title Act discussed below.
27 Subdivision G of Div 3 is headed “Future acts and primary production”. Section 24GA(1) provides that the expression “primary production activity” includes the things listed in subs (a)–(g), relating to the cultivation of land and the maintenance of animals.
28 As mentioned above, s 24OA provides that a future act is invalid to the extent that it affects native title, unless a provision of the Native Title Act provides otherwise. Argument proceeded on the basis that if the Tourism Decision is valid in accordance with administrative law principles, it is invalid to the extent that it affects native title in relation to any part of Lorella Springs unless s 24GB of the Native Title Act applies. If s 24GB applies to the Tourism Decision as a future act, then:
(1) the act is valid for the purposes of the Native Title Act (s 24GB(5));
(2) the non-extinguishment principle in s 238 of the Native Title Act applies (s 24GB(6)); and
(3) the native title holders are entitled to compensation for the act, payable by the Crown in right of the Northern Territory (s 24GB(7)).
29 Apart from the allegations of jurisdictional error affecting the validity of the Tourism Decision, a significant controversy in this proceeding relates to whether s 24GB of the Native Title Act applies by reason of subs (2), having regard to the exception in subs (3). Section 24GB is relevantly as follows:
24GB Acts permitting primary production on non-exclusive agricultural and pastoral leases
(1) This section applies to a future act if:
(a) a non‑exclusive agricultural lease (see section 247B) or non‑exclusive pastoral lease (see section 248B) was granted on or before 23 December 1996; and
(b) the grant was valid (including because of Division 2 or 2A); and
Note: As at the commencement of this section, grants before 1 January 1994 that were invalid because of native title have been validated by or under Division 2.
(c) the future act takes place after 23 December 1996; and
(d) the future act permits or requires the carrying on of any of the following while the lease (including as renewed on one or more occasions) is in force:
(i) a primary production activity (see section 24GA) on the area covered by the lease; or
(ii) another activity, on the area covered by the lease, that is associated with or incidental to a primary production activity covered by subparagraph (i), provided that, when the other activity is being carried on, the majority of the area covered by the lease is used for primary production activities; and
(e) the future act could have been validly done or authorised at some time before 31 March 1998, if any native title in relation to the area covered by the lease had not then existed.
Note: For the renewal, re‑grant, re‑making or extension of certain acts covered by this section, see Subdivision I.
Farm tourism included
(2) This section applies to a future act that:
(a) takes place after 23 December 1996; and
(b) permits or requires a farm tourism activity in the area covered by a lease meeting the requirements of paragraphs (1)(a) and (b) while the lease is in force (including as renewed on one or more occasions).
Exception to subsection (2)
(3) However, this section does not apply to a future act permitting or requiring farm tourism if the act permits or requires tourism that involves observing activities or cultural works of Aboriginal peoples or Torres Strait Islanders.
Certain acts not covered
(4) This section does not apply to a future act if:
(a) where the lease covered by paragraph (1)(a) is a non-exclusive pastoral lease covering an area greater than 5,000 hectares—the act has the effect that the majority of the area covered by the lease is required or permitted to be used for purposes other than pastoral purposes;
…
(emphasis added)
30 For the purposes of s 24GB(2)(b) it is common ground that PL 757 meets the requirements in s 24GB(1)(a) and (b). It is also common ground that, for the purposes of s 24GB(4)(a), PL 757 is a non-exclusive pastoral lease (as defined in s 248B) covering an area of greater than 5,000 ha.
31 Section 24GB(9) is as follows:
(9) If:
(a) the primary production activity mentioned in subparagraph (1)(d)(i) or (ii) is forest operations, a horticultural activity or an aquacultural activity; or
(b) the lease mentioned in paragraph (1)(a) is a non-exclusive pastoral lease and the primary production activity mentioned in subparagraph (1)(d)(i) or (ii) is an agricultural activity;
before the future act is done, the person proposing to do the act must:
(c) notify, in the way determined, by legislative instrument, by the Commonwealth Minister, any representative Aboriginal/Torres Strait Islander bodies, registered native title bodies corporate and registered native title claimants in relation to the land or waters covered by the non-exclusive agricultural lease or non-exclusive pastoral lease that the act, or acts of that class, are to be done in relation to the particular land or waters; and
(d) give them an opportunity to comment on the act or class of acts.
32 For the purposes of s 24GB(9)(c), the relevant legislative instrument is the Native Title (Notices) Determination 2011 (No. 1) (Cth) (Notices Determination). Item 8(3) of the Notices Determination required that the notice given under s 24GB(9) include, among other things, (a) a clear description of the area to which the act or class of acts mentioned in the notice relates; and (b) a description of the general nature of the act or class of acts. The Notices Determination was superseded in 2024, but no party submitted that the outcome of this proceeding would differ if the 2024 version applied.
33 In s 24GB(2)(b) and (3) the word “permit” is used as a verb. It is defined in s 244 as follows:
(1) The expression permit, in a reference to a lease permitting a thing, means permit:
(a) expressly by the terms of the lease; or
(b) by implication from the terms of the lease; or
(c) otherwise (including expressly, or by implication, from the operation of legislation).
Example of implication from legislation
(2) An example of a thing permitted by implication from the operation of legislation is where the legislation states that, if a lease is not renewed, compensation is payable for any building constructed on the land subject to the lease. The construction of the building is permitted by implication from the statement.
34 The controversy concerning the Water Decision is whether the grant of the Water Extraction Licence (if validly granted under the Water Act) is an act that “affects native title” so as to fall within the “future act” definition in s 233 of the Native Title Act. There is no dispute that if the Water Decision is a future act, then it is an act falling within s 24HA(2) of the Native Title Act, and hence:
(1) it is a valid act by virtue of s 24HA(3);
(2) it is an act to which the non-extinguishment principle applies by virtue of s 24HA(4); and
(3) the native title holders are entitled to compensation for the act in accordance with Div 5 of the Native Title Act, by virtue of s 24HA(5).
35 In such a case, the compensable act is the grant of the permit itself, not the doing of any activity in accordance with the permit: Native Title Act, s 44H.
Pastoral Land Act
36 For the purposes of the Pastoral Land Act, “pastoral land” is land that is the subject of a pastoral lease granted over Crown land for pastoral purposes: Pastoral Land Act, s 3(1). Pastoral purposes are defined in s 3(1) as follows:
pastoral purposes means the pasturing of stock for sustainable commercial use of the land on which they are pastured or agricultural or other non-dominant uses essential to, carried out in conjunction with, or inseparable from, the pastoral enterprise, including the production of agricultural products for use in stock feeding and pastoral based tourist activities such as farm holidays, but does not include a use which, under section 91, is declared by the Board not to be a use for pastoral purposes.
37 For now, it is sufficient to observe that the Lessees do not need a permit to use the land subject to PL 757 for the non-dominant use of “pastoral based tourist activities such as farm holidays” if that use is carried out in conjunction with the pastoral enterprise.
38 A pastoral lease is subject to conditions under s 38. They include a reservation in favour of the Aboriginal inhabitants of the Territory (s 38(1)(n)), defined in s 38(2) as follows:
(2) In a pastoral lease, a reservation in favour of the Aboriginal inhabitants of the Territory is to be read as a reservation permitting those Aboriginal persons:
(a) who ordinarily reside on the leased land; or
(b) who ordinarily reside on an area of land that at any time after 1 January 1979 was within the boundaries of the land that then comprised the leased land and which area of land has since that date been excised from the leased land as a living area or part of a living area for those Aboriginal persons; or
(c) who, by Aboriginal tradition, are entitled to use or occupy the leased land;
subject to subsection (3):
(d) to enter and be on the leased land; and
(e) notwithstanding any other law of the Territory, to take and use the water from the natural waters and springs on the leased land; and
(f) subject to any other law in force in the Territory:
(i) to take or kill for food or for ceremonial purposes animals ferae naturae; and
(ii) to take for food or for ceremonial purposes vegetable matter growing naturally;
on the leased land;
but not permitting:
(g) the Aboriginal persons referred to in paragraph (a) to erect or use a structure on the leased land that would serve as a permanent shelter for human occupation, other than at the place on the leased land where they ordinarily reside; or
(h) the Aboriginal persons referred to in paragraph (b) or (c) to erect or use such a structure on the leased land.
39 Subject to some exceptions, that reservation does not apply to land within 2 km of a homestead: s 38(3).
40 It is an offence of strict liability to interfere with the full and free exercise by Aboriginal people of rights reserved in their favour under a pastoral lease: s 38(5).
41 Subject to s 88 of the Pastoral Land Act, a pastoral lease is also subject to the condition that the lessee will use the land only for “pastoral purposes” as defined in s 3(1): s 38(1)(d).
42 It is a function of the Board to monitor and administer the conditions to which pastoral leases are subject. To that end, a pastoral lease is made subject to the reservation of a right of entry and inspection in favour of the Minister or a member of the Board: ss 29(h), 38(1)(a). Breach of the conditions of a pastoral lease may result in action by the Minister under s 40 of the Pastoral Land Act, including the forfeiture of the lease.
43 When exercising a power or performing a function under the Pastoral Land Act, the Minister and the Board are obliged to act consistently with, and to seek to further the objects of, the Act: s 5. The objects relevantly include that in s 4(c), namely to recognise the right of Aboriginal persons to follow traditional pursuits on pastoral land.
44 Section 86(1) provides that a pastoral lessee who wishes to use all or part of the land the subject of a pastoral lease for a non-pastoral purpose may, in the form the Board requires, apply to the Board for a non-pastoral use permit. Before considering any such application, the Board may request from the lessee such additional information relating to the proposed use as it thinks fit, and it may defer consideration of the application until the information is provided: s 86(2).
45 Section 85A(1) is as follows:
85A Non-pastoral use permit
(1) The Board may, on application by a pastoral lessee under section 86(1), grant the lessee a non-pastoral use permit to use all or part of the land the subject of the lessee’s pastoral lease for a purpose that is not a pastoral purpose (a non-pastoral purpose).
46 A non-pastoral use permit is registrable under the Land Title Act 2000 (NT). Upon registration, the permit gives the lessee of the land to which the permit relates the right to use the land the subject of the lease for non-pastoral purposes to the extent specified in the permit: Pastoral Land Act, s 85B(3).
47 Section 87A requires that public notice be given of an application made under s 86. It is as follows:
87A Public notice of application
(1) Before making a decision on an application the Board must give public notice of the application.
(2) The Board may determine the manner in which the public notice is to be given.
(3) The notice must:
(a) give details of the application; and
(b) be in the form approved by the Board; and
(c) invite any person who is interested in doing so to make written submissions to the Board about the application within the time specified in the notice (which must be not less than 14 days after the date the notice is first published).
48 Section 87(2) prescribes matters the Board must take into account in relation to such an application. They include “the likely effect of the proposed use on the environment” (s 87(2)(c)) and any submissions received in the context of the public notification process under section 87A: s 87(2)(ca). The Board may also consider or take into account any other matters as it thinks fit: s 87(2)(d). In addition, in the performance of its functions, the Board is not bound by the rules of evidence and may inform itself in such manner as it thinks fit: s 28.
49 Section 87(3A) of the Pastoral Land Act provides that the meeting of the Board at which the application is considered may be open to the public. If the meeting is open to the public, the Board must invite the applicant and any person who made a submission under s 87A to attend and provide them with a reasonable opportunity to address the Board: s 87(3B).
50 In addition to the public notification requirement in s 87A, s 87(2A) requires that:
… if the grant of the non-pastoral use permit by the Board would be a future act to which Part 2, Division 3, Subdivision G of the [Native Title Act] applies, the Board must comply with the requirements of Part 2, Division 3, subdivision G of the [Native Title Act] in considering the application.
51 That provision has the effect of imposing, as a condition on the Board’s powers under Northern Territory law, a requirement to comply with the notification requirements set out in s 24GB(9) of the Native Title Act, extracted above. Implicitly, it also requires that in the exercise of the power conferred under s 85A of the Pastoral Land Act, the Board must have regard to submissions made by Aboriginal persons notified under the Native Title Act provisions. Those obligations arise only if the act of granting the permit “would be a future act to which Part 2, Division 3, Subdivision G of the [Native Title Act] applies”.
52 An issue arises as to whether material non-compliance with the notification requirements in s 24GB(9) of the Native Title Act may constitute jurisdictional error and so render a purported exercise of power under s 85A of the Pastoral Land Act invalid.
53 Section 88 of the Pastoral Land Act confers a power on the Board to impose such conditions on a non-pastoral use permit as it “considers appropriate”. The imposed conditions must be specified in the permit.
54 A non-pastoral use permit may be varied by the Board of its own initiative in accordance with s 89B, having regard to (among other things) the extent of a lessee’s compliance with the conditions of the permit. A non-pastoral use permit may also be suspended under s 89D or revoked under s 89E by reference to a lessee’s conduct or non-compliance.
Events culminating in the Tourism Decision
55 To understand the Grounds of review relating to the Tourism Permit it is necessary to set out in some detail the events culminating in the decision to issue it.
56 On 12 April 2022 the Lessees lodged an application for non-pastoral use of the pastoral land comprising PL 757 by filling out and lodging a form with the Department then responsible for assisting with the administration of the Pastoral Land Act. The responsible Department was later changed, but the change does not affect the narrative that follows.
57 The application lodged on 12 April 2022 will be referred to as the Permit Application.
58 The selected non-pastoral use identified in the Permit Application was “tourism”. The permit was sought for the remaining period of PL 757, being 17 years to the end of 2039.
59 The form is said to have been completed by a named consultant and “Lorella Springs Owners and Managers, Marie and Rhett Walker”. The application was made in circumstances where activities in the form of commercial tourism had been carried out on the land comprising Lorella Springs for many years without the Lessees or any other person having first obtained a permit authorising those activities. Some curious features of the application form and the events that followed are to be understood against that history of use.
60 Part 4 of the form is headed “Non-Pastoral Use Details”. The form prompted the proponent to “provide a list of the proposed use/s, stating which use [was contemplated] in each nominated area”. In response to that prompt, the Lessees inserted this table:
Name | Capacity (maximum number of people) | Proposed Use – Infrastructure/camp area | Area (m²) |
Standard Rooms | 8 | 8 single rooms, no ensuite (staff accommodation) | 50 |
Small cabins | 8 | 4 double rooms with ensuite (staff and family accommodation) | 50 |
Family cabin | 20 | 6 Individual cabins with ensuite | 50 |
Deluxe rooms | 32 | 16 double rooms with ensuite – 1 queen bed or 2 single beds | 500 |
Lorella Homestead Bar/restaurant | 100* | 200 sqm outside deck dining area. Food kitchen and toilets | 200 |
Lorella homestead campground | 250 | 5 Toilet and shower blocks (approx. 30 toilets and 30 showers) 100 Vehicles | 800 |
Total number of people / accommodation per night | 318 | Main tourism accommodation facilities area (see Attachment C. Figure 3) | 240,000 (24 ha) |
*Total 100 pax bar/restaurant not included in max. capacity (based on accommodation)
Note: Tracks, small infrastructure or natural features – for example campfire pits or swimming holes – used by tourism have not been included, as per DEPWS advice on 12 January 2021.
61 As can be seen, that description identifies areas of tourist accommodation and facilities ranging from rooms, cabins, a homestead, bar and restaurant, and campground collectively covering 240,000 m2 (24 ha), all of which already existed.
62 The form then prompted the proponent to attach a development plan, being a map showing the “proposed non-pastoral use extent/layout”. That part of the form contains instructions for the presentation of such a map, as follows:
The plan is a map or drawing made to scale showing the geo-referenced location of the proposed use(s) numbered or identified as listed in the above table. Different plans may be required for uses at different scales. The plan must be provided as a digital spatial file such as shapefile or KML.
The plan must contain:
• the map datum (e.g. GDA94) used to locate each area;
• the map projection or zone;
• a north arrow;
• a suitable background (e.g. cadastre showing property boundaries, satellite/aerial imagery or topographic map);
Useful free applications include:
• Desktop: NR Maps, Google Earth Pro and QGIS
• Mobile: SW Maps, Google Maps and Google Earth
For assistance contact the Land Development Coordination Branch (DEPWS) on 8999 4454 or email: PastoralAssessment.DEPWS@nt.gov.au.
63 In response to that prompt the Lessees supplied maps at Attachment C (also referred to in the last row of their table of uses). Part 4.3 of the form prompted the proponent to provide a comprehensive description of the proposal and its “potential impact to the lease”. The Lessees addressed that requirement in Attachment D.
64 When asked to provide cost estimates of the infrastructure or developments, the Lessees identified that there would be “$0 capital expenditure required” because existing infrastructure would be used. The infrastructure was described as “accommodation, bar/restaurant, vehicle tracks/roads”. Similarly, when asked to describe the staging of the development, the Lessees stated that no further works were required because most of the “existing tourism infrastructure has been developed since 2015” and further development had been undertaken in 2017 and 2020.
65 When prompted to give an accurate description of the site (including any possible environmental impacts), the Lessees gave a detailed description of the geological and topographical features of the whole of the area covered by PL 757, referring again to Attachments C and D and describing it as covering 1 million acres of diverse landscape comprised of 128 land systems. The Lessees’ description of weeds and weed management included references to a location known as Rosie Creek.
66 They described the potential impact in the following terms:
Potential impacts to the site values from tourism is expected to be low.
Lorella Springs is also a wilderness park. The objective is to protect and preserve its natural features. This is achieved through and implementing policies and permits to protect the environment from tourism (See Attachment L).
Tourism numbers at Lorella are between 12,000 to 15,000 persons per year (65 to 80 per day). This number of visitors spread over a portion of the 1 million acres is not significant. Limiting tourism activities to 6 months of the year (dry season) allows the environment to regenerate with no tourism during the wet season.
The existing roads and tracks which are currently used for station use and property management are dually used for tourist vehicle access.
An impact assessment of the site values has been addressed in Attachment G NT EPA pre-referral screening.
(emphasis added)
67 The Lessees went on to disclose that they required a water extraction licence and that an application for that licence was yet to be lodged. Later in the form the Lessees disclosed that between October and March only a bore solar pump was used for water extraction “for domestic purpose only as no tourism during this time”, and that between April and September water was pumped into the campground for ablution and irrigation during the day.
68 Part 13 of the form is titled “Heritage and Sacred Sites”. The Lessees there provided the results of a Declared Heritage Search at Attachment K, and again referred to Attachment C. They disclosed the existence of sacred or significant sites protected under the Northern Territory Aboriginal Sacred Sites Act 1989 (NT) and supplied (as Attachment L) an abstract of records from the Aboriginal Areas Protection Authority (AAPA).
69 In a table outlining risk mitigation measures the Lessees stated:
• Aboriginal archaeological sites to be avoided from all tourism activity
• No additional construction / disturbance proposed
• Lorella rules for tourists:
• Use of existing access tracks / no driving off formed tracks
• Only swimming in designated areas
• Restricted access
70 The maps comprising Attachment C were referred to at some length in the course of the hearing. They paint a confusing picture against the information in the remainder of the Permit Application in that the area to be utilised for tourism is left uncertain. The maps depict a “main tourism area” of 24 ha in the vicinity of Lorella Homestead, a very small proportion of the overall 3,840 km2 covered by PL 757. That is the area referred to in Part 4 of the application form. However, the depiction of that small area is difficult to understand against the statement that the 12,000 to 15,000 visitors a year would be “spread over a portion of the 1 million acres”. Also attached to the Permit Application were Tourism Brochures used in connection with that tourism. The provision of the Tourism Brochures further confuses the picture with their references to locations across PL 757, in some instances long distances from the “main tourism area”.
71 In addition, the maps provided by the Lessees did not accord with the guidance for the provision of precise maps with geospatial references as prompted by the form.
72 Attachment D describes the proposed tourism activities. Given its significance for the applicant’s argument it is here set out in full:
Attachment D – Proposal description and its potential impact to the lease.
Total number of visitors each year may range from 12,000 to 15,000 during the Dry Season and commence in approximately March and finish in approximately October each year – depending on access and weather. Tourist activities are conducted in an environmentally sensitive and sustainable manner with an emphasis on environmentally conscious tourism.
Cattle are run on the property year-round, and tourism does not impact on the pastoral use aspect. The tourism supplements income for 6 months of the year and provides more employment opportunities during the tourist season.
Tourism activities do not negatively impact the pastoral enterprise. Lorella manages any potential impacts on pastoral activities by tourism by implementing rules and permits for tourists to abide with. Such as the implementation of:
• no-go zones for pastoral use and environmental reasons
• tourism access outside of the fenced cattle grazing areas
• access restrictions at certain times of the year such as cattle mustering
• ensuring tourists leave gates how they find them
• limiting noise by restricted generator operating hours
• speed limit restrictions to reduce dust and prevent disturbance to cattle.
See Attached [sic] L for Lorella rules and permits.
Activities carried out by tourists at Lorella include:
• bush camping
• accommodation (cabins & motel rooms)
• fishing
• boating
• bush walking
• photography
• bird watching
• swimming
• 4x4 driving
• helicopter tours (see further details below)
• station based activities.
The helicopter tours are currently operated by Northern Helicopter Charter and a Robinson 44 helicopter is based at Lorella Springs during the tourist season and offers scenic flights and helitours.
See attachment M for Lorella tourism maps and location of activities.
Accommodation is available in cabins (4 cabins) and motel rooms (20 rooms) built for this purpose. Each room has its own en-suite. The cabins were built originally for staff accommodation and are approximately 7 years old and the motel accommodation was built in 2015, 2017, 2020. This accommodation is separate to the station and staff residence.
Camping at the main campground, which is located around the station homestead, has the use of scattered small un-powered amenities blocks containing toilets and showers with wastewater septic systems. The main campground houses a bar and restaurant facilities with a large deck area for dining.
Bush camping has no fixed structures and the only facilities which are provided are mowed areas under native trees and (along with swimming, bushwalking, 4x4 driving etc) is accessed by dirt and gravel tracks which were created by and for the use of the station staff. Many of the activities within the station are also undertaken on foot, as the terrain makes access difficult.
There is no tourism infrastructure (besides roads/tracks) outside the main campground.
73 The expression of that description in the present tense is explained by the circumstance that the proposed permit was for activities that were presently carried on notwithstanding the absence of a permit. That was confirmed in correspondence from the Lessees’ consultant in the context of an Aboriginal heritage search, in which it was said that the tourism areas were “well established”.
74 Nothing in the Permit Application suggested that the proposed non-pastoral use purpose would be any different from the activities described in the Tourism Brochures. The Tourism Brochures depict sites of interest well outside of the 24 ha “main tourist area” described in Attachment C, some of which will be the subject of consideration later in these reasons. One page of a Tourism Brochure names and describes 10 destinations and activities within “Lorella Springs Wilderness Park”. No reference is made in those descriptions to pastoral activities, other than a mention that a particular hot springs attraction might be closed at certain times of the year when cattle mustering is occurring.
75 Another Tourism Brochure depicts 38 locations. With the exception of the closed hot springs at times of mustering, none of the descriptions relate to the observation of the activities of the pastoral station itself. Nor are activities of that kind mentioned in the descriptions of 23 destinations promoted on another brochure page. The many locations referred to in the Tourism Brochures are not confined to the 24 ha described within the body of the application form itself.
76 On 17 June 2022, NLC and Top End received a notice given (or purportedly given) under s 24GB(9)(c) of the Native Title Act (First Native Title Notification). It described a proposed future act in the following terms:
The Proposed Future Act is the grant of a permit to the lessee of Lorella Springs Station, being Maximus No. 82 Pty. Limited & Landmark Developments Pty. Limited, pursuant to section 85A of the Pastoral Land Act to allow approximately:
• 24 hectares of the non-exclusive pastoral lease to be used for non-pastoral purposes being farm tourism operations.
Section 24GB(7) of the [Native Title Act] provides that native title holders may be entitled to compensation in accordance with Division 5 of Part 2 of the [Native Title Act].
77 The “Background” gave this description:
The proposed permit for a non-pastoral use of pastoral land involves the utilising of approximately 24 hectares of land for the purpose of tourist restaurant, accommodation and campground facilities (farm tourism) operations on Lorella Springs Station (“the Proposed Future Act”).
78 The First Native Title Notification went on to invite Top End to make a submission regarding the proposed future act (as described) and to state that the comment would be taken into account by the Board “in considering whether or not, and in what manner, to proceed with the Proposed Future Act”.
79 A cover letter to the First Native Title Notification contained a link to an online applications webpage where the Permit Application (including the Attachments referred to above) could be viewed. The webpage also contained a “spatial data file” that could not be accessed other than with specialised software.
80 The webpage was also the means by which public notice was given of the Permit Application, in accordance with or purportedly in accordance with s 87A of the Pastoral Land Act.
81 By letter dated 15 September 2022, the NLC made submissions to the Board on behalf of Top End and the native title holders. It incorporated and annexed submissions made on the same date by the Chief Executive Officer of the NLC. The submissions were to the effect that:
The proposed future act (being the grant of the Tourism Permit) was not covered by s 24GB of the Native Title Act and accordingly the permit could not be validly granted in the absence of an Indigenous Land Use Agreement (ILUA).
The Board must take into account the objects of the Pastoral Land Act, the matters referred to in s 87 and the matters referred to in [6] of the Non-Pastoral Use Guidelines (NPU Guidelines).
It was plain that tourism operations were in fact carried out on a much larger scale than the 24 ha nominated on the Permit Application, as evidenced by the Tourism Brochures, the description of tourism activities and the anticipated number of visitors who were said in the Permit Application to be “spread over a portion of the 1 million acres”, as well as extrinsic materials. It was also clear that those activities had been undertaken for more than 20 years.
The extrinsic materials included a website for the Lorella Springs Wilderness Park, the contents of a booklet titled “FAQ Lorella Springs Station 2021”, the Northern Territory’s own tourism website promoting “Lorella Springs Wilderness”, and submissions made on behalf of the Lessees in 2018 to the Aboriginal Land Commissioner. The latter submission included this statement, made on behalf of the Lessees:
Over the past thirty years I estimate we have invested over $4,000,000 in Lorella’s tourism and recreational activity infrastructure, along with thousands of hours of labour by me and my family.
The proposed tourism activities were likely to require or permit the use of the majority of the lease area for non-pastoral purposes within the meaning of s 24GB(4)(a).
The Board should require the Lessees to obtain a non-pastoral use permit over all areas that were in fact used for tourism.
The native title holders had never been properly consulted about the tourism operations.
The Board and Minister had ignored their obligations under the Pastoral Land Act by allowing the tourism operations to continue for so many years without a permit, and no permit should be granted until an ILUA had been made concerning the doing of the relevant act.
There were sacred sites and heritage places at Lorella Springs within the meaning of the Sacred Sites Act in respect of which NLC had functions and responsibilities under the Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cth). The protection of those sites was a matter of utmost concern to the native title holders. As thousands of tourists visit Lorella Springs each year, there was a high likelihood of damage to those sites in the absence of an agreement providing for their protection.
The records of AAPA showed the existence of registered sites, many of which could be and were accessed by tourists, as evidenced by the Tourism Brochures. The sites would be violated notwithstanding the statement on the Permit Application that they would be “avoided”. The Tourism Brochures themselves actively promoted visitors to the sites, including by advertising rock art. The sites were of high cultural heritage value and yet there were no conditions prohibiting visits to them.
There were other sacred sites not registered with AAPA, and the Board and the Lessees were on notice of a real and foreseeable risk of their desecration.
The Board should provide the documents referred to in the Permit Application to NLC and the native title holders, including a copy of the advice that had been given to the Lessees (referred to on the face of the Permit Application) and a copy of a map referred to in an attachment to the Permit Application relating to sacred sites.
The Permit Application otherwise gave rise to environmental concerns specifically relating to weed management.
The grant of the permit would detrimentally affect the native title holders’ exercise and enjoyment of their rights and interests, including their right to access, remain and use the area, their right to access and take resources from the area, and their right to protect places, areas and things of traditional significance. An ILUA was required to ensure that the rights and interests of the native title holders could co-exist with the tourism activities.
82 Accompanying NLC’s submissions was a letter from the operators of Lorella Springs used in connection with the then-ongoing tourism activities. Dated 1 March 2021, it promoted a number of attractions across the whole of PL 757 and included the following words:
A small part of Lorella operates as a cattle station …
…
A small part operates as a cattle station, but on some of it, until now, no white man has ever trod. You may be the first person to explore that piece of the world.
…
Giant prehistoric fossils have been found nearby. Perhaps you may have the next dinosaur named after you! Around it is wilderness reserve land, Aboriginal Land and Ocean frontage to the barely investigated Gulf of Carpentaria. There are hundreds of kilometres of untouched rivers, creeks and billabongs …
…
There are so many destinations to see and things to do – whether you just would like to do some scenic four-wheel driving, checking out swimming holes and waterfalls…exploring bat caves…Or perhaps you are a little keener and would like to test out your recovery gear? Then maybe you should make a trip to our Rosie Fishing Camp or the recently blazed track out to the river mouth to our northwest The Secret Fishing Spot for the ultimate in remote, raw, pristine fishing, or simply to experience this magnificent remote untouched stretch of coastline with one of the only few access points to the Gulf of Carpentaria.
…
83 In November 2022, the Department provided a briefing paper to the Board, including an assessment of the Permit Application against the NPU Guidelines and a summary of the submissions that had been made in respect of it. Among other things, the briefing paper identified that the Permit Application indicated that tourism activities will occur outside of the proposed non-pastoral use area and that it described “rock art” as an attraction. It noted that the submission of NLC gave rise to significant concerns and recommended that the Board request further information from the Lessees under s 86(2) of the Pastoral Land Act and defer its consideration of the Permit Application until the information was provided.
84 By a notice given on 10 November 2022, the Board invited the Lessees to provide further information, including a traffic impact statement and information on water extraction licensing (Information Notice). In addition, the notice stated:
Clarification on the actual proposal footprint, including details, descriptions, maps and spatial data on all tourism activity areas and access tracks used, is required.
85 As detailed elsewhere in these reasons, on 19 June 2023, the Lessees made an application under the Water Act for a water extraction licence to take 31.2 ML of water during the dry season. That application referred to a tourism area of 24 ha and proposed an extraction point from Rosie Creek. It ran its course in parallel with the processes culminating in the Tourism Decision. The grant of the Water Extraction Licence was ultimately affirmed by the Minister in September 2024.
86 In circumstances described below, in the period following the Information Notice, the Lessees and employees of the Department jointly formulated a new permit area consisting of tracks across PL 757 connecting visitor attraction points and measured the areas covered by those tracks. The newly described area covered 3,497.11 ha.
87 On 11 June 2024, NLC and Top End received a further notice of the Permit Application pursuant to (or purportedly pursuant to) s 24GB(9)(c) of the Native Title Act. I will refer to that as the Second Native Title Notification. It described the proposed future act in the following terms:
The Proposed Future Act is the grant of a permit to the lessee of Lorella Springs Station, being Maximus No. 82 Pty. Limited & Landmark Developments Pty. Limited, pursuant to section 85A of the Pastoral Land Act 1992 to allow approximately:
• 3497 hectares of the non-exclusive pastoral lease to be used for non-pastoral purposes being farm tourism operations.
Section 24GB(7) of the [Native Title Act] provides that native title holders may be entitled to compensation in accordance with Division 5 of Part 2 of the [Native Title Act].
88 At the same time, a further public notice relating to the Permit Application was published online (Second Public Notification). The Second Public Notification did not refer to a permit area. It linked “application documents” in the same terms as the original Permit Application with the site layout map unchanged and without any alteration to their content. The Second Public Notification was, however, accompanied by the following additional materials:
(1) comments from AAPA and extracts from its records;
(2) a Google Earth Map titled “LORELLA – Proposed Area for NPU” depicting tracks across PL 757;
(3) the Lessees’ response to the first assessment dated 24 April 2024; and
(4) a spatial data file that could not be accessed other than with specialised software.
89 In its submissions in response, NLC contended that the Second Native Title Notification did not contain a clear description of the area to be affected by the proposed future act and so did not satisfy the statutory notification requirements. NLC also submitted that the Board had no power to vary an application and that its powers were limited to deciding whether the Permit Application, as made, should be granted (and, if so, with or without conditions) and that it was necessary for a fresh application to be made. NLC went on to re-state concerns it had previously raised in relation to the coverage of s 24GB of the Native Title Act, including that the proposed tourism was not “farm tourism” and that the activities proposed by the Lessees would involve people observing cultural works of Aboriginal people. As a consequence, it submitted, an ILUA was necessary before the Board could commit to the proposed act of granting the permit. It submitted that the Lessees had not adequately addressed the issues raised in the first assessment relating to environmental impacts and Aboriginal heritage and sacred sites. On the topic of sacred sites, NLC submitted that:
No certificate under the Sacred Sites Act (Authority Certificate) had been issued by AAPA or provided to the Board in accordance with the NPU Guidelines.
The material lodged with the application advertised the locations of Aboriginal caves, rock art and paintings as tourist attractions, contrary to the Lessees’ submission that accessible sacred sites would not be visible.
At least six tourist locations referred to in the Permit Application appeared to intersect with AAPA registered and/or recorded sacred sites.
As the Lessees had been conducting tourism operations “unregulated for decades”, there was a real risk that the sacred sites would be or had already been interfered with or damaged by those activities.
90 The Department then issued a further assessment to the Lessees, referred to in submissions as the “Second Technical Assessment”. Among other things, it summarised the submissions made by NLC, observations that had been made by AAPA, and risks to the protection of sacred sites in the absence of an Authority Certificate.
91 In their written response, the Lessees maintained that their mapping demonstrated that tourism activities would primarily take place at the homestead and on pastoral tracks, being areas in which native title rights and interests had been determined not to exist. They further contended that the tourism activities would not take place on a majority of the leasehold area, and that no observation of cultural works or the activities of Aboriginal people would occur. They alleged that they had lines of communication with traditional owners to discuss cultural matters and to ensure that cultural activities could not be observed.
92 The Department prepared a Recommendation Report for the Board. In summary, it recommended that the Board grant a non-pastoral use permit, subject to the imposition of three conditions under s 88(2) of the Pastoral Land Act, namely:
1. The permit holder must ensure that all activities subject to this Permit are carried out in accordance with the Endorsed Plan [number to be confirmed].
2. An annual fee for this permit is payable by the permit holder under section 85D of the Pastoral Land Act 1992 from the date of this Permit and continuing throughout the Term (and any extension of the Term), in accordance with notices issued by the Pastoral Land Board from time to time.
3. The Permit Holder must obtain an Authority Certificate.
93 The Recommendation Report did not include any Endorsed Plan as then proposed.
94 The Recommendation Report said that the Board should proceed on the basis that the grant of the Tourism Permit would be a future act covered by s 24GB(2) of the Native Title Act. The latter recommendation was based on an acceptance of the Lessees’ position that only one rock art site was ever visible to tourists and that access to that site would be restricted.
95 A public hearing relating to the Permit Application took place on 19 March 2025. The Recommendation Report was provided to NLC and the native title holders in advance of the meeting. The papers provided to the Board itself in advance of that meeting included the Recommendation Report, a draft non-pastoral use permit and a map marking up a “Proposed NPU Area” of 155,732 ha. Neither party could explain how the 155,732 ha area was arrived at. It was not a figure any interested party was informed about at the public meeting, it was not said to have been a figure put forward by the Lessees and, as will be seen, it did not form a part of the decision ultimately made by the Board.
96 The Board heard submissions from representatives of NLC, the native title holders and the Lessees. It received information from some native title holders about the impact of the ongoing tourism activities, including tourists roaming off the pastoral tracks, alleged interference with skeletal remains and destruction of two Dreaming sites by the Lessees in constructing a track with a grader.
97 In its deliberations following the public meeting, the Board determined that the Tourism Permit should be granted for a period of 10 years, subject to the conditions suggested in the Recommendation Report. The Board determined that there should be a further condition confining the non-pastoral use to an area to be described in an “Endorsed Plan”. As discussed below, the Board used the mechanism of an “Endorsed Plan” to delineate the area within PL 757 on which the tourism activities were to be permitted. The Board’s decision to grant the Tourism Permit was subject to its review of the endorsed plan. The Board then resolved that the endorsed plan was to be prepared by a Board member and an officer from within the Department.
98 The manner in which the endorsed plan was then finalised is the subject of a Ground of review and will be detailed later in these reasons.
99 On 28 March 2025, the Board approved an endorsed plan presented to it after making some minor corrections and on 31 March 2025 it issued the Tourism Permit.
The Tourism Permit
100 The Tourism Permit is subject to four Conditions. It states, in part:
DEFINITIONS
In this Permit:
“Endorsed Plan” means any plan subject to the conditions of the Permit that has been endorsed by the Board as forming part of this Permit.
“Permit Holder” means the Pastoral Lessee.
SCHEDULE OF CONDITIONS
1. The Permit Holder must ensure that all activities and works subject to this Permit are carried out in accordance with the Endorsed Plans NPU25/01-001-NPU25/01-009.
2. An annual fee for this permit is payable by the Permit Holder under section 85D of the Pastoral Land Act 1992 from the date of this Permit and continuing throughout the Term (and any extension of the Term), in accordance with notices issued by the Pastoral Land Board from time to time.
3. Prior to commencing any activities permitted by the Approved Purpose on the Pastoral Lease for which a non-pastoral use permit is required, the Permit Holder must obtain an Authority Certificate under the Northern Territory Aboriginal Sacred Sites Act 1989, and provide a copy of the Authority Certificate to the Pastoral Land Board.
4. This permit does not authorise tourism activities that involve the observation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultural works or activities.
…
NOTES
1. This permit will be revoked automatically upon the termination or surrender of the Pastoral Lease. For the avoidance of doubt, a transfer of the Pastoral Lease does not revoke this Permit.
…
11. Tourism activities that do not require a non-pastoral use permit may continue on the pastoral lease prior to the issue of an Authority Certificate by AAPA.
The Endorsed Plan
101 I will now refer to the Endorsed Plan as the plan referred to on the face of the Tourism Permit in fact issued. It takes the form of a series of maps depicting the area covered by PL 757. Within those maps there appear areas marked with green hatching. That is the area ultimately decided by the Board to be the subject of the non-pastoral use permit. I will refer to it as the Endorsed Plan Area.
102 The Endorsed Plan Area omits some places originally proposed by the Lessees. It also depicts the 1 km corridor traversing PL 757 between the allowed tourism attractions (comprised of roads with a 500 m radius on each side) together with areas around each attraction in most instances of a 1 km radius, but in other instances a 500 m radius.
103 Importantly for some of the Grounds of review, the Endorsed Plan Area also includes an area of land that is isolated from all of the other areas, referred to at times in the course of submissions as the Island Area. It is considerable in size, covering approximately 3,440 ha. The inclusion of the Island Area did not form a part of any public notification processes. The Territory could not explain it. As the Board and the Lessees did not participate in the proceedings no explanation was forthcoming from them either. How a tourist might access the Island Area without traversing places that are not permitted for non-pastoral use was not explained.
104 The Endorsed Plan also depicts areas of pink hatching. I will refer to them as restricted zones. They correspond with zones around sites recorded by AAPA.
Written reasons of the Board
105 A notice of consent issued to the Lessees outlines the Board’s Reasons for issuing the Tourism Permit. In the Reasons, the Board stated that the Lessees’ application had been re-advertised “due to an amendment to increase the area of land”. It stated that the proposal would see tourists using tracks and camping in areas covering approximately 3,497.11 ha, including access tracks leading to natural features such as waterways, billabongs, swamps and wetlands. However, later in the Reasons the Board confirmed that the area approved under the endorsed plans was 60,257 ha.
106 The Board referred to the need for there to be an Authority Certificate issued by AAPA and recorded its conclusion that there should be a condition that one be obtained. On that topic, the Board said:
The Board is aware that the applicant has applied to AAPA for an Authority Certificate. The Board also notes the advice dated 11 July 2023 from AAPA that the application for an Authority Certificate has been suspended, based on advice from the NLC that an ILUA is required for the grant of the permit. The grant of this permit without a requirement for an ILUA provides an opportunity for AAPA to reconsider the status of the application currently before it.
107 The Board said that the grant of the permit was a future act that fell within s 24GB(2) of the Native Title Act, including because the activity permitted was “farm tourism”, construing those words by reference to the Explanatory Memorandum to the Native Title Amendment Bill 1997 (Cth). The Board continued:
Accordingly, the term “farm tourism” encompasses tourism directed at experiencing primary production activities (i.e., a pastoral enterprise) and tourism focused on the land’s natural features and wildlife. However, it excludes activities involving the observation of Aboriginal/Torres Strait Islander cultural works or activities (e.g., rock art), which would require an ILUA.
The Lorella tourism experience involves observing the pastoral enterprise, as well as overnight stays for the purpose of enjoying the natural environment and non-Indigenous cultural sites. Therefore, the Board is of the view that the grant of a permit would fall within s24GB(2) of the Native Title Act 1993. The Board has also placed a condition on the permit that the permit does not authorise tourism that involves the observation of Aboriginal/Torres Strait Islander cultural works or activities.
Additionally, the applicant has stated that only one rock art site has ever been visible to tourists at Lorella and that measures have now been implemented to prevent further visibility. Diversion tracks have been established, which the applicant stated have successfully deterred access to the site.
108 The Board mentioned that the areas around the tracks had been enlarged to include a 500 m radius either side of them. The reasons for that enlargement are unclear. The Board also said that a radius of 1 km had been provided for around each promoted tourism attraction. It went on to say that a buffer of less than 1 km had been specified in relation to four attraction points because of their proximity to recorded sacred sites.
109 The Board stated that the AAPA record had been georeferenced so that recorded sites could be compared with the sites and tracks mentioned in the Lessees’ application. The Board said that it had omitted some tracks and attraction points from the permit area because of their proximity to recorded sacred sites.
110 The Board said that it had included in the Endorsed Plan areas in the immediate vicinity of the homestead, main accommodation area, airstrip, main access road and other facilities. It acknowledged that those areas overlapped with recorded sacred sites and a restricted zone. It said that a track known as “Carpentaria Track” had been included “for reasons of access”, that the track directly passed a recorded sacred site aligning with an attraction point, and that the attraction point had been removed from the Endorsed Plan.
RESOLUTION OF THE TOURISM PERMIT GROUNDS
111 Broadly summarised, the contentions underpinning the Grounds relating to the Tourism Decision are to the effect that:
(1) if a valid exercise of the power conferred by s 85A of the Pastoral Land Act, the act granting the Tourism Permit is not a future act covered by s 24GB of the Native Title Act and hence it is not a valid future act for the purposes of the Native Title Act because:
(a) the future act did not permit “farm tourism” within the meaning of s 24GB(2)(b) but rather authorised the use of PL 757 as a wilderness park having no substantive connection to pastoral activities; and
(b) the future act had the effect of permitting tourism activities that involved observing the activities or cultural works of Aboriginal people within the meaning of s 24GB(3); and
(2) the decision to grant the Tourism Permit was not a valid exercise of the power conferred under s 85A of the Pastoral Land Act, because:
(a) the imposition of Condition 4 was legally unreasonable because it is inconsistent with Condition 1;
(b) when imposing Condition 4 in conjunction with Condition 1, the Board exercised the power under s 88 of the Pastoral Land Act for the improper purpose of securing (or purporting to secure) the coverage of s 24GB of the Native Title Act;
(c) the Board failed to comply with statutory obligations relating to the notification of the Permit Application under both s 24GB(9) of the Native Title Act and s 87(2) of the Pastoral Land Act because the notifications did not give a clear description of the proposed affected area;
(d) the Board did not decide the application that had been lodged by the Lessees but instead made a decision that had not been sought; and
(e) the Board otherwise failed to comply with its obligation to afford procedural fairness by failing to afford NLC and the native title holders an opportunity to be heard in respect of the Tourism Decision it ultimately made, or communications passing between it (or its representatives) and the Lessees.
112 It is convenient to decide issues arising under the future act provisions of the Native Title Act first, as that is the order in which the declaratory relief is sought.
113 To decide the questions arising under the Native Title Act it will be necessary to bring forward into that analysis some of the Grounds for judicial review impugning the Tourism Decision under administrative law principles, specifically those Grounds impugning the imposition of Condition 4.
The grant of the Tourism Permit is an act covered by s 24GB of the Native Title Act
Farm tourism: Ground 1(1)
114 Section 24GB of the Native Title Act is concerned with acts that permit primary production on (relevantly) certain non-exclusive pastoral leases. Subsection (1) provides that s 24GB covers certain acts permitted or required to be done in the area covered by such a lease while the lease is in force. Subsection (2) is to be construed in that context. It provides that s 24GB applies to an act that permits or requires a “farm tourism activity” in the area covered by the lease mentioned in subs (1).
115 There are disputes both as to the proper construction of the phrase “farm tourism activity” and as to the characterisation of the activities permitted to occur on PL 757 by virtue of the grant of the Tourism Permit.
116 The words “farm tourism activity” should be understood as a composite expression. Within that expression, the word “tourism” may be understood to mean an activity involving travel for pleasure, including for learning. An enterprise that hosts or guides those travelling for pleasure may be regarded as engaging in a tourism activity. A tourism activity may also be a self-directed activity undertaken by travellers themselves.
117 The Territory’s position is that the phrase encompasses hosted or guided activities undertaken by travellers on land covered by the lease to which s 24GB is directed, irrespective of whether the activities relate to those pastoral or agricultural activities carried on under the lease. Top End’s contention is that to meet the description of a farm tourism activity, the activity must involve the observation or participation in the pursuits that comprise the pastoral enterprise (here a cattle station) or that otherwise have some factual connection with that enterprise. It was not enough, Top End submitted, for there to be tourism activities that happened to occur on the land covered by the lease.
118 Section 24GB is to be construed in a manner consistent with the language and purpose of all provisions of the Native Title Act, having the statutory context: Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355 at 381 (McHugh, Gummow, Kirby and Hayne JJ).
119 Four contextual considerations bear on the proper construction of the phrase “farm tourism activities”. There is tension between them, as I will now explain.
120 The first arises from s 24GB(1). It is the starting point in determining whether s 24GB applies to a future act. In accordance with s 24GB(1) a future act will be covered if it (relevantly) permits a “primary production activity” or another “activity” on the area covered by the lease in question that is associated with or incidental to the primary production activity. The phrase “primary production activity” supplies some context for the interpretation of subs (2). The lease presently under consideration falls within s 24GB(1) because it is a non-exclusive lease permitting the holder to use the land and waters of the lease area “solely or primarily for maintaining or breeding sheep, cattle, or other animals or any other pastoral purpose”: Native Title Act, ss 248(a), 248B.
121 The second contextual consideration is to be found in the surrounding words within s 24GB(2)(b) itself. The text describes a future act having four elements to it. The future act must:
(1) permit or require;
(2) a “farm tourism activity”;
(3) in the area covered by a lease meeting the requirements of s 24GB(1)(a) and (b);
(4) while the lease is in force.
122 If the Territory’s submission in relation to s 24GB(2) were to be accepted, the word “farm” would appear to have no work to do. To achieve coverage of an act permitting tourism activities of any kind on land covered by a lease described in subs (1), the word “farm” could be omitted altogether from the second element listed above. So too could the word “activity”. If Parliament had intended coverage in respect of an act permitting tourism per se on the leased area, it need only have used the word tourism as the second element to convey that meaning. That is a strong indicator that the word “farm” is a qualifying word intended to describe particular kinds of activities that would occur on the land as a consequence of the act of granting permission.
123 On that interpretation, the expression “farm tourism activities” in s 24GB(2) is a reference to tourism activities that are factually related to the primary production activities referred to in s 24GB(1). It contemplates something other than the mere visitation and presence of tourists on the land that happens to form the subject of the lease.
124 The third contextual consideration is that s 24GB(2) supplies coverage to a future act on a factual basis that is discrete from the coverage supplied by s 24GB(1)(d)(ii). It refers to a future act that permits or requires (in addition to the pastoral activity in subs (1)(d)(i)) “another activity, on the area covered by the lease, that is associated with or incidental to a primary production activity covered by subparagraph (i), provided that, when the other activity is being carried on, the majority of the area covered by the lease is used for primary production activities”. The words in s 24GB(1)(d)(ii) do not provide support for Top End’s preferred construction of s 24GB(2), but nor do they provide compelling support for the Territory’s view. Section 24GB(1)(d)(ii) should not be understood as dealing with the same subject matter as subss (2) and (3). Given the importance of the condition in s 24GB(3), Parliament should be taken to have intended that the coverage test for an act permitting tourism is the specific prescription in subss (2) and (3), not the more general provision in subs (1)(d)(ii).
125 The fourth contextual consideration is in s 24GB(3) itself. It is expressed in the form of an exception and so should be understood as intended to carve out from s 24GB any operation that subs (1) and (2) might otherwise have. That tends to support the wider construction of the phrase “farm tourism activity” contended for by the Territory. The inclusion of s 24GB(3) recognises that the act of permitting farm tourism activities to be undertaken on the leased land may also have the effect of permitting or requiring tourism that involves observing activities or cultural works of Aboriginal peoples or Torres Strait Islanders, so necessitating an exception.
126 Expressed another way, if the phrase “farm tourism activities” was more narrowly confined to activities related to farming operations, the need for the carveout in s 24GB(3) would appear to be unnecessary.
127 The fourth contextual consideration is at odds with (at least) the second.
128 When interpreting the Native Title Act, the interpretation that best suits the purpose or object of the legislation (whether or not that purpose is expressed) should be preferred to each other interpretation: Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth), s 15AA. The Court may have regard to any material not forming part of the Native Title Act that is capable of assisting in ascertaining the meaning of s 24GB, for the purposes specified in s 15AB(1), namely:
(a) to confirm that the meaning of the provision is the ordinary meaning conveyed by the text of the provision taking into account its context in the Act and the purpose or object underlying the Act; or
(b) to determine the meaning of the provision when:
(i) the provision is ambiguous or obscure; or
(ii) the ordinary meaning conveyed by the text of the provision taking into account its context in the Act and the purpose or object underlying the Act leads to a result that is manifestly absurd or is unreasonable.
129 An occasion arises to consider the extrinsic materials under s 15AB(1)(b)(i) because there is some ambiguity or obscurity, as identified above.
130 In accordance with s 15AB(3), when deciding whether to consider extrinsic materials (or the weight to be afforded to them), the Court must have regard to:
(a) the desirability of persons being able to rely on the ordinary meaning conveyed by the text of the provision taking into account its context in the Act and the purpose or object underlying the Act; and
(b) the need to avoid prolonging legal or other proceedings without compensating advantage.
131 It is appropriate in any event to turn to the extrinsic materials, principally because both parties have made submissions in connection with them to frame their respective cases. In addition, the Court was informed that there is no prior judicial consideration of s 24GB and there is some public interest in the resolution of the issue given the likelihood that it may arise again in the context of extensive pastoral leases affecting large tracts of land in the Northern Territory and South Australia.
132 The Territory calls in aid the following passages from the Explanatory Memorandum to the Native Title Amendment Bill 1997 (Cth) (before the House of Representatives on the return of an amendment by the Senate):
What is farm tourism?
9.27 The Senate made 1997 Government amendment (19) which is included in the Bill. This amendment makes it clear that paragraph 24GB(2)(b) is not confined to farmstay tourism but extends to any tourism that takes place in relation to a farm operation. ‘Farm tourism’ would include, for example, day tours of a farming operation, as well as overnight stays. This provision continues to be subject to subsection (3). The Senate also made 1997 Government Amendment 20 which is included in the Bill. This amendment to Subsection (3), was necessary as a result of 1997 Government amendment (19) to paragraph 24GB(2)(b).
9.28 Farm tourism is not defined in the Bill but has its ordinary meaning. In essence it is an activity under which persons are involved in tourism on land and waters covered by non-exclusive agricultural and non-exclusive pastoral leases.
Farm tourism activities would include:
• observing or becoming involved in primary production activities; or
• observing and enjoying the natural environment and non-indigenous cultural activities or sites (e.g. colonial era buildings).
9.29 As noted in Table 9.2, acts that allow farm tourism involving observing Aboriginal/Torres Strait Islander activities or cultural works (e.g. rock art) will not be valid under Subdivision G (although they might be permitted under, say, an indigenous land use agreement). However, this does not exclude tourism activities that involve observing natural objects (such as wildlife or rock formations).
133 The Senate’s substitution of the word “farmstay” with “farm” is not particularly significant. As the above extract states, the intent of that amendment was to ensure the inclusion of day-time activities that were not undertaken in conjunction with overnight accommodation. The references to “any tourism that takes place in relation to a farm operation” and “day tours of a farming operation” do not support the wider construction for which the Territory contends. They each connect the tourism with the operation of the farm. The words of [9.28] and the closing words of [9.29] are more expansive. Together, they support the Territory’s contention.
134 There are further extrinsic materials before the Court, in the form of Hansard records in which a Senator responded to questions about the impact of the proposed s 24GB on the rights and interests of Aboriginal people. The question referred to the vast tracts of Country subject to pastoral leases and on which there were places of cultural significance. The question referred to the natural desire of pastoral lease holders to exploit those attractions by drawing tourists to them. The Senator explained that the concern of the questioner was addressed by the introduction of s 24GB(3), which made it plain that s 24GB would not supply coverage to an act that permitted or required tourism that involved observing activities or cultural works of Aboriginal people or Torres Strait Islanders. That exchange confirms the observation I have made above concerning the competing available interpretations of the phrase “farm tourism activities”. It confirms that s 24GB(3) was intended to supply an exception to the wide subject matter of s 24GB(2), consistent with the fourth textual consideration identified above.
135 In my view, the Explanatory Memorandum and the Hansard assist in resolving that tension in the Territory’s favour. Properly construed, the expression “farm tourism activities” should be understood to encompass all activities that may be engaged in by a tourist entering the land for the purposes of tourism (being travel for pleasure). The exception in s 24GB(3) then deals with (and excludes) a part of that very wide subject matter.
136 Whether the Board did an act having the effect of permitting “farm tourism activities” (so construed) is therefore a more straight-forward question than it would otherwise have been.
137 The Tourism Permit must be interpreted as intended to authorise a thing to be done that would not otherwise be authorised under the terms of the lease and the Pastoral Land Act. That is the purpose of the power in s 85A of the Pastoral Land Act. Importantly, the Lessees did not require the permission of the Board to use the area covered by PL 757 for pastoral purposes, as defined in s 3(1) of the Pastoral Land Act. From the definition in s 3(1) it follows that the lease itself authorises not only the pasturing of stock for commercial use on the land on which they are pastured, but other “non-dominant uses” carried out in conjunction with, or inseparable from the pastoral enterprise. Those non-dominant uses expressly include “pastoral based tourist activities such as farm holidays”. No permission is required for those non-dominant uses; the Lessees were already authorised by the Pastoral Land Act itself to carry out “pastoral based tourist activities such as farm holidays” as a non-dominant use of the land.
138 The Endorsed Plan is to be understood in the context of the activities described by the Lessees in the Permit Application, which included the Tourism Brochures.
139 It is true that the proposed tourism activities are largely (if not wholly) unrelated to cattle and their pasturing. So much is reinforced by the closure of some sites during the mustering season. The focus is principally on the natural landscape as a wilderness attraction, including flora and fauna, with a secondary focus on aspects of colonial history (such as the homestead in the “main” accommodation area). There is an emphasis on self-drive and self-sustained camping necessitating and encouraging the use of tracks spanning vast distances between “attractions”. All of that is consistent with the Lessees’ conduct of a business under the name “Lorella Springs Wilderness Park”.
140 The activities expressly promoted in the Tourism Brochures otherwise include such things as swimming, bushwalking, fishing, socialising (including food, drinks and other hospitality at and near the homestead), and observation and appreciation of wildlife and topographical features. All of these activities are permitted by virtue of the grant of the Tourism Permit. They all fall within the phrase “farm tourism activities” within the meaning of that phrase in s 24GB of the Native Title Act, properly construed. It follows that Top End’s arguments in support of Ground 1(1) must be rejected.
141 If Top End’s narrower interpretation of the expression “farm tourism activities” were to be preferred, I would have had no hesitation upholding their contention that the permitted activities did not fall within it, given the above findings.
142 The next argument concerns the construction of s 24GB(3) of the Native Title Act and its application to the facts.
The exception in s 24GB(3) was not enlivened: Ground 1(2)
143 Ground 1(2) is to the effect that by its act of issuing the Tourism Permit the Board permitted tourism that involved observing activities or cultural works of Aboriginal people within the meaning of s 24GB(3) of the Native Title Act, with the result that it was not an act covered by s 24GB. The arguments underpinning that Ground overlap with those underpinning Ground 2(2) relating to Condition 4. In the pages that follow, I explain why I have rejected Top End’s contention that the imposition of Condition 4 on the Tourism Permit was affected by legal unreasonableness or an improper purpose.
144 Resolution of Ground 1(2) requires a proper understanding of the rights, interests and responsibilities of the native title holders, being Aboriginal people who also have the benefit of express reservations under the Pastoral Land Act.
145 Under cl 9 of the Determination in Riley, the estate group members have rights that inform the question of the activities and cultural works occurring or existing on the land and waters comprising PL 757. They have rights to access, remain on and use the areas, to access and take for any purpose the resources of the area, and to protect places, areas and things of traditional significance. The rights and interests are discussed at some length in an expert report of two qualified and experienced anthropologists, Dr John J. Bradley and Dr Stephen P. Johnson. The anthropologists accepted and adopted the opinions that underpin the Determination. Their report described the continuing observance and acknowledgement of the traditional laws and customs under which the native title rights and interests are held. The anthropologists also referred to the substantial and longstanding ethnographic material underpinning the Determination and expressed their agreement with the anthropological opinions prepared for the purposes of securing it. I accept their evidence in respect of those broader topics.
146 It may be inferred from the Determination itself that the native title rights and interests described in the Determination continue to be both possessed and exercised to the present day. If the Determination did not provide sufficient support for that finding, the finding is supported in any event by the evidence of the Aboriginal witnesses in this proceeding, as interpreted by the anthropological opinions. There were four Aboriginal lay witnesses, none of whom were cross-examined on their affidavits: Rex Isaac, David Barrett, Patrick Mulholland and Yvette Bradley.
147 I unreservedly accept the evidence of Mr Isaac, Mr Barrett and Mr Mulholland (subject to rulings as to use) concerning the places at which sites of significance are situated, the meaning that those sites have for them, their continuing observance of the traditional laws and customs giving rise to those meanings, and their hurt and distress concerning the past and proposed tourism at Lorella Springs.
148 I also accept that they hold genuine beliefs (founded in traditional law and custom) concerning Aboriginal concepts of “cultural work”, discussed in more detail below. That evidence reflects their spiritual connection to Country, a connection that forms an essential element of the rights and interests recognised by this Court in Riley: Native Title Act, s 223.
149 I also accept the evidence of Ms Bradley concerning her observations on a visit to a site actively promoted in the Tourism Brochures and other marketing materials, as discussed below.
150 However, for the reasons that follow, I have ultimately accepted the Territory’s submissions as to how both s 24GB(3) of the Native Title Act and the Tourism Permit must be construed, and it is for that reason that Top End’s arguments advanced in support of Ground 1(2) and other related Grounds must be rejected.
151 Condition 4 of the Tourism Permit is a complete answer to the allegation in Ground 1(2). My reasons for that conclusion are to be understood against the findings I make in relation to Grounds 2(2) and (3) below. The focus of Ground 1(2) is on the text of the Tourism Permit in order to identify those activities that are authorised by it and those that are not.
152 The Court is to approach the Tourism Permit on the basis that it is not necessarily drafted with legal expertise and that its terms should be construed so as to work harmoniously. It is akin to an approval granted under land development laws, and so should be given a construction that is concerned with practical results: see Snowy Monaro Regional Council v Tropic Asphalts Pty Ltd [2018] NSWCCA 202; (2018) 362 ALR 359 at [34] – [35] (Bathurst CJ) and the cases cited therein. Adopting that approach, Conditions 1 and 4 can and should be read together. They are not inconsistent as Top End contends.
153 Condition 1 is that the Lessees must ensure that all activities and works subject to the Tourism Permit are carried out in accordance with the Endorsed Plan. The Endorsed Plan included maps depicting those parts of PL 757 in which the non-pastoral use (being “tourism”) is permitted. It was by the imposition of Condition 1 that the Board defined the areas in which non-pastoral uses could occur and, by implication, those areas in which they could not.
154 Condition 4 is that the Tourism Permit “does not authorise tourism activities that involve the observation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultural works or activities”. As the Territory correctly submitted, Condition 4 operates to limit the activities that might otherwise have been expressly or impliedly authorised by any other aspect of the Tourism Permit, including Condition 1.
155 The words in Condition 4 should otherwise be interpreted as having the same meaning as they have in s 24GB(3) of the Native Title Act. The word “authorise” in Condition 4 has the same meaning as “permit” in the statutory provision.
156 The defined word “permits” (as it appears in s 24GB(3) of the Native Title Act) should encompass the act of giving legal authorisation for an event or conduct that could not otherwise lawfully occur. Authorisation may be given either expressly or impliedly. I accept that implicit authorisation of conduct or an event may arise if the conduct or event is a necessary or inevitable consequence of the authorising act.
157 In its express terms, the Tourism Permit neither permits nor requires tourism activities that involve the observation of the activities or cultural works of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. Rather, Condition 4 makes it plain that the permitted activities do not include the very activities referred to in s 24GB(3) of the Native Title Act, howsoever construed. By substantially adopting the language of s 24GB(3), the Board put that beyond doubt. The effect of Condition 4 is that the exception in s 24GB(3) is not enlivened such that s 24GB applies to the future act. The implication sought by Top End is inconsistent with the express words of the Tourism Permit.
158 As discussed below, if tourists visiting Lorella Springs engage in activities that involve the observation of the activities or cultural works of Aboriginal people (whether inside the Endorsed Plan Area or outside of it), that is a state of affairs that is neither permitted nor required by any act of the Board. To the contrary, it may evidence non-compliance by the Lessees with Condition 4 (and hence the Tourism Permit) and so provide a basis for the suspension or revocation of the Tourism Permit under the enforcement provisions of the Pastoral Land Act. In addition, the native title holders may avail themselves of public and private law remedies. The potential causes of action are outlined in the Territory’s supplementary submissions filed after the conclusion of the hearing and encompass the enforcement of native title at common law, trespass, nuisance, and injunctive and declaratory relief. Top End did not challenge those legal propositions.
159 Whilst I accept that contravention of the Conditions may be difficult to detect and that the rights of the native title holders may be legally cumbersome to enforce, those circumstances do not mean that the Tourism Decision is affected by the alleged reviewable errors.
160 The focus of s 24GB(3) is upon what has been authorised by the Board, not upon what may happen in the future by reason of feared unauthorised actions of the Lessees or tourists.
161 I would reach the same conclusion irrespective of how s 24GB(3) is to be construed. Its proper construction is discussed in the Grounds that follow.
162 A different argument to the effect that the grant of the Tourism Permit had the necessary consequence of permitting the things referred to in s 24GB(3) will also be considered in the context of the Grounds that follow.
Grounds relating to Condition 4 and Note 11: Grounds 2(2), 2(3), 4 and 8A(2)
163 It is convenient to turn next to the various Grounds of review that directly or indirectly impugn Condition 4 on the Tourism Permit.
No improper purpose and legal unreasonableness: Grounds 2(2) and 2(3)
164 By Ground 2(2), Top End contended that the material before the Board and the Board’s own Reasons reveal that the Tourism Permit would permit tourism that would involve observing places, areas or things of traditional significance covered by the Determination in Riley. Accordingly, it was submitted, the Board made a decision that was unreasonable or irrational because the proposed tourism would, as a necessary and certain consequence, involve observing activities or cultural works of Aboriginal people within the meaning of s 24GB(3) of the Native Title Act. In addition, Top End contended that the Board did not exercise the condition-making power in s 88 of the Pastoral Land Act for the purposes for which that power was conferred, but instead exercised the power “for the purpose or for the substantial purpose of avoiding s 24GB(3) of the [Native Title Act]”. For the same reason, the decision to introduce Condition 4 was said to be affected by legal unreasonableness.
165 The circumstances in which a statutory power will have been exercised for an improper purpose were conveniently summarised by Martin CJ in Hunter v Minister for Planning [2012] WASC 247. His Honour said (at [24]) that the expression “improper purpose” does not necessarily connote a purpose that is corrupt, immoral or otherwise lacking in probity. His Honour went on to say:
24 … Rather, it connotes a purpose which is ulterior or extraneous in the sense that it is beyond the scope of the purposes for which the relevant power is conferred (see, for example, Thompson v Randwick Corporation (1950) 81 CLR 87 at 106; [1950] ALR 711 at 715–16; [1950] HCA 33 (Williams, Webb & Kitto JJ)). Accordingly, where the relevant power derives from legislation, the purposes for which the power has been conferred will be derived by a process of construction of the legislation: see R v Toohey; Ex Parte Northern Land Council (1981) 151 CLR 170 at 186; 38 ALR 439 at 452–3; [1981] HCA 74 per Gibbs CJ, at CLR 233; ALR per Aickin J.
25 The ulterior purpose need not be established to be the sole purpose for the exercise of the power. It will be sufficient if it is established that the purpose is a substantial purpose, in the sense that the power would not have been exercised but for the ulterior or extraneous purpose: Thompson v Randwick at CLR 106; ALR 715–16; see also Re Minister for the Environment; Ex Parte Elwood [2007] WASCA 137 at [173].
166 His Honour then emphasised that an inference of an improper purpose should not be drawn unless the evidence cannot be reconciled with the proper exercise of the power (citing Industrial Equity Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (1990) 170 CLR 649 at 672 (Gaudron J)). See also A v Corruption and Crime Commissioner [2013] WASCA 288; (2013) 306 ALR 49 at [140] (Martin CJ and Murphy JA) and South Australia v Slipper (2004) 136 FCR 259.
167 As discussed in the context of Ground 1(2), the imposition of Condition 4 also had the legal consequence that s 24GB applied to the Board’s act of permitting farm tourism activities on a part of the land subject to PL 757.
168 On the facts, I am satisfied that the coverage of s 24GB of the Native Title Act was indeed an outcome that the Board subjectively intended to achieve. That inference may be drawn from the near exact replication of the words of s 24GB(3) of the Native Title Act in Condition 4. I accept Top End’s submissions to that extent.
169 As I understood Top End’s submissions, that purpose was improper for three reasons.
170 First, it was said that Condition 4 was employed as a disguise to give the appearance that something was not permitted, when that same thing was in fact permitted (or indeed necessitated) by Condition 1. I have already rejected that submission. The two Conditions are not inconsistent for the reasons stated above.
171 Second, the submissions were to the effect that the Board was not authorised to exercise the condition-making power under s 88 of the Pastoral Land Act for the purpose of securing its desired outcome that its act would be a future act covered by s 24GB of the Native Title Act. I do not accept that submission. The Board’s Reasons indicate that it was concerned to address a submission advanced by NLC to the effect that the Tourism Permit could not be granted unless there was first an ILUA in place with the native title holders. In addition, the Board addressed the circumstance that the native title holders had sought to suspend the grant of any Authority Certificate to the Lessees by AAPA on the basis that an ILUA must first be made. It was open to the Board to utilise its powers to articulate the scope of the permission granted in words that reflected or replicated the provisions of the Native Title Act. The exercise of its powers in that way fulfilled the objective of certainty in respect of the permitted use of the land. That purpose is not alien to the Pastoral Land Act. The Pastoral Land Act is expressed in terms that interact with the Native Title Act and in my view the Board was entitled to make a decision with a view to achieving practical and legal certainty about the effect of its own act under a different but interacting law. That was especially so in circumstances where NLC had raised the need for an ILUA as an obstacle to the Board’s act and to any Authority Certificate that might otherwise be issued by AAPA.
172 Third, and relatedly, it was said that Condition 4 was ineffective, irrational and affected by an improper purpose because:
(1) observance by tourists of the activities and cultural works of Aboriginal people was, as a matter of objective fact, a necessary and natural consequence of permitting the Lessees to conduct tourism activities in the Endorsed Plan Area;
(2) accordingly, a tourism activity would “involve” such observations if the observations were a necessary circumstance, condition or consequence of what was permitted: Australian Conservation Foundation v Minister for the Environment [2021] FCA 550; (2021) 390 ALR 157 at [89] – [93] (Perry J);
(3) on any view of the facts, Condition 4 was ineffective (and knowingly so) to prevent those inevitable observations from occurring; and
(4) the imposition of Conditions 1, 2 and 4 was otherwise affected by legal unreasonableness because it was irrational to proceed on the basis that Condition 4 could ever be effective: see Friends of the Gelorup Corridor v Minister for the Environment and Water (2023) 299 FCR 236 at [62], [65] – [66] (Jackson and Kennett JJ).
173 It is necessary to summarise the considerable body of evidence upon which Top End relied concerning the nature and implications of the permitted tourism enterprise, and how it was said to meet the description of tourism that “involves observing activities or cultural works of Aboriginal peoples”.
Evidence
174 The evidence included written testimony of the native title holders as well as mapping and other data depicting the location of sacred and significant sites. In addition, Top End referred to the native title rights and interests as recognised in the Determination in Riley. I have already accepted the evidentiary significance of that Determination.
175 The evidence may be considered by reference to two geographical areas. The first is the area identified with green hatching and a corresponding legend in the Endorsed Plan defining the area where non-pastoral use may occur, subject to Condition 4. I have referred to that as the Endorsed Plan Area. The following propositions are agreed:
(1) within the Endorsed Plan Area there are places, areas and things of traditional significance that are subject to native title rights and interests described in clauses 9(c) and 14(i) of the Determination in Riley; and
(2) within the Endorsed Plan Area there are also places and areas where native title holders under the Determination may, subject to the full terms and effect of the Determination, do the activities within the meaning of cl 14(g) and (i) of the Determination (being the activities mentioned at [11] above).
176 The second category is those places falling outside of the Endorsed Plan Area.
177 There are several sites falling within each category. I have had regard to the whole of the evidence, but have especially focussed on the sites listed below as they collectively illustrate the issues in dispute across the whole of PL 757.
Maps
178 There are a number of maps in evidence. They include the maps defining the Endorsed Plan Area (forming part of the Tourism Permit itself) as well as a series of maps prepared by Alexandre Coutinho, a Geographic Information Systems Officer employed by NLC. Mr Coutinho overlaid the Endorsed Plan maps with the location of registered and AAPA recorded sacred sites and other locations referred to in the evidence. I have found the maps annexed to his affidavit especially informative.
179 Mr Coutinho said this of the Board’s Reasons.
20. … At page 5 of the letter the Board states that it was provided with spatial data showing the location of accommodation, facilities, tracks and attraction location points. The letter further states that the abstract of records from AAPA was georeferenced for comparison with the sites and tracks provided by the applicant. At page 3 the Board states that it has reduced the area under the permit to exclude sacred sites identified in the abstract of records except for sites immediately in the vicinity of the Lorella Homestead. For the reasons explained above, the use of georeferencing in the absence of spatial data is more likely to lead to variance in depicting the location of these places.
21. On closer examination, there are sacred sites identified in the AAPA abstract of records within or proximate to green hatched areas on the permit maps, in addition to sites immediately in the vicinity of the Lorella Homestead marked as 6066-2, especially when one has regard to the extent of a site recorded by AAPA in the abstract marked with blue hatching on the maps I have prepared. These include, as appearing on Map 1.1:
(1) 6066-3 and 6066-3A at the southern boundary of PL 757 south east of the tourist location “Walker Rock (mini Ayers Rock)”;
(2) 6067-64A at the coast at the tourist location “Secret Fishing Spot”;
(3) 6067-80 north west of the tourist location “Lorella Homestead”;
(4) 6066-81 with a north east extent near the tourist location “Jump Up Valley Lookout”;
(5) 6067-34 east of a junction south of the cluster of tourist locations marked “Nannie's Retreat Car Park” etc.
22. On closer examination, there are restricted work areas identified in the AAPA abstract of records within or overlapping green hatched areas on the permit maps. These include, marked in pink hatching on the maps I have prepared, restricted work areas shown on Map 1.1:
(1) along Rosie Creek associated with sites 6066-11, 6066-5 east of the tourist location “Rock Pools” near the junction with Warramana Creek;
(2) at the coast associated with site 6067-64A at the tourist location “Secret Fishing Spot”;
(3) at the southern boundary of PL 757 south east of the tourist location “Walker Rock (mini Ayers Rock)” associated with site 6066-3;
23. On closer examination, there are Aboriginal heritage sites identified in Figure 10 of attachment C and in the list within attachment K of the permit application within green hatched areas on the permit maps, appearing on Map 1.1 as “WDHRAS02” in the tip of the green section east of tourist location “Rock Pools” and the Aboriginal heritage site “Lorella Spring” near “Lorella Homestead”.
180 Mr Coutinho’s description of the sites and their locations relative to the Endorsed Plan Area was not the subject of challenge, whether as to conclusion or methodology. I accept that evidence.
181 I have already mentioned the anthropological report of Dr Bradley and Dr Johnson. The authors have overlaid one of Mr Coutinho’s maps with information drawn from their informants concerning Dreaming tracks and associated sacred or significant sites. Their map fairly reflects the lay evidence before me and the other sources of information underpinning the anthropologists’ report.
182 I have considered the places referred to in the maps in light of the evidence as a whole, some of which is subject to confidentiality orders. Without diminishing the importance of the places to the native title holders, it will suffice to give a brief description of each of them, drawn from the uncontested evidence of the anthropologists and Aboriginal witnesses.
183 Top End placed particular emphasis on the first to fifth mentioned sites, each of which falls within the Endorsed Plan Area.
Lorella Spring
184 This site is identifiable by AAPA reference number 6066-2. It is one of two sites located within the Lorella restricted zone and is specifically mentioned in the Board’s Reasons. The site includes rock art, an unrestricted mythological site and paintings. It is situated approximately 550 metres south of the main accommodation area.
Lorella Campground (Lurala)
185 Lurala refers to a round hill near the Lorella homestead in an area known as the Lorella Campground. It is the second site in the Lorella restricted zone and is identifiable by AAPA reference 6066-80. Traditional owners depose that Lurala is a sacred place where two significant Dreaming stories converge and then continue. It is also specifically mentioned in the Board’s Reasons.
186 Mr Mulholland described his shock and anger at seeing tourists walking all over the hill. He described the Dreaming that travelled from the hill through the Yiyintyi range. He continued:
The Yiyintyi is very dangerous, no-one should go there. I read in the Tourism Brochure that Rhett Walker said there is rock art in what he calls “Sloshy Springs” and marked “20”. Tourists shouldn’t see that rock art, unless they are with a traditional owner. They need to have a traditional owner with them, or a jungkayi. That is our custom.
Warramarnda
187 There are two AAPA sites with reference numbers 6066-3 and 6066-3A co-located within the Endorsed Plan Area along the southern boundary. Both sites are located within a restricted works area.
Secret Fishing Spot (Yarnarndu/Warli)
188 The Secret Fishing Spot is located on the coastline at the mouth of the Wurulwuntya Creek within the northern boundary of the Endorsed Plan Area. The site has AAPA reference number 6067-64A and is subject to a restricted zone. It is described in a Tourism Brochure as “the ultimate in remote, raw pristine fishing” and a “magnificent remote untouched stretch of coastline with one of the only few access points to the Gulf of Carpentaria”. To the native title holders, the site is known as Yarnarndu. It is associated with a Dreaming story for Burdel Country associated with the dingo (Karrwiri) and a camping ground used by the old people (ancestors). Mr Isaac described it as follows:
My dad used to tell me that our old people would travel up and down from Numbulwar and Borroloola to Lorella in canoes, and camp out all along the coast, like at that place called “43” (Secret Fishing Spot) on that Tourism Brochure. We call those old people walngala in Yanyuwa. The old people left their mark there. There are camp sites with old tools and there are caves and other places where the old people painted on the rocks. I have seen paintings there a long time ago with my father. We don’t want tourists to go there because it is sacred. The tourists shouldn’t see the paintings. I am worried they will damage the paintings…
189 There is an additional site within the restricted works area known as Warli, associated with the same Dreaming track. There are some differences in the path of the dingo through the sites of Yarnarndu and Warli as depicted in the maps, however nothing of moment turns on those differences.
Lijala
190 The north-eastern and south-western boundaries of the site associated with Lijala (AAPA reference number 6066-81) slightly overlap with the Endorsed Plan Area. Lijala has ceremonial significance and is connected to the Women Dreaming track. It is the final major site associated with the Travelling Women on Lorella Springs.
Nyamulumulu/Yigala
191 Nyamulumulu (AAPA reference number 6067-34) and Yigala (an unrestricted mythological site) are co-located in close proximity to the Endorsed Plan Area and a restricted zone, and approximately 570 m south of an existing track.
WDHRAS02
192 This heritage site is described as “stone artefact scatter” located on laterite ridges in a clearing 800 m from the eastern side of Rosie Creek. The site is not otherwise known or referred to by any name other than its Heritage Branch reference number. It falls outside of the Endorsed Plan Area.
Rock Pools (Maliba)
193 Maliba is located adjacent to Rock Pools at a fork in Rosie Creek and has AAPA reference number 6066-11. The site is not within the Endorsed Plan Area but is within close proximity to the boundary. Maliba refers to a man who sang while mermaid women known as Mararabana sang. The site is a ceremony ground where old people used to fight and are now buried. It is referred to by Mr Isaac as a “big law place” and a “big ceremony place” where people were punished. He said that it is not visited because it is too dangerous. Mr Isaac described the area in the vicinity of Rosie Creek as follows:
Tourists shouldn’t be camping anywhere near Rosie Creek. Rosie Creek is kurdu kurdu. There are a lot of dangerous places around there. Back in the day, lots of old people camped at Rosie Creek. They could camp there because they got wudnali there – something to protect themselves. Only people who have that knowledge can go there. You can go fishing at Rosie Creek, but you need to do it the right way and call out to country. My dad taught me that.
Sloshy Springs
194 Sloshy Springs falls within the Endorsed Plan Area. It is described in a Tourism Brochure as follows:
This place is remote and only a handful of people get out here. Hiking up into the “Yiyinti” you will discover incredible rock formations, rock art, pretty falls and impressive views.
195 Mr Barrett referred to a quartzite deposit in the Yiyintyi Range (in the vicinity of Nanny’s Retreat) where there existed Aboriginal artefacts and archaeological finds such as spear tips and sharpening tools.
Nanny’s Retreat
196 This site has historically been promoted by the Lessees in the Tourism Brochures and is also a site of Aboriginal rock art. It is described in a Tourism Brochure as follows:
Only newly accessible this is one spot that will become very popular. A tall narrow meandering sandstone gorge with a beautiful spring flowing through the cliffs and surrounded by endless jagged rocky landscape.
197 Nanny’s Retreat is also advertised in promotional material for tours of Lorella Springs on a website maintained by a commercial tour operator.
198 Mr Barrett expressed concern about the continuation of tourism activities already occurring at the site:
The Tourism Brochure refers to “a walk to The Cave” at “Nanny’s Retreat”. Tourists should not go up into that range, I am really worried that they will. I am worried because the rock hole there is really dangerous, even Marra people are frightened of it. I am also concerned that tourists would tamper or damage any artefacts or rock out there. Also, some rock art has gender restrictions or should not be seen by children.
199 Ms Bradley deposed to a visit she made to Nanny’s Retreat in 2020. She described seeing Aboriginal rock art depicting hand prints, visible to her on a walk from the car park. She said that the art was located about 20 minutes from the car park, that it was situated on the walking track and easily located. Ms Bradley recognised Nanny’s Retreat in photographs taken for websites promoting the site for tourism.
Musterer’s Cave
200 This site is mentioned as an attraction in a Tourism Brochure with the following description.
This cave has provided shelter to all sorts of animals from dragonflies, rare ghost bats and snakes to wallabies and dingos. You can walk into the cave, just be careful not to upset any cave inhabitants ... This cave was used in the 50s by the early cattlemen for storage and a place to stay through the wet season.
201 A further description of the site contains a direct reference to “rock art” as a reason to visit.
Dingo Ridge
202 This site is also described in the Tourism Brochures in a way that references rock art as an attraction:
One of the many hundreds of swampy wetlands full of life. With a rocky escarpment backdrop, caves and rock art.
Spoonbill Swamp
203 Spoonbill Swamp sits just outside the Endorsed Plan Area, however, it is directly accessible by turning off the road falling within the Endorsed Plan Area and travelling a short distance. Mr Isaac described the site as one of the most important places on Lorella Country. He said that it was very secret and dangerous. He continued:
We can’t go there unless you say special words to go there, like special language. You need to be through high ceremony to know that language. It’s very sacred, and very dangerous. If someone goes there, the consequences will be really bad for them, they could get hurt or get lost. Us mob have to be there to talk to country. Everyone all around this area is concerned about that, not just in Borroloola but also up in Numbulwar and Roper way.
204 Mr Barrett and Mr Mulholland gave evidence to similar effect.
Evidence of tourism impact
205 Mr Barrett, Mr Mulholland and Mr Isaac each deposed at some length about the impact of past tourism activities at Lorella Springs. Considered as a whole their evidence supports a finding that the interests of Aboriginal people have historically been ignored or overtly disrespected by the Lessees, specifically by their conduct in actively directing tourists to sites of Aboriginal significance and by using Aboriginal rock art as a feature to be actively marketed for commercial gain. The witnesses deposed to tourists leaving larger “haul” roads and venturing down other roads directly to or through Dreaming tracks and sacred sites. They each believed that tourists have engaged in conduct of deliberate desecration of sites and things of significance. I accept that those beliefs are genuinely held.
Expert evidence
206 Dr Bradley and Dr Johnson jointly reinforced the evidence of the Aboriginal witnesses concerning the potency of some sites and the laws and customs delineating responsibilities and restrictions on access. They explained the significance of places by reference to well-documented ethnographic records and the earlier anthropological foundations for the Determination in Riley. The anthropologists went on to express their opinion concerning the concept of the “cultural works of Aboriginal people”. Their overarching opinion was that whilst the expression “cultural works” did not have a single accepted meaning in the discipline of anthropology, the expression did have a meaning for the native title holders. Top End relies upon that opinion to assist in the construction of s 24GB(3). Given its significance to Top End’s case, it is preferable to extract that evidence directly from the anthropologists’ report:
The entire extent of the Lorella area and beyond is “interrelated [and] connected as a whole”. In the opinion of the authors, from a Yanyuwa/Marra perspective the tourism activities described will have an impact (to lesser and greater degree) on the entire Lorella area, not only in respect to those sites within or in proximity to the permit area but also to the interrelated and interconnected creation myths, which formulate ancestral beings, dreaming paths (yijan/njijan) and kujika (songlines). These traverse Lorella and travel beyond…
…
The “activities or cultural works of Aboriginal peoples…” In the opinion of the authors, formed over years of observation, the term cultural works cannot be adequately understood within physical parameters alone. For Yanyuwa/Marra people cultural works encapsulate an entire world view and extend well beyond the physical manifestations of human activity – engravings, rock “art”, baskets, artefacts, larla [log coffins] – to embrace Dreaming dimensions and articulate the fundamental interrelatedness of all living and non-living things…For Yanyuwa and Marra people, the very landscape constitutes a “cultural work”, from the Yiyinydi Range itself, to the rock shelters, lagoons, and savannah lands, all provide evidence of a deep and abiding presence relating to matters of Yanyuwa and Marra Law. Further, we find that from the cultural works present in the landscape, related cultural works such as rock art, stone tools, ceremony grounds, sacred objects, ceremonial body designs, and songs are also derived from this country. We also find that through an understanding of kincentricity, animals, plants and all other physical and metaphysical features on Lorella and elsewhere form a part of the complex consideration of cultural works. The authors arrive at the opinion, after long term observation, that any disturbance or disruption to that landscape represents a breach of cultural protocol for Marra and Yanyuwa people and may cause disorder and distress in both physical and social realms as a consequence. Witness statements confirm that uncontrolled tourism activity in this area is seen as such a disturbance and threatens to impair the maintenance of law and custom over the area under discussion.
…
Our understanding of what Yanyuwa and Marra people might see as cultural works entails an understanding of purpose and participation in what is often described as the Dreaming; in Yanyuwa yijan and in Marra njijan. In our experience it is only by understanding the significance of these terms is it possible to comprehend how living people and their deceased kin are placed within country.
…
In the opinion of the authors, sites such as those mentioned above are considered the cultural works of the Dreamings and they also represent at times the cultural works that men and women construct when they wish to perform ceremonies. The ceremony grounds, created by people, at times represent the sites to which the ceremonies belong. Thus during important ceremonies the actual ceremony ground might represent the physical features found at a site, or a performer is said to embody the knowledge that is derived from those sites, and the singing of song lines visits these sites providing details of the activities associated with these places.
Yanyuwa and Marra men and women that Bradley has worked with over the years described ceremonies to the author as hard work, but essential for the maintenance of country. This hard work also includes the singing of the sacred song lines (kujika) which are also perceived as a form of cultural work drawing on knowledge embedded in country.
(emphasis in original)
207 Dr Bradley and Dr Johnson went on to explain the Aboriginal concept of “rock art” and Aboriginal understanding of artefacts in the landscape. They opined that in Yanyuwa, Marra, Gudanji or Garrwa language there were no terms for rock art. Rather, what in western terms was understood as rock art was, to the native title holders, “a form of visual images found in Country and in Aboriginal tradition incorporated within the matrix of lived social, cultural, Dreaming and ritual significance”. The anthropologists continued:
Depending on context and who is present while discussing rock art it is rarely if ever attributed to living people; it is the work of spiritual entities that are said to dwell in the country as well as the work of Dreaming beings and sometimes the spirits of deceased kin. Where “rock art” is attributed to the work of actual known human beings it is associated with the actions of sorcery.
…
“Rock art” then can be a literal expression of spiritual entities, of Dreamings, at times described as ‘old people’ and also of dangerous men who have lived and are remembered in recently historical times. And while rock art may appear immobilised in the rock shelters and caves in country, the owners and managers of country often do not make a distinction between marks in country (that a western way of knowing might describe as natural) and the ochre marks in country which a western way of knowing would call man made.
208 The anthropologists also referred to sites within the Endorsed Plan Area known for fine grained quartzite from which stone tools were once made and traded. They opined that stone tools derived from the site could be found throughout the area. The stone tool quarries were evidence of human activities. They added that the quarries were:
… first and foremost evidence of the creative actions of the Dreaming beings who brought these places into being and thus these too are cultural works that begin in the long past creative period and then move into the world of human beings, who bestowed great value in this source of stone. It is the ancestors of Yanyuwa and Marra families that processed the stone at these sites and then traded it throughout the area, [sic] These stone tools may no longer be used but they are evidence of both a spiritual and human creative past.
209 They went on to report that there was a pervading sense of sorrow and fear that the quarries and the stone tools might be disturbed.
Risk of desecration, interference and affront
210 Section 24GB(3) is specific in its language. The exception created by the provision is (relevantly) confined to acts having the effect of permitting farm tourism (as already widely construed) that “involves observing” either the “activities … of Aboriginal people” or the “cultural works of Aboriginal people”. It is not concerned with any and every impact (however severe, insensitive or harmful) that an act may have on the interests of Aboriginal people.
211 The verb “observe” must be understood to refer to a deliberate form of looking or seeing, undertaken in the context of tourism (already construed to mean travel for pleasure or education). In its ordinary meaning, the word does not denote a passing disengaged glance, nor does it denote the inspection of a thing with any significant degree of focus or intellectual attention.
212 A tourism activity that “involves” observing a thing is an activity that has as its purpose (or among its purposes) the act of looking at the thing as part of the experience of tourism. The expression is not intended to capture anything or everything that happens to fall within the field of a tourist’s vision.
213 Adopting those meanings, I have no difficulty concluding that tourism undertaken for the purpose of going to a site to see and appreciate its outward appearance is a tourism activity that involves the observation of those sites. But s 24GB(3) is not textually focussed on places. The text is focussed on activities of and works of Aboriginal people. The circumstance that a tourist may visit and see a site of great significance to the native title holders does not, of itself, support a finding that the tourist will engage in an activity to which s 24GB(3) refers. Section 24GB(3) is not expressed in terms directed to the prevention or avoidance of the desecration of sacred sites or the affront that may be caused by tourists being in places where, in accordance with Aboriginal traditional law and custom, they do not belong.
214 The impact of the permitted activities was of course a relevant consideration for the Board to consider in the exercise of its powers under the Pastoral Land Act. I have accepted the evidence of Aboriginal witnesses and anthropologists in relation to the breadth and depth of their concerns about the impact of tourism at Lorella Springs. However, the questions arising from some of those impacts are not questions for this Court to consider when deciding the different question of whether s 24GB of the Native Title Act applies.
Activities of Aboriginal people
215 As explained in the course of rejecting Ground 1(2), I have already concluded that by Condition 4 the Board expressed that it did not authorise tourism activities that involved observing the activities of Aboriginal people. It remains to consider whether the act of granting the Tourism Permit nonetheless had the necessary consequence that the activities of Aboriginal people would in fact be observed, such that Condition 4 was not capable of being complied with. That is a factual matter in respect of which Top End bears the burden of proof. I am not satisfied that the evidence is sufficient to discharge the burden for four reasons.
216 First, whilst I have found that the native title rights and interests of the native title holders are in fact exercised by them, that finding is one that broadly relates to the Determination area. It does not encompass a finding that observable activities in fact occur in all places within the Endorsed Plan Area that will necessarily be observed by tourists by virtue of tourists being permitted to be in those places.
217 Second, it is an agreed proposition that adjoining and/or overlapping the Endorsed Plan Area there are places and areas where native title holders under the Determination may, subject to the full terms and effect of the Determination, do the activities within the meaning of cl 14(g) and (i) of the Determination. However, that does not constitute proof that the rights are in fact exercised in those places or areas, or that the act of granting the Tourism Permit is an act that permits tourism activities involving their observation. There is insufficient specificity in the evidence to support a finding as to which activities of living Aboriginal people occur at which places so as to properly frame an enquiry as to whether those activities would necessarily be observed by tourists as a necessary consequence of the Tourism Decision.
218 Third, much of the evidence of the Aboriginal witnesses was concerned with keeping tourists away from places where they should not be, including places where their ancestors conducted ceremonies, places where their ancestors were buried and places the formation of which is explained in Dreaming stories. Again, I accept that those are matters of fundamental importance to the native title holders. However, it does not follow that the grant of the Tourism Permit was an act permitting tourism activities involving the observation of the activities of Aboriginal people.
219 I emphasise that these findings are not premised on an assumption that no tourist will venture beyond the Endorsed Plan Area. Evidence of historical practices shows that it is likely that some of them will. That may in turn lead to a circumstance in which the activities of Aboriginal people may in fact be observed. However, for the reasons given in connection with Ground 1(2), that consequence would not follow from the Board’s act of granting the Tourism Permit. Rather, it would constitute a breach of the Pastoral Land Act because it would fall outside of the scope of the Board’s authorisation.
220 Fourth, to the extent that the Endorsed Plan Area may encompass specific sites of significance to the native title holders, the Tourism Permit does not of itself have the effect of permitting tourists to approach or observe them. The Board determined it appropriate that the activities that would otherwise be authorised by the grant of the Tourism Permit should not proceed unless and until an Authority Certificate was granted by AAPA. In light of that condition, it is unclear on the evidence before me how it is said that the activities of Aboriginal people will necessarily be observed in connection with any recorded site within AAPA’s area of responsibility.
221 In addition, the Tourism Decision should not be understood to be an act authorising tourism of the kind described in the Tourism Brochures. Rather, the Board must be understood to have denied the Lessees’ application in part, specifically by denying permission to promote locations by reference to the activities of Aboriginal people.
Cultural works of Aboriginal people
222 The meaning of the phrase “cultural works of Aboriginal people” is disputed.
223 Top End contends that the phrase should bear a meaning that properly accords with the nature of the rights and interests with which the Native Title Act is concerned, specifically the spiritual connection of native title holders to Country. The nature and extent of that spiritual connection is discussed by Dr Bradley and Dr Johnson. I accept their joint opinion that the phrase “cultural work” has a very different meaning to the native title holders than it does to western minds. I have extracted their opinions at some length on that topic and I accept that they fall within their areas of expertise.
224 I also accept that the text in s 24GB of the Native Title Act is to be construed having regard to its statutory context. That context includes the definition of the phrase “native title rights and interests” in s 223(1)(b) of the Act and its emphasis on connection to land and waters.
225 However, I do not accept that Parliament intended the phrase “cultural works of Aboriginal people” to have the broader meaning for which Top End contends. In my view, the word “works” should be understood as concerned with something narrower than the broader spiritual imperatives to which the anthropologists referred. In their ordinary meaning, the words “works of Aboriginal people” may be understood as the outcome of human work, whether the outcome is tangible (as in an object), intangible (as in sound or movement), aesthetic (as in a mark) or utilitarian (as in a tool). The word “cultural” suggests a connection between those human activities and their outcomes and the traditional laws and customs with which the Native Title Act is principally concerned. There is no dispute that rock art falls within that meaning. But the phrase is not at all confined to visual marks left in the landscape.
226 I am not satisfied that Parliament intended the meaning of the phrase to extend to natural features in the landscape the existence or form of which is (in Aboriginal law and custom) explained by ancestral beings or in which Aboriginal knowledge is embedded. If that meaning had been intended, I consider a different form of words would have been used, being words of a kind used elsewhere in the statute when places of significance to Aboriginal people are specifically referenced: see for example Native Title Act, s 237 (“areas or sites of particular significance, in accordance with their traditions, to the persons who are the holders … of the native title in relation to the land or waters concerned”). The Australian common law readily accepts that the spiritual connection of Aboriginal people is such that “land and everything that exists on and in it, are organic parts of one indissoluble whole”: see Northern Territory v Griffiths (2019) 269 CLR 1 at [153], [198], [206] (Kiefel CJ, Bell, Keane, Nettle and Gordon JJ). However, I do not accept that Parliament intended the word “works” to encompass that concept.
227 On the facts in the present case, there are indeed places where there exist rock art and things fashioned by humans, including tools. I accept the evidence of the experts and the Aboriginal witnesses (including Ms Bradley) in relation to those things. I also accept that a ceremonial ground may be the outcome of a human activity (as opposed to a natural landscape), although that may depend on something more than the circumstance that ceremonies may occur at the place, and the parties did not make submissions on that specific question. In addition, a place where ancestors are buried may be a cultural work, but Top End’s submissions did not address that discrete topic by reference to the narrower meaning of “works”. Notwithstanding all of that, I do not accept that the act of granting the Tourism Permit was an act permitting tourism activities involving the observation of works within the meaning of s 24GB(3) of the Native Title Act, so far as their existence is established on the evidence. Drawing on aspects of my reasoning thus far, that is because of any one or more of the following factors:
(1) The tourism activity of being in a place does not of itself equate to an activity involving the observation (as defined above) of each and every thing in that place.
(2) In any event, Condition 4 prohibits any activity that involves any such observation. It is hence for the Lessees to put into place practices and systems to avoid the consequence that the tourism activities involve their observation. If that cannot be achieved, then the activity cannot commence or continue notwithstanding anything else said in the Tourism Permit.
(3) Works that might be observed by virtue of visitation to a recorded place falling under AAPA’s responsibility are not permitted to be observed without the issue of an Authority Certificate and, as at the date of these reasons for judgment, it has not been shown that any such Authority Certificate has been (or would necessarily be) issued.
(4) The evidence and submissions in relation to some features of the land and waters (ceremonial grounds and burial places) were not sufficient to support a finding that those places were (or contained) “works of Aboriginal people” properly construed.
(5) The evidence was not sufficient to establish the factual proposition that the activities of Aboriginal people would necessarily be observed notwithstanding Condition 4.
228 It follows that the remaining Grounds impugning Condition 4 and related aspects of the Tourism Decision must fail.
Conclusion on claim for relief under the Native Title Act
229 I pause here to resolve Top End’s application for a declaration that “the grant of non-pastoral use permit NPU25/01 under s 85A of the [Pastoral Land Act], if validly granted under that law, is a future act that is not covered by a provision of Part 2 Div 3 of the [Native Title Act] and is invalid to the extent it affects native title”.
230 That relief will not be granted principally because the Tourism Decision (if validly made under the Pastoral Land Act) is covered by s 24GB of the Native Title Act, contrary to Top End’s submissions. Accordingly, if validly granted under the Pastoral Land Act, the decision to grant the Tourism Permit would be valid for the purposes of the Native Title Act to the extent that it affected native title.
231 I would not grant relief in the terms sought in any event because, for the reasons that follow, the Tourism Decision was not validly made under the Pastoral Land Act. The Tourism Decision will be declared invalid and for good measure there will be an order in the nature of certiorari setting it aside. An invalid decision purportedly made under a law of the Northern Territory cannot affect native title and it therefore does not fall within the statutory definition of a “future act” under s 233 of the Native Title Act.
232 The invalidity of the Tourism Decision will now be explained by reference to the remaining Grounds for judicial review.
Procedural fairness and Condition 4: Ground 8A(2)
233 Top End alleged that it was entitled to be given an opportunity to be heard about the imposition of Condition 4 before it was imposed. That submission can be briefly disposed of. Condition 4 was included in response to the submissions of Top End opposing the grant of a non-pastoral use permit on the grounds that an ILUA was required. It was open to the Board to respond to that submission by introducing a condition directly addressing that concern and putting beyond doubt that an ILUA was not required.
234 The Board’s power to impose conditions on a non-pastoral use permit extends to a condition of the kind mentioned, given that it limits the activities to a narrower compass to that which was sought by the Lessees. The imposition of Condition 4 reflects the principle (made manifest in s 88) that a power to accept an application in full includes a power to accept an application in part.
No retrospective authorisation: Ground 4
235 Ground 4 contends that the Board “erred in concluding that commercial operations for tour groups conducted on the pastoral lease since December 2022 do not require a non-pastoral use permit under the [Pastoral Land Act] and may continue”.
236 It was submitted that the conclusion referred to in that Ground may be inferred from Condition 3 and Note 11 on the face of the Tourism Permit, together with the Board’s Reasons. The Reasons commence with the following:
The Board notes that the applicant has advised that some form of tourism activities have taken place on the Lorella pastoral lease since the late 1980’s, with a modest number of visitors initially. The Board understands that visitor numbers grew to approximately 10 000 visitors annually, with a spike of approximately 17 000 visitors in the immediate post Covid-19 period. The Board has been advised that the applicant voluntarily ceased offering tourism activities to the public in December 2022, whilst continuing to maintain certain commercial operations for tour groups. As far as the Board is aware, no concerns have been raised in regard to environmental issues, sacred sites issues or any other matters from the operation of these commercially operated tourism activities.
(emphasis added)
237 The suggestion that the material before the Board did not indicate any concerns having been raised by the activities mentioned is surprising given the detailed content and tenor of NLC’s submissions and the evidence before the Board. However, that is not the issue with which I am presently concerned.
238 Condition 3 and Note 11 appear on the face of the Tourism Permit. They are as follows:
3. Prior to commencing any activities permitted by the Approved Purpose on the Pastoral Lease for which a non-pastoral use permit is required, the Permit Holder must obtain an Authority Certificate under the Northern Territory Aboriginal Sacred Sites Act 1989, and provide a copy of the Authority Certificate to the Pastoral Land Board. Tourism activities that do not require a non-pastoral use permit may continue on the pastoral lease prior to the issue of an Authority Certificate by AAPA.
…
11. Tourism activities that do not require a non-pastoral use permit may continue on the pastoral lease prior to the issue of an Authority Certificate by AAPA.
(emphasis added)
239 Condition 3 and Note 11 do not support the contention underlying Ground 4. The Board did nothing more than to recognise that there may be tourism activities occurring at Lorella Springs that did not require a non-pastoral use permit. Its conclusion in that respect correctly reflects the definition of “pastoral use” in s 3(1) of the Pastoral Land Act. It expressly incorporates a form of tourism within the concept of a pastoral use. The Board made no finding as to whether or not the commercial activities referred to in its Reasons would or would not fall within the limited form of tourism described in the pastoral use definition in s 3(1) (such as “farm holidays”). If they do not meet that description, nothing in Condition 3 or Note 11 has the effect of authorising them, whether prospectively or retrospectively.
240 By Note 11, the Board should be understood as saying that the conditions imposed in connection with the non-pastoral use forming the subject of the Tourism Permit should not be understood as applying to any limited form of tourism already authorised by the lease read in conjunction with the Pastoral Land Act. It may well be that members of the Board subjectively intended to authorise the continuation of commercial tourism operations of any kind (whether or not they constituted a non-pastoral use) but if that were the case, the subjective intention was not achieved by the Tourism Permit, properly construed.
241 Top End did not argue that tourism activities allowed by virtue of the definition in s 3(1) of the Pastoral Land Act would themselves be prohibited absent an Authority Certificate. That argument would appear to depend upon the interrelation between the Pastoral Land Act and other laws of the Northern Territory, and I should not be understood to express any concluded view about it.
Failure to have regard to mandatory relevant considerations: Grounds 7 and 8
242 Ground 8 is as follows:
When performing its functions in relation to the application, the Board failed, as required by [s] 5 of the [Pastoral Land Act], to act consistently with, and seek to further, the object of the [Pastoral Land Act] to recognise the rights of Aboriginal persons to follow traditional pursuits on pastoral land (s 4(c)) by failing to take into account the potential effects of the permit upon traditional uses reserved from a pastoral lease (s 38(n)).
243 This Ground proceeds from the undisputed premise that PL 757 is made expressly subject to the reservation in s 38(1)(n) of the Pastoral Land Act. The reserved rights of Aboriginal people are described in s 38(2). Relevantly, they include the right “to enter and be on the leased land”: s 38(2)(d). By virtue of s 38(3), that reservation does not apply to land within 2 km of a homestead and I exclude that area from the consideration that follows.
244 The objects of the Pastoral Land Act are set out in s 4 as follows:
(a) to provide a form of tenure of Crown land that facilitates the sustainable use of land for pastoral purposes and the economic viability of the pastoral industry;
(b) to provide for:
(i) the monitoring of pastoral land so as to detect and assess any change in its condition;
(ii) the prevention or minimisation of degradation of or other damage to the land and its indigenous plant and animal life; and
(iii) the rehabilitation of the land in cases of degradation or other damage;
(c) to recognise the right of Aboriginal persons to follow traditional pursuits on pastoral land;
(d) to provide reasonable access for the public across pastoral land to waters and places of public interest; and
(e) to provide a procedure to establish Aboriginal community living areas on pastoral land.
245 As identified earlier in these reasons, s 5 imposed an obligation on the Board to “act consistently with, and seek to further” those objects when exercising the powers conferred upon it. The statutory objective in s 4(c) informs the purpose of the reservation in s 38(1)(n) – the right to enter and be on the land is reserved in recognition that the land subject to the lease is traditionally the Country of Aboriginal people. It is well established that Aboriginal traditional pursuits include the discharge of responsibilities to care for Country, to protect it from desecration and damage, and to observe and maintain traditional laws and customs. They include laws and customs relating to the responsibility for Country, who is or is not entitled to enter a place, and who is entitled to speak for a place. In my view, the reference in s 4(c) to the right to follow traditional pursuits is capable of encompassing all of those things in a particular case, but they do not arise for consideration in the abstract. They are fact-sensitive issues.
246 Top End’s submissions on this Ground at times equated the obligation in s 5 with a limitation on the power under s 85A to the effect that no Tourism Permit could be lawfully granted if the grant would in any way impinge upon the objective of recognising the right of Aboriginal persons to follow traditional pursuits on pastoral land. That argument is not articulated in any Ground of review. The suit was not framed as an action for trespass on proprietary rights of Aboriginal people, nor was it framed as a suit for compensation for loss and damage caused by the transgression of any right reserved under s 38(1) of the Pastoral Land Act. The present Ground is framed in terms of an alleged failure to comply with the obligation in s 5. The alleged failure is not established.
247 Section 5 is concerned with all of the objects of the Pastoral Land Act, not merely the object mentioned in s 4(c). There may be cases in which the Board will be required to have regard to competing considerations, such that pursuing one of the objects mentioned in s 4 may detract from the achievement of another. The Board was entitled (indeed obliged) to have regard to the objective in s 4(a) (including the economic viability of the pastoral industry) and s 4(d) (public access to places of public interest). The Reasons disclose a deliberative process by which the matters referred to in s 5 were considered and weighed. It was not otherwise necessary for the Board to express itself in terms that reflected the wording of s 4 or s 5.
248 Top End otherwise argued that when exercising the power under s 85A, by necessary implication, the Board was required to “consider the effects of a permit on Aboriginal use reserved out of the pastoral lease but not reserved out of [the] non-pastoral use permit”. The requirement was said to arise by implication, having regard to the subject matter, scope and purpose of the Pastoral Land Act in accordance with the principles discussed by Mason J in Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24 at 39 – 40 and 44. His Honour said:
(1) Failure To Take Into Account a Relevant Consideration.
The failure of a decision-maker to take into account a relevant consideration in the making of an administrative decision is one instance of an abuse of discretion entitling a party with sufficient standing to seek judicial review of ultra vires administrative action. That ground now appears in s. 5(2)(b) of the [Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth)] which, in this regard, is substantially declaratory of the common law. Together with the related ground of taking into account irrelevant considerations, it has been discussed in a number of decided cases, which have established the following propositions:
…
(b) What factors a decision-maker is bound to consider in making the decision is determined by construction of the statute conferring the discretion. If the statute expressly states the considerations to be taken into account, it will often be necessary for the court to decide whether those enumerated factors are exhaustive or merely inclusive. If the relevant factors – and in this context I use this expression to refer to the factors which the decision-maker is bound to consider – are not expressly stated, they must be determined by implication from the subject-matter, scope and purpose of the Act …
…
The Act does not expressly state that the Minister is bound to take into account the Commissioner’s comments on the matters in pars. (a) to (d) of s. 50(3) in exercising his power under s. 11(1)(b) to decide whether or not he is satisfied that a land grant should be made. But a consideration of the subject-matter, scope and purpose of the Act indicates that such a finding is necessarily implied by the statute. The factor that leads irresistibly to this conclusion is the specific requirement in s. 50(3) that the Commissioner comment in his report on each of the four matters enumerated in the sub-section, including of course detriment. That provision recognizes that the granting of land to a Land Trust may adversely affect the interests of many people, in some cases in a very substantial way …
249 In support of the implication, Top End relied upon the combined effect of ss 4, 5, 38(1)(d), 38(1)(n), 38(2), 39(b), 85A and 87(c) of the Pastoral Land Act.
250 The additional argument misunderstands the legal effect of the Tourism Permit. The Tourism Permit does not in terms affect the reserved right of an Aboriginal person “to enter and be on” any part of the leased area forming part of the Endorsed Plan Area. In the present case, the right of Aboriginal people to enter and to be on the land is non-exclusive: Riley, cll 11 and 16. It does not include the right to exclude the presence of others who may otherwise be entitled to lawfully enter and be there. Nor does the reservation in s 38(1)(n) of the Pastoral Land Act.
251 More fundamentally, the statutory provisions relied upon by Top End do not support an implication that the power in s 85A was conditioned by an obligation to have regard to the particular mandatory relevant consideration articulated in this Ground of review. On the proper construction of the Pastoral Land Act, the Board is obliged to comply with s 5 by seeking to act in a manner that advances the objects in s 4. Section 5 is concerned with a mode of decision making. In discharging that obligation, the Board is obliged to have regard to things said on all of the statutory objects by any person exercising the statutory right to comment upon an application, duly notified under s 87(2A) and s 87A of the Pastoral Land Act. There are then express obligations to have regard to those submissions: Pastoral Land Act, s 87(2)(ca); Native Title Act, s 24GB(9)(d). The content of that duty is akin to that discussed by the High Court in Plaintiff M1-2021 v Minister for Home Affairs (2022) 275 CLR 582 at [36] (Kiefel CJ, Keane, Gordon and Steward JJ).
252 By its submissions to the Board, NLC specifically referred to the asserted impact of the grant of the Tourism Permit both on native title rights and interests and in relation to the separate and discrete statutory reservation in s 38(1)(n) of the Pastoral Land Act. The submissions made by NLC in 2022 were repeated and elaborated upon in 2024 and have been summarised earlier in these reasons. Those submissions were made in the exercise of a statutory right to be heard.
253 The Reasons and the outcome disclose that the Board did have regard to the submissions of NLC concerning the effect of the grant of the Tourism Permit on the rights and interests of the traditional owners of the area, as they articulated them to be, and so discharged its obligation under s 5. Having elected to give the Reasons, the Board was not obliged to repeat each and every submission made before it. It was sufficient that it had regard to the matters raised in response to the statutory notifications. That it did so is evidenced by the exclusion from the Endorsed Plan Area of some of the attractions referred to in the Tourism Brochures, as well as the additional measures taken with a view to protecting sacred sites, including the imposition of Conditions 3 and 4. Those aspects of the Tourism Decision are to be understood as the Board’s response to the concerns raised by NLC on Top End’s behalf. It is not the role of this Court to review the merits of the outcome, nor to analyse whether the Board could or should have done more to prevent the risk of harm to the interests of the traditional owners.
254 Accordingly, to the extent that s 5 of the Pastoral Land Act supports a conclusion that the Board’s power was conditioned by a requirement to have regard to a mandatory relevant consideration, that requirement was met.
Impacts upon the environment: Ground 7
255 When exercising the power under s 85A of the Pastoral Land Act, the Board had a statutory obligation to consider the likely effect of the proposed use on the environment: s 87(2)(c).
256 By Ground 7, Top End contended that the Board failed to have regard to the following matters, contrary to ss 85A(2), 87(2)(c) and 87(2)(d) of the Pastoral Land Act and item 6(g) and (i) of the NPU Guidelines:
(1) the presence of threatened species as declared under the Territory and [sic] Parks and Wildlife Conservation Act 1976 (NT) (item (g));
(2) environmental issues under the Environment Protection Act 2019 (NT) or the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth), which may require referral to the Environment Protection Authority (item (i));
(3) the likely effect of the proposed use on the environment (s 87(2)(c));
(emphasis added)
257 The first two subject matters are referenced in the NPU Guidelines and are directed to the discrete topics of threatened species and issues arising under Commonwealth environmental protection legislation. The NPU Guidelines were issued by the Board under s 85A(2) of the Pastoral Land Act. That section is expressed as a power to issue guidelines “for pastoral lessees in relation to the processes of application for a non-pastoral use permit and the determination of the application”. Any such guidelines must be approved by the Minister: s 85A(3).
258 Argument proceeded on the basis that the NPU Guidelines in force at the time of the Tourism Decision were those constituting version 3.2 dated 7 March 2024. No point was taken about the difference between that version and any earlier version at the time when the Lessees’ application was originally made.
259 Item 6 of the NPU Guidelines states “[i]n making a decision on a non-pastoral use application, the Board considers the following sections of the Act”, and there follows a list of the matters mentioned in s 87(2)(b), (c), (ca) and (d). It is to be recalled that under s 87(2)(d) the Board is to have regard to any other matters it thinks fit.
260 The NPU Guidelines go on to state “[o]ther matters the Board considers relevant include, but are not limited to …” 11 listed matters, including the two discrete subject matters mentioned in Ground 7 before me.
261 In my view, the circumstance that those matters were listed in the NPU Guidelines does not of itself support a conclusion that all of the matters there named are to have the status of mandatory relevant considerations in every case. That is because the power to issue guidelines is not expressed as intended to bind the Board itself, but rather to provide an indication to proponents as to the matters the Board may consider to be relevant in a particular case. The statutory mechanism of guidelines issued for an express purpose (assisting applicants) ought not be construed as serving another purpose (binding the Board in relation to its substantive fact-finding or evaluative functions).
262 I have nonetheless concluded that the obligation to have regard to threatened species arises by a different legal route.
263 Ground 7 refers to s 87(2)(c) itself. There can be no dispute that the “likely effect of the proposed use on the environment” was a mandatory relevant consideration according to the principles in Peko-Wallsend, given the language of s 87(2)(c) of the Pastoral Land Act. In order to discharge that obligation it was necessary that the Board correctly identify the proposed use.
264 As the Northern Territory correctly submitted, where a statute creates an obligation to consider a matter at a high level of generality, the manner in which the thing is to be considered (and the weight to be afforded to it) is for the decision maker to determine: Changshu Longte Grinding Ball Company Ltd v Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry, Innovation and Science (2019) 270 FCR 244 at [93(5)(b)] (Yates, Moshinsky and Thawley JJ). However, I do not accept the Territory’s related submission that the Board had no obligation to consider the impact of the proposed use on threatened species as a subset of the broader subject matter of environmental impact. A requirement to have regard to the likely effect of the proposed use on the environment would necessarily encompass an obligation to identify the existence of threatened species (and the likely impact on them) because threatened plant and animal species are features that are inherent in the concept of “the environment” mentioned in s 87(2)(c). They are an inextricable part of the mandated subject matter. The obligation arises implicitly as an unavoidable part of an obligation to consider the environmental impacts. The source of the Board’s obligation to have regard to the impact of the proposal on threatened species was not so much the NPU Guidelines, but the Pastoral Land Act itself.
265 The discharge of the Board’s obligation to consider that subject matter was facilitated by its power to issue guidelines under s 85A(2) of the Pastoral Land Act to proponents requiring that the topic be addressed, as well as its power to require a proponent to provide more information in support of an application under s 86.
266 As discussed elsewhere in these reasons, the area affected by the non-pastoral use was poorly described in the application, both as originally made by the Lessees in 2022 and then as revised in 2024. The Endorsed Plan Area was not an area specified by the Lessees in their application as originally made, nor in any amended application put forward by them. It was an area created by the Department at the request of the Board following the public meeting.
267 The application as originally framed was accompanied by an assessment of environmental impacts premised upon the original (hopelessly obscure) land description, namely an area of 24 ha, albeit with accompanying documents showing tourism attractions across a much larger area.
268 The Second Technical Assessment provided to the Board stated that the application lodged in 2022 had included a report about matters protected under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth) (EPBC Act) as at 16 March 2022 and that an updated report had not been provided as part of the re-advertised application. The Second Technical Assessment then detailed an assessment undertaken by the Vegetation Assessment Unit reporting that “no matters were identified in the applicant’s NT EPA self-referral checklist that would require referral under the EPBC Act or the EP Act”. The self-referral checklist was that accompanying the original Permit Application in 2022. The self-referral was not in relation to the 60,257 ha forming the subject of the Tourism Decision ultimately made.
269 It is to be recalled that at the time of the Second Technical Assessment, the area was described in variable terms, but it did include a reference to 3,497.11 ha of affected land. That area comprised roads connecting the tourism attractions then proposed to be included by the Lessees, with a 20 m area on each side of each road.
270 By the Tourism Decision, the Board excluded some attractions, increased the area on each side of the connecting roads to 500 m (so creating 1 km thoroughfares) and allowed a radius around most of the remaining allowed attractions to 500 m, so resulting in the Endorsed Plan Area of 60,257 ha. The Board neither sought nor obtained a revised environmental assessment from the Lessees specifically addressing that area.
271 In its Reasons, the Board said:
87(2)(c) - the likely effect of the proposed use on the environment and the pastoral enterprise of the pastoral lessee
The proposal will see tourists using tracks and camping in areas covering approximately 3497.11ha. This includes a homestead, network of camp areas, and existing pastoral tracks throughout the pastoral lease. The application describes tourism activities based around the homestead, with visitors able to access other areas by way of existing infrastructure to ensure minimal disturbance to the continued pastoral operations of the lease and cattle grazing areas.
The proposal includes access tracks leading to natural features, such as waterways, billabongs, swamps, and wetlands. There is no clearing required or other land disturbance. The Flora and Fauna Division advised that, as the proposal will use existing infrastructure, there is unlikely to be increased impact on regional biodiversity. No matters were identified in the applicant’s Northern Territory Environment Protection Authority self-referral checklist that would require referral under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 or the Environment Protection Act 2019.
Water Resources Division advised a water licence has now been granted to support the proposal. The applicant also provided a traffic impact statement, which demonstrated that the potential impacts on the road network were low. The impact statement was accepted by the Roads Division, the Department of Logistics and Infrastructure.
There is also a note on the permit to ensure that environmental protection, including waste management, disposal of waste (such as for landfill) and human waste and sullage.
(emphasis added)
272 The reference in that part of the Reasons to an area of 3,497.11 ha is wrong. That figure bears no relation to the Endorsed Plan or any part of it. Moreover, the Board had before it the Second Technical Assessment advising that the assessments that had been done were in relation to the application as originally made in 2022. That application referred to an area of 24 ha. I have already described it as hopelessly obscure.
273 Top End submitted that this state of affairs had the consequence that the Board had failed to have regard to the environmental impacts of the use actually proposed at the time of the Tourism Decision (60,257 ha), as opposed to consideration of impacts of the earlier proposed use (either 24 ha, 3,497.11 ha or some undefined other area). I accept Top End’s submissions in that respect.
274 It is true that in an earlier response dealing with the risks of erosion and pollution, the Lessees listed a number of sites, including by their registration numbers in AAPA’s records. They stated that the risks to those places would be minimised as follows:
• Aboriginal or archaeological sites to be avoided from all tourism activities
• No additional construction/disturbance proposed
• Lorella rules for tourists:
o Use of existing access tracks / no driving off formed tracks
o Only swimming in designated areas
o Restricted access
There is no tourism infrastructure (besides roads/tracks) outside the main campground.
275 That response must also be taken to refer to the proposed use the Lessees themselves had put forward, not the enlarged area described in the Endorsed Plan.
276 The expansion of the area on either side of roadways to increase the width of the thoroughfare from 40 m to 1 km cannot be said to be a negligible change. The Court may draw upon ordinary human experience to conclude that the 1 km expansion of the corridor along the roadways opens up obvious opportunities for camping beyond the immediate roadside and hence human and vehicular impact in that 1 km-wide thoroughfare. The consequence of the Board considering outdated assessments was that it did not consider the likely environmental impact of the relevant proposed use (being the use it ultimately decided upon), but rather the likely impact of some other ill-defined proposed use (being the use originally proposed by the Lessees).
277 The relevant impact to be assessed was the impact of the non-pastoral acts as proposed (the influx and movements of tourists lawfully in the Endorsed Plan Area), assessed against what would be the position if there were no permission and hence no tourists in that area. It also fell to be assessed against the absence of any proposal for a condition that the camping be self-contained in respect of grey and brown waters (to politely adopt camping parlance).
278 The Territory next relied on the circumstance that Top End had made submissions relating the existence of threatened species in the whole of the area covered by PL 757 and that the Board had taken those submissions into account. It followed, the Territory submitted, that the Board had discharged its obligation to have regard to the mandatory consideration in s 87(2)(c) because impacts across the whole of Lorella Springs had been the subject of submissions before it.
279 The submissions referred to are those made by NLC in response to the Permit Application as originally filed. They commence with a statement that there should be a referral of the proposal to the Northern Territory Environment Protection Authority (EPA). It is true that the submissions go on to raise a number of concerns that are not specific to any particular area. That is not surprising as the submissions commenced with a justified complaint that the area affected by the proposal was not able to be ascertained.
280 I am not satisfied that the Board in fact had regard to the content of that submission. That is because it makes no reference to anything that had been said by NLC on the subject and there is nothing in the Reasons to indicate that it grappled with the environmental concerns the NLC had raised. Without being exhaustive, they included matters relating to the management of sewerage, the disposal of waste, the Gouldian Finch as a vulnerable species, the spread of weeds by vehicular movement and an allegation that the Lessees were in breach of existing environmental obligations with respect to weed control.
281 In the absence of any reference to that subject matter in the Reasons, I am not satisfied that a mere reference in the Board’s Reasons to NLC’s 2022 submissions can support a finding that it in fact gave any consideration to the environmental impacts referred to in them, let alone in specific relation to the 60,257 ha Endorsed Plan Area. In any event, the thrust of the submission was that the proposal ought to have been the subject of an EPA assessment and no such assessment was ultimately done of the proposal in its ultimate form (being the form it took immediately prior to the Tourism Decision).
282 For those reasons, Ground 7 should be upheld to the extent that it asserted a failure to consider the environmental impacts of a correctly identified proposed use. The error serves to illustrate the importance that a proposed use be articulated with certainty by the proponent in an application made under s 86 of the Pastoral Land Act.
283 Ground 7 is upheld.
284 Similar issues arise in the group of Grounds considered next.
Notification requirements, procedural fairness and limits of jurisdiction: Grounds 3, 5, 6 and 8A
285 Of these Grounds it is convenient to turn first to Ground 5. The Ground should be upheld. My consideration of the remaining Grounds illustrates the procedural mayhem created by the Board exceeding its jurisdiction in the manner established by Ground 5.
Ground 5
286 Ground 5 is to the effect that the Board’s power to grant a non-pastoral use permit under s 85A of the Pastoral Land Act was a power to decide an application as made by a proponent under s 86, subject to the imposition of conditions under s 88, and did not extend to granting a permit for an area larger than that for which the proponent had applied.
287 I accept that submission. Read together, the relevant provisions of the Pastoral Land Act contemplate that a proposal be put to the Board for a decision by way of an application under s 86. It is that proposal that is to be the subject of the express notification provisions. The Board’s power under s 85A is to decide whether to grant the permit applied for, with or without conditions. Properly construed, the power to impose conditions does not extend to the introduction of a condition having the effect of enlarging the expanse of the area to which a non-pastoral use application refers. If the power in s 88 of the Pastoral Land Act were construed to permit an enlargement of that kind, it may result in a distortion of the statutory procedural fairness mechanisms and the chronology of procedural steps established by them. The orthodox chronology commences with an application made under s 86, followed by notification of that application under s 87A and s 87(2A), followed by consideration of the submissions made by the public or affected persons in relation to that application, followed by the Board’s decision on that application under s 85A, having regard to those submissions. The application made by a proponent is foundational in that sequence and, subject to any revisions made to it by the proponent, it represents the outer limits of the proposed future act.
288 The proposal put forward by the Lessees was that articulated by them in the additional information provided in 2024, read in the context of the material they had originally lodged in 2022. The application was for a permit relating to 3,497.11 ha. The power of the Board was limited to a power to grant that application, to grant it subject to conditions, or to refuse it. The Board exceeded its jurisdiction by purporting to use its condition-making power to grant a Tourism Permit relating to the enlarged area of 60,257 ha, for which the Lessees had not applied.
Procedural fairness, notification and the expansion of the proposed area: Grounds 3, 8A(1)(a) and 6
289 As identified earlier in these reasons, the Board was obliged to give notice of the Permit Application in two different ways.
290 The first obligation arose under s 87(2A) of the Pastoral Land Act which in turn picked up notification requirements under s 24GB(9) of the Native Title Act. Item 8 of the Notices Determination required that notice under s 24GB(9)(c) of the Native Title Act include “a clear description of the area to which the act … mentioned in the notice relates”. The expression “clear description” is defined in item 4 as:
… a description of the area that contains enough information, whether by map drawn to scale or description by other means, to work out:
(a) the general location of the area; and
…
291 The Explanatory Memorandum concerning the introduction of that definition stated:
This change ensures that there is no uncertainty over the relevant area of the notice. As procedural rights apply in these circumstances, the changes ensure persons are provided with all relevant information to identify where their interests are affected. …
This change makes it clear that the area that must be described in the proposed notice is the area to which the act mentioned in the notice relates.
292 Ground 3 alleges that the Board failed to comply with that obligation. It is as follows:
When considering the application, the Board failed, as required by s 87(2A) of the [Pastoral Land Act], to comply with the requirements of Part 2 Div 3 Sub-div G (primary production) of the [Native Title Act] in that the application had not been notified in accordance [with] s 24GB(9) of the [Native Title Act], in particular, the notice that was given did not include a clear description of the area to which the application relates as required by s 8(3)(a) of the [Notices Determination] – notice dated 17 June 2022 referring to 24 ha, notice dated 14 June 2024 referring to 3,497 ha, and permit condition 1 for activities in an area of 60,257 ha (reasons for decision p.6).
293 Ground 8A(1)(a) is to the effect that the Board failed to afford Top End (as the representative to the native title holders) procedural fairness by proceeding to make a decision to grant a non-pastoral use permit in respect of an area within PL 757 covering 60,257 ha. It is convenient to deal with that part of Ground 8A(1) in conjunction with Ground 3.
294 It is not appropriate to assess Ground 3 by reference to the First Native Title Notification made on 17 June 2022. That is because the Board did not purport to make a decision after giving that notification. Rather, it made its decision after making the Second Native Title Notification on 14 June 2024. It did so after exercising its power under s 86 of the Pastoral Land Act to require the Lessees to provide (among other things) a better description of the area to which the Permit Application related. Among other things, the invitation to provide additional information stated:
The [NLC] has raised, amongst other things, the requirement for an indigenous land use agreement with the native title holders of Lorella Springs to comply with the [Native Title Act]. The NLC, and the Department of Industry, Tourism and Trade, have also raised that the tourism activities described in the application occurred outside the proposed area of the non-pastoral use application and that those activities could include impacts on sacred sites, the observation of cultural activities or works, and occupy the majority of the pastoral lease. Clarification on the actual proposal footprint, including details, descriptions, maps and spatial data on all tourism activity areas and access tracks used, is required.
295 The Lessees provided additional information on 29 April 2024. That information included updated “shapefile data”. An email from the Department to NLC dated 1 August 2024 confirms the Board’s view that the additional information had the effect of changing “the footprint” of the proposed non-pastoral use, necessitating a new notification process.
296 By providing the additional information, the Lessees should be understood as having amended the application they had originally made and abandoning their reliance on the inadequate description of the affected area they had originally put forward. Nothing in the Pastoral Land Act precluded the Lessees from changing the description of the land to which their application related. In addition, properly construed, the Board’s power to require the provision of further information should be understood as extending to a circumstance in which a proponent has not provided sufficient information to enable the Board to discharge its own notification obligations under s 87(2A) of the Pastoral Land Act and, by incorporation, the obligation under s 24GB of the Native Title Act. It was open to the Board to proceed in the manner that it did by making the Second Native Title Notification (and for that matter the Second Public Notification process discussed in the context of Ground 6 below).
297 As will be seen, much of the description of the land as originally put forward in the Permit Application in 2022 made its way into the amended application and hence infected the notification process in any event.
298 By its email to NLC dated 1 August 2024, the Department directed NLC to “the Shapefiles and kml file for the 2024 application footprint”. The email states that the information contained in those files had previously been made available among the documents notified via a publicly available online portal. A comparison of the information contained in the First Native Title Notification and the Second Native Title Notification bears that out.
299 The Recommendation Report provided to the Board in advance of the public meeting describes (on its front page) a “proposed NPU extent” of 3,497.11 ha. In the body of the report, it was said that “the revised shapefiles expanded the proposed tourism area from 24ha to 3497ha, covering all intended areas and tracks”.
300 The Recommendation Report did not form a part of the Second Native Title Notification documents.
301 The instrument comprising the Second Native Title Notification is evidenced in the affidavit of Courtney Dutton affirmed on 9 May 2025. The instrument was delivered under the cover of a letter from a representative of the Department to Top End. The cover letter is not to be equated with the instrument itself. The instrument contains the following statements:
BACKGROUND
The proposed permit for a non-pastoral use of pastoral land involves the utilising of approximately 3497 hectares of land for the purpose of tourism activities, accommodation and campgound [sic] facilities (farm tourism) operations on Lorella Springs Station (“the Proposed Future Act”).
…
DESCRIPTION OF LAND AFFECTED
The land affected by the Proposed Future Act is Pastoral Lease 757, being Northern Territory Portion 1333 (Lorella Springs Station).
FUTURE ACT
The Proposed Future Act is the grant of a permit to the lessee of Lorella Springs Station, being Maximus No. 82 Pty. Limited & Landmark Developments Pty. Limited, pursuant to section 85A of the Pastoral Land Act 1992 to allow approximately:
• 3497 hectares of the non-exclusive pastoral lease to be used for non-pastoral purposes being farm tourism operations.
302 Those statements do not describe the places on PL 757 where the affected 3,497.11 ha are located.
303 There is then a reference to a website on which the Board was giving public notice of the application. Reasonably construed, the Second Native Title Notification should be understood as referring the recipient to that website for information concerning the application. I am satisfied that the information on that website should be understood as forming a part of the Second Native Title Notification itself. It contained additional information that enabled the area to be affected by the proposed future act to be better understood. I have therefore had regard to the materials published by the Board in the discharge or purported discharge of its public notification obligations when considering the sufficiency of the Second Native Title Notification. Those materials included a copy of the Permit Application in its original form referring to an affected area of 24 ha, together with the supporting materials originally provided in 2022 which also referred to that smaller area. They also contained the additional information put forward by the Lessees in 2024.
304 The reader of the information would understand that the Permit Application had subsequently been revised by the provision of additional information referring to an affected land area of 3,497.11 ha. The reader would understand that a larger area of 3,497.11 ha was proposed to be affected by the proposed future act. That is reinforced on the face of the instrument itself. I do not consider that references among the materials to an area of 24 ha could be reasonably understood by the notice recipient as contradicting references to the larger land area. I reject Top End’s submissions to that extent.
305 It remains to consider whether the information contained in the online materials gave a “clear description” of the area to be affected by the proposed future act, as that phrase is defined in the Native Title Act. The standard to be met is that the description must contain enough information to work out the general location of the area and its approximate boundaries.
306 Among the additional material provided by the Lessees was a satellite image said to have been derived from Google Earth marked with white lines said to depict roads to be used by tourists for the purpose of travel across Lorella Springs to and between the advertised attractions.
307 There are references in the materials to spatial mapping resources. On the evidence before me, those resources were not able to be accessed by recipients of the Second Native Title Notification. Whatever their content, this Court was not taken to them. I accept the uncontested evidence that no spatial data was accessible to the recipients of that Notice, other than the marked Google Earth image.
308 Importantly, the Google Earth image was not the only document containing information from which the recipients of the Notice could “work out” the “general location” of the affected area and its “approximate boundaries”. The information accompanying the instrument also included the Tourism Brochures. They depicted the tourism attractions at which the non-pastoral use activities were contemplated and included mud-map depictions of the roadways on which the tourists could travel to reach them.
309 The materials, considered as a whole, gave a description of the affected area proposed by the Lessees themselves at the time that the Second Native Title Notification was made. I therefore conclude that the description given at that time was sufficient to describe the proposed future act sought by the Lessees by their Permit Application, as revised. Reasonably interpreted, the documents disclose a revised application by which the Lessees proposed that the tourists would access the places named on the Tourism Brochures and that they would utilise existing pastoral roads to get there. I am reinforced in that view by the Lessees’ submissions included in the additional information provided in 2024, in which they submitted that the majority of the area to be affected by the proposed future act was land in which native title did not exist. The Lessees relied on Schedule D to the Determination in Riley declaring that native title did not exist in (relevantly) “public roads” and “community and pastoral access roads which are not otherwise public roads”. The Lessees asserted that the marks on the Google Earth image largely depicted roads of that kind.
310 I accept that the Google Earth image alone was not sufficient to confirm that the lines marked upon it were roads. However, that conclusion could be reasonably drawn from the other information provided. In addition, the Google Earth image was not of itself sufficient to identify with precision the boundaries of the areas constituting the roads to be used by the tourists. Importantly, however, the definition of the phrase “clear description” does not demand that degree of precision. The approximate boundary of that lineal space could be “worked out” by having regard to the Lessees’ stated purpose of including the roads within the non-pastoral use area – being the stated purpose of vehicular movement between destinations. That purpose was capable of incorporating some area on the roadsides for pulling vehicles over. The approximate boundaries could fairly be “worked out” by accommodating some width on either side of the roads for that ancillary or incidental purpose. Ground 3 is not established to the extent that it alleged that the Second Native Title Notification did not fairly disclose the proposed future act for which the Lessees themselves had applied by their revised application. I reject that discrete aspect of Top End’s submissions.
311 The peculiar feature of the present case is that the Board ultimately granted a Tourism Permit for a much larger area of 60,257 ha and the circumstances in which that came about are not at all clear. The Second Native Title Notification did not purport on its face to contemplate a future act affecting an area of that size, nor did the accompanying information permit of an interpretation allowing the location of the affected area or its approximate boundaries to be “worked out” in any fashion. The inclusion of the Island Area is alone sufficient to demonstrate the point. The sizeable Island Area was not foreshadowed at all on the Google Earth image provided by the Lessees and accompanying the Second Native Title Notification. Nor am I satisfied that the Second Native Title Notification provided “enough” information to work out that the Tourism Permit would extend to an area of 500 m wide on either side of the long expanses of roads. Contrary to the Territory’s submission, that is a significant expansion because it goes beyond the utilitarian use of the roads referred to by the Lessees (the road area plus 20 m on either side) and opened up a 1 km thoroughfare along its very considerable length. The upshot of all of that is that the Board did not give notification of the future act it in fact proposed to do, and later purported to do. Ground 3 is upheld to that extent.
Ground 6
312 Ground 6 involves similar considerations. It alleges non-compliance by the Board with the public notification requirements in s 87A. Top End’s submissions were made equally in response to the public notification and hence it has standing to allege a non-compliance by the Board of that separate and discrete obligation. For the reasons given in connection with Ground 3, the Second Public Notification fairly represented the revised application the Lessees had made. The relevant error of the Board was that it did not decide the application that was made and notified. Accordingly, it is more appropriate to grant relief on the judicial review application by reference to Ground 5, rather than Ground 6, subject to considerations of materiality discussed below.
Procedural fairness and “ex parte” communications: Ground 8A(3)–(5)
313 Top End further alleged that it was denied procedural fairness by reason of the Board having regard to correspondence that had passed between the Lessees and the Department, the content of which was not made known to Top End and in respect of which it was not given an opportunity to be heard. Top End confirmed that it made no allegation of apprehended bias. It limited this Ground to a breach of the hearing rule by virtue of the decision maker having in its actual or constructive possession “ex parte communications” that were adverse to its interests. It contended that, apart from the public notification requirements in the Pastoral Land Act, the Board had an obligation to inform Top End of the nature and content of the ex parte communications that may be adverse to its interests: Commissioner for ACT Revenue v Alphaone Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 576 at 590 – 591 (Northrop, Miles and French JJ); SZBEL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2006) 228 CLR 152 at [29] (Gleeson CJ, Kirby, Hayne, Callinan and Heydon JJ); Peko-Wallsend at 58 – 60 (Brennan J).
314 The correspondence had the effect of expressing the Lessees’ intention that the area authorised for tourism purposes not be of a size that would engage s 24GB(4) of the Native Title Act. As identified earlier, s 24GB(4) operates to disapply s 24GB to a future act if the subject lease covers an area greater than 5,000 ha (as in the present case) and the future act has the effect that the majority of the area covered by the lease is required or permitted to be used for purposes other than pastoral purposes. In addition, the correspondence was said to be for the purpose of expressing the Lessees’ intention that the area of the permitted use avoid sacred sites and hence the risk that s 24GB(3) of the Native Title Act might be engaged. The Board was said to have had actual or constructive knowledge of the correspondence by reason of the facts set out below.
315 The Information Notice given to the Lessees on 10 November 2022 invited them to provide further information, including clarification of the “actual proposed footprint” of the area over which the tourism activities would occur. The Lessees were invited to provide spatial data and to identify the access tracks that were to be used. The time by which the Board would consider the application was deferred to permit the Lessees time to respond. Some of the correspondence records the extension of the deferral period over many months whilst the Lessees gathered and supplied additional information.
316 In some of the communications, the Lessees corresponded with a representative of the Department, Ms Rebecca de Vries. Three such emails were copied to (or later forwarded to) Mr Tom Garnham and Dr Alana Mackay. Mr Garnham’s name appears as a Department contact on the initial briefing paper provided to the Board on 18 November 2022. Ms Mackay was at relevant times the Director of the Pastoral Branch of the Department and is described in the evidence as a “standing observer” at Board meetings. She also signed the Recommendation Report of 11 March 2025 and the 18-19 March Briefing Paper provided to the Board in advance of the public meeting. In March 2025, Ms Mackay forwarded some of the Lessees’ correspondence to Dr Michael Wellington, the Board member having the responsibility for drafting the Endorsed Plan.
317 The particulars to this Ground refer to 16 emails variously dated between 11 September 2023 and 24 January 2024. It is unnecessary to summarise them all. In the course of submissions Top End focussed on three email exchanges between the Lessees and the Department.
318 The first was an email sent on 11 September 2023 from the Lessees’ representative to Ms de Vries stating (among other things) that the Lessees were awaiting “maps from Google Earth to be put into spatial data” as well as the outcome of the Water Extraction Licence application. The representative stated that the Google Maps were “very important to show the [B]oard that the tourism activities are limited to existing infrastructure and do not cover the majority of the lease area”.
319 The second was an email sent on 19 September 2023 from Ms de Vries to the Lessees’ representative stating that the “team” had reviewed the spatial data which “shows points only”. Ms de Vries required the Lessees to “provide a polygon shape showing the roads and points of interest” that were to be provided in the proposed permit area. Ms de Vries also expressed her understanding that the Lessees’ intention was to exclude areas with rock art from the permit area.
320 The third was an email sent on 20 September 2023 directly from Ms Marie Walker (one of the Lessees) to Ms de Vries. That correspondence addressed (among other things) the Department’s request for the proposed area to be shown with polygon shaping. Ms Walker said that she did not know what was meant by a polygon of the areas. She added that if she was to include all of the locations into a polygon, it would encompass the whole of the property, but the surface area covered by the destinations were only a small percentage of the whole. Ms Walker also referred to a Google Earth map and explained that it depicted existing haul roads and access tracks. She asked Ms de Vries to confirm if an attached Google Earth file was useful.
321 Those exchanges occurred before notification of the revised application occurred via the Second Native Title Notification and the Second Public Notice.
322 Dr Mackay forwarded the correspondence to Dr Wellington following his nomination as the Board member responsible for preparing the Endorsed Plan that was ultimately agreed upon at the Board meeting of 18 March 2025.
323 More generally, Top End relied upon correspondence passing between the Lessees and representatives of the Department that were not forwarded to Dr Wellington, comprising:
(1) additional correspondence from June 2023 to January 2024 regarding the shaping of the polygons for the endorsed plan to avoid covering sacred sites and a majority of the lease area, the formulation of the “buffer” on either side of the tracks, consideration of an abstract of records from AAPA and the progression of the applications for the Tourism Permit and the Water Extraction Licence;
(2) correspondence from January to February 2024 about the overlap of the permit area with sacred sites (in particular, Jump Up Loop Lookout) and the incorporation of buffers around those sites;
(3) correspondence in January 2024 regarding queries from the Lessees about plotting known sacred sites within the proposed permit area based on an AAPA abstract of records in the absence of an Authority Certificate; and
(4) correspondence in April 2024 about finalising the footprint of the endorsed plan following the Lessees’ submission of its response to the technical assessment.
Consideration
324 I am not satisfied that the fact or content of correspondence relied upon gives rise to a breach of the rules of procedural fairness.
325 The phrase “ex parte communication” is not an appropriate description for the emails passing between the Lessees and the Department. The Pastoral Land Act envisages that an application made to the Board may be handled administratively by representatives of the Department. That is especially so in circumstances where the Board seeks further information under s 86. The communications of 11, 19 and 20 September 2023 were made in a context in which the Department facilitated the provision of the additional information the Lessees sought to provide and included advice or directions about the form that the information should take. Section 25 of the Pastoral Land Act authorised the Board to consult with such persons and to make such enquiries as it thought fit in the exercise of its powers or performance of its statutory functions. The Board is not a court and Top End was not a “party” having an entitlement to be included in correspondence passing between the Lessees, the Department or the Board for that purpose.
326 Secondly, the content of the correspondence of September 2023 clearly disclosed the Lessees’ position that the permit area was comprised of the tourism destinations (excluding sacred sites) and existing access tracks or haul roads that would be used to travel between them. Fairly interpreted, Ms Walker’s concern was that the drawing of a single “polygon” shape would not properly reflect the Lessees’ intention that tourists would use existing roads and tracks when moving between the destinations, such that the permit sought was in respect of only a small portion of PL 757. The Lessees’ subjective intentions in that regard were fairly disclosed to Top End when the revised application was notified and by the Lessees’ submissions. In addition, the briefing paper circulated in advance of the public meeting reflected the intent of the Lessees that the issue of the permit be a future act to which s 24GB of the Native Title Act applied. Accordingly, the substance of the correspondence was encompassed within documents provided to Top End and Top End was afforded an opportunity to be heard in respect of that substantive subject matter.
327 I have already mentioned that the content of the Endorsed Plan, as prepared by Dr Wellington and agreed by the Board, remains something of a mystery. The area endorsed by the Board is not explained by the September 2023 correspondence forwarded by Dr Mackay to Dr Wellington in March 2025. The evidence does not show that the Lessees proposed the enlarged buffer along the lengths of the road nor that the Lessees proposed the inclusion of the Island Area. Nothing of that kind is referred to in the September 2023 communications. In that regard the Court was not shown an attachment to the Lessees’ correspondence described as a “shape file” (having a suffix .kmz) and no finding can be safely made with respect to its contents.
328 Nor does the evidence support a finding that the Lessees communicated with a Board member with a view to influencing a recommendation or decision of the Board (conduct that would contravene reg 4 of the Pastoral Land Regulations 1992 (NT)). It is not clear whether (and if so how) Dr Wellington deployed the correspondence in the preparation of the Endorsed Plan beyond the inference that he had regard to the Lessees’ intention that the permit area be confined in the manner described in the body of the emails. That intended confinement was disclosed in the materials proposing a permit area of 3,497.11 ha.
329 In addition, I am not satisfied that the discrete cohort of correspondence that was not in fact before any Board member should be characterised as being in the Board’s “constructive possession” so as to give rise to an obligation to afford Top End an opportunity to be heard in respect of its contents. The circumstance that Dr Mackay or Mr Garnham may have been identified as contacts for the Board or any other person, or that they prepared documents for the Board does not have the consequence that everything seen or heard by them should be regarded as having been seen or heard by the Board, let alone taken into account by it.
330 To the extent that it was submitted that Ms Mackay should be regarded as forming a part of the decision-maker by virtue of being involved in the Board’s deliberations, the submission is not made good on the evidence. In any event, I am not satisfied that the Board could act upon submissions, assertions or expressions of intent in correspondence of which no Board member had actual knowledge.
331 None of that detracts from my conclusion that Top End was entitled to be heard in respect of the revision of the area falling within the Tourism Permit ultimately issued. That entitlement was not sourced in the fact or content of the “ex parte” correspondence passing between the Lessees and the Department but rather arose because of the Board’s proposal to grant a permit in respect of an area not applied for by the Lessees.
Materiality of errors
332 The Board’s errors will not amount to jurisdictional error if they were immaterial to the Tourism Decision. An error will be material if there is a possibility that the Tourism Decision could realistically have been different if the error had not occurred: LPDT v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (2024) 280 CLR 321 at [7], [14] (Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Steward, Gleeson and Jagot JJ). The test is not onerous.
333 The materiality threshold is met in connection with the error established under Ground 8A(1). Top End was entitled to be furnished with information sufficient to enable it to direct the force of its submissions to the area described and not to some other area. More specifically, Top End was entitled to demonstrate the extent to which the non-pastoral use affected native title by reference to particular sites of significance. To make meaningful submissions Top End was entitled to be provided with a description of the area to which the proposed future act would relate sufficient for it to identify what native title rights and interests would be affected and how so.
334 The inclusion of the Island Area without notice to Top End is itself sufficient to satisfy the test for materiality for two reasons. First, the Island Area covers a recorded significant site. Second, its inclusion gave rise to an absurd and ambiguous situation in which there existed one part of the authorised area disconnected from all other parts, giving rise to a risk that the Lessees and tourists would argue there to be an implied right of passage to and from the disconnected part. It is unnecessary to decide whether the materiality threshold would have been met were it not for the foreshadowed and unexplained inclusion of the Island Area within the Endorsed Plan Area, but I am inclined to the view that it would have been. That is because the concentration of 12,000 to 15,000 tourists along the 1 km thoroughfare opened up the natural likelihood of vehicular movement and camping off roads in circumstances where the Lessees had sought to include the roads for the sole utilitarian purpose of movement between attractions as destination points. At the very least there might have been submissions concerning the impact of the permitted use upon the 1 km thoroughfare, giving rise to the possibility of a different outcome. The applicant might have argued that the 1 km thoroughfare went beyond what was necessary for the utilitarian purpose of travel between attraction sites.
335 In respect of the proven error alleged in Ground 5, I have concluded that the Board purported to exercise the power under s 85A in respect of an area of land over which there had been no application at all. I have no difficulty concluding that if the Board had given notice of its intention to grant a permit in respect of a larger expanse of area exceeding 60,000 ha, NLC would have made the very same arguments as it did in this proceeding on behalf of Top End. It would have submitted that the Board’s power was confined to the grant or refusal of an application made by a proponent under s 86 of the Pastoral Land Act and did not extend to expansion of a non-pastoral use to any other area. If the intentions of the Board had been duly notified, and such a submission were made, there is a reasonable likelihood that the Board would not have endorsed the plans created between the day of the public meeting and the day that the Tourism Decision was made. The Endorsed Plan Area might then have been confined to an area less than 3,497.11 ha following the exclusion of locations referred to in the Board’s Reasons.
336 As for the error disclosed by Ground 7, the obligation to consider the impact of the proposed use on the environment is a mandatory consideration for a reason. The inclusion of s 87(2)(c) assists in the advancement of the express objective that pastoral land be developed sustainably. The numerous environmental concerns raised by NLC were not insignificant. It is possible that their consideration with specific reference to the 60,257 ha area (particularly the roadway corridors and the Island Area) could realistically have resulted in a different outcome. At the very least it is possible that the Board might instead have called upon the Lessees to provide an updated environmental assessment with respect to the area that ultimately became the subject of the purported decision. That might realistically have included an assessment of the impact of the use of the 1 km thoroughfare for purposes other than mere transit and including off-road driving and camping. There was no reason to include a thoroughfare of that width other than in anticipation that the off-road thoroughfare could and would be used for tourism purposes including camping.
337 The Territory submitted that any non-compliance with the statutory notification requirements contained in the Native Title Act was not material in the requisite sense for two reasons. First, it was submitted that s 24GB(9) was “materially complied with”. I do not accept that submission. I have already found that the Second Native Title Notification was not a notification of the relevant proposed future act, that the Lessees had not applied for a Tourism Permit for an area as large as that decided and that there was no notification at all of the purported future act proposed to be made just prior to the Tourism Decision. It was then submitted that the evidence and contentions advanced by NLC before the Board were not limited to the notified areas but went well beyond them. Accordingly, it was submitted, any failure to give notice of a proposed future act affecting the larger area could not have materially affected the outcome. I reject those submissions.
338 Non-compliance with the notification requirements in s 24GB(9) of the Native Title Act was a material breach of the condition in s 87(2A) of the Pastoral Land Act in the sense that (at the very least) Top End was deprived of the opportunity to speak against the inclusion of the Island Area and the 1 km thoroughfare and there is a possibility that its submissions might have persuaded the Board not to proceed in the way that it did.
Invalidity and relief
339 The identification of a jurisdictional error affecting an administrative decision will not necessarily have the consequence that the decision is void ab initio for all purposes. Whether an erroneous decision is invalid in that sense turns on the proper construction of the statute under which the decision was made or purportedly made. As Gaudron and Gummow JJ explained in Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Bhardwaj (2002) 209 CLR 597, “the Parliament may give an administrative decision whatever force it wishes” (at [47]) and “an administrative decision has only such force and effect as is given to it by the law pursuant to which it was made” (at [46]). The same approach applies to enactments of the Northern Territory.
340 The Territory submitted that non-compliance with s 24GB(9) of the Native Title Act could not result in invalidity of the Tourism Decision under the Pastoral Land Act, notwithstanding s 87(2A) of that Act. I need not express a view about the correctness of that submission.
The Tourism Decision will be declared invalid because of the Board’s material non-compliance with a number of other pre-conditions on the exercise of its power identified in these reasons. There is nothing in the Pastoral Land Act to support a contention that a decision made other than in accordance with those other provisions should have the effect of validly authorising the Lessees to do what the Tourism Permit purports to authorise.
341 It follows that Top End is entitled to the declaration sought at [2] of the OA (extracted at [9] above). There will also be orders to the effect sought at [3] and [4] of the OA (namely an order in the nature of certiorari setting the Tourism Decision aside) and an order in the nature of mandamus requiring the Board to determine the Lessees’ application according to law.
342 The declaration sought by [1] of the OA is one premised on an assumption that the Tourism Decision was validly made under the Pastoral Land Act. The invalidity of the Tourism Decision means that it does not fall within the definition of a “future act” in s 233 of the Native Title Act and s 24GB cannot operate in respect of it. Even if the Tourism Decision was valid (apart from the Native Title Act) I would not have made the declaration sought, given the conclusions I have drawn about the coverage of s 24GB.
THE WATER DECISION
343 The Water Extraction Licence authorised LSS to extract a maximum of 31.2 ML of water each year from Rosie Creek via a river pump. In its application LSS stated that the licence was for tourism purposes, particularly in relation to “campground irrigation and supply of water to facilities and ablutions during the dry season”.
344 By Grounds 10 and 12 Top End alleged that the Water Decision was not validly made under the Water Act. If those Grounds were to be upheld, the Water Decision could not constitute a “future act” within the meaning of s 233 of the Native Title Act.
345 Alternatively, by Ground 9 Top End argued that if validly made under the Water Act, the Water Decision is a future act to which s 24HA of the Native Title Act applies, that it is valid for the purposes of the Native Title Act and that the native title holders are therefore entitled to compensation in respect of it.
346 Declarations were sought in either case.
347 It remains necessary to resolve the Grounds of review relating to the Water Decision notwithstanding that the Tourism Decision will be quashed. That is because the Lessees’ application for a non-pastoral use permit remains on foot and the grant of a licence for the taking of water has been lawfully required by the Board as a necessary step before the proposed tourism activities can commence. The Court was not asked to determine whether water could be extracted pursuant to the Water Extraction Licence notwithstanding the setting aside of the Tourism Decision and I should not be understood to express a view on that question.
The Water Act
348 The Water Act has been amended since the Water Decision was made. The provisions discussed below are those in force at the relevant times.
349 Section 45(1) of the Water Act confers upon the Controller the discretion to grant a person a licence to take water that is flowing or contained in a waterway. When an application is made for a licence, the Controller must give public notice of the application and invite written comments: Water Act, s 71B. The comments must be taken into account: Water Act, s 71C(2). In addition, the Controller must take into account the factors mentioned in s 90(1) of the Water Act, so far as they are relevant to the decision. They include:
(b) the existing and likely future demand for water for domestic purposes in the area in question;
(c) any adverse effects likely to be created as a result of activities under the permit, licence or consent on the supply of water to which any person other than the applicant is entitled under this Act;
…
350 A person aggrieved by a decision of the Controller to grant a water extraction licence may apply to the Minister for a review: Water Act, s 30(1).
351 On review, the Minister must have regard to the same factors as the Controller, including comments made under s 71B(4) and the factors in s 90(1): s 71E(4). The review to be conducted is a de novo review on the merits. However, as Hiley J explained in Environment Centre Northern Territory (NT) Incorporated v Minister for Land Resource Management (2015) 35 NTLR 140 at [151], the correct task of the Minister requires as follows:
• that the [Controller’s] decision is not to be ignored but that the [Minister] needs to decide for himself whether that decision is wrong and what is the “true and correct” or “preferable and correct” decision;
• a broad ranging factual enquiry afresh is not necessarily required;
• the [Minister] has a wide choice available as to how he or she undertakes the task of deciding what is the true and correct decision;
• error (or lack of it) by the [Controller] will or may be relevant to the [Minister’s] task, but does not define the task.
352 The Minister may uphold the Controller’s decision, substitute for the decision a decision that the Minister considers should have been made, or refer a matter back to the Controller for reconsideration: Water Act, s 30(3).
Top End’s submissions to the Controller
353 It is common ground that the native title holders are persons who have entitlements to take water from the same source affected by the grant of the Water Extraction Licence, being the Rosie River and Rosie Creek catchments. Their entitlement to take water from the area covered by PL 757 is recognised in the Determination, and reinforced (if not separately conferred) by s 38(1)(n) of the Pastoral Land Act. In addition, the native title holders are entitled to occupy the land on or adjacent to the relevant waterways and hence have statutory rights to take water from the relevant waterways in accordance with s 11 of the Water Act. The rights just described are non-exclusive.
354 In accordance with s 71B of the Water Act, the Controller gave notice of an intention to make a decision on LSS’s application. Top End (by its representative NLC) made submissions in connection with the proposed decision and the Controller was obliged to take those submissions into account under s 71C(2). Top End’s submissions were to the effect that the proposed Water Extraction Licence would likely impact on sacred sites in the vicinity of Rosie Creek, some of which were water-dependent. It was submitted that works for the taking of water under the Water Extraction Licence would themselves interfere with sites in a manner contrary to the Sacred Sites Act. It was further submitted that the grant of the Water Extraction Licence would be a future act that could not be done until an ILUA was negotiated. Top End also submitted that the Controller should have regard to the Lessees’ prior contraventions of the Water Act by the unauthorised taking of water from the catchment, including by interfering with Rosie Creek in 2020 and should reject the application because of the Lessees’ character.
355 The Controller’s reasons for granting the Water Extraction Licence included a finding that there was sufficient water available to provide for the amount proposed to be taken annually by the Lessees, “even at the most conservative estimates of creek flows”.
356 The Controller concluded:
Furthermore, the calculated flow rates are derived from conservative estimates of average dry season flows, with 20% of those values used to determine the estimated sustainable extraction flowing [sic] the framework. Considering that the creek typically experiences flow rates between 10 and 100 litres per second, and the springs themselves have a recorded flow rate of 30-40 L/s, the proposed extraction of 31.2 ML/yr, constitutes a minimal fraction of the observed flows within the creek and falls within the natural variation expected. Change to flow rates and therefore water levels within the creek are more likely to be linked to seasonal fluctuations·rather than the extraction itself.
357 The Controller was satisfied that the Lessees had verified a need for the extraction of water, specifically to support tourism activities during the peak tourism season. The Controller said that it was unlikely that there were any other beneficial users who would be adversely affected.
358 Those findings were based on a 2009 report provided by the Lessees, referred to as the Gulf Water Study. The Controller concluded that changes to flow rates in Rosie Creek were more likely caused by seasonal fluctuations rather than the Lessees’ extraction of water and that the extraction in and of itself would not impact surrounding sacred sites.
359 The Controller was not satisfied that the grant of the Water Extraction Licence would extinguish native title, nor that the grant of the Water Extraction Licence would inhibit the native title holders from accessing water. Accordingly, the Controller was not satisfied that the grant of the Water Extraction Licence was a future act to which s 24HA of the Native Title Act could apply.
360 As to the alleged past contraventions of the Lessees or LSS, the Controller said they had engaged with the responsible Department to licence the water use and that issuing a licence would “improve the management of the resource and contribute to protecting any significant points of interest”.
361 With some exceptions, the Water Extraction Licence authorised LSS to take 31.2 ML from specified extraction points of Rosie Creek each year for a period of 10 years. It is a condition that the water be extracted for the purpose of “Industry”. No particular industry is specified.
362 The Minister affirmed the Controller’s decision on 20 September 2024. The reasons for the Minister’s Decision will be considered in the context of addressing Grounds 10 and 12 below (Ground 11 is not pressed).
Grounds 10 and 12
363 Ground 10 is to the effect that the Minister failed to have regard to the mandatory considerations specified in s 90(1)(b) and (c) of the Water Act. Ground 12 is to the effect that the Minister failed to take into account Top End’s comments made pursuant to s 71B(4) but rather adopted the Controller’s conclusions on those comments without coming to his own view on the merits of their subject matter.
364 Neither Ground is made out.
365 The Minister’s reasons set out a summary of the Grounds upon which Top End relied for the purposes of the review in dot points as follows:
• water licence activities cannot be done except in contravention of Northern Territory Sacred Sites Act 1989 (Sacred Sites Act);
• the Controller did not impose a condition on the Licence that the Licence Holder obtain an Authority Certificate under the Sacred Sites Act;
• the Controller did not consider the invalidity of the proposed tourism operation;
• no consideration of current or accurate data to determine water availability;
• misunderstanding of lawful occupation and use;
• did not consider cultural use pursuant to s90(1)(e);
• seek the [Minister] to notify native title holders in accordance with the Native Title Act 1993; and
• procedural fairness denied to native title holders.
366 Collectively the Grounds asserted the rights and interests of the native title holders in that capacity and in any event as persons having entitlements to extract water from Rosie Creek. The Minister then addressed each of the Grounds in turn, including in each case an elaboration of Top End’s submission and the reason why the submission was not accepted. The subject matter of the submissions encapsulates at least the factual subject matter mentioned in s 90(1)(b) and (c) of the Water Act.
367 At the conclusion of the reasons and under the heading “Comments made under s 71B(4)”, the Minister stated:
In making my decision I adopt the Controller’s consideration of the comments made on the application under s 71B(4).
368 Top End submitted that the Minister had misunderstood the nature of the review because he had not turned his own mind to the merits of LSS’s application (as he was required to do) but rather had asked himself whether the decision to grant the Water Extraction Licence was one that was reasonably open to the Controller. On that topic, Top End relied on portions of the reasons in which the Minister referred to things that the Controller had said or done and expressed views about whether the Controller was correct or had erred or had adopted an approach that was available on the materials.
369 I do not accept those submissions.
370 The passages complained of are explained by the circumstance that Top End had advanced its own Grounds of review in terms alleging errors on the part of the Controller. That portion of the reasons may be understood as evidencing the Minister’s response to the Grounds as Top End had articulated them. Their inclusion in the reasons does not support a conclusion that the Minister misunderstood his statutory task on review. In some passages there is some intermixing between the Minister’s views about the Controller’s decision and the Minister’s own conclusions. However, on considering those passages as a whole and in their proper context it remains clear enough that the Minister engaged with the comments Top End had made under s 71B(4) whilst at the same time responding to Top End’s complaints about the Controller’s approach. The reasons either directly engage with the subject matter, or it is otherwise implicit that the views reached by the Controller were shared by the Minister.
371 For example, with respect to the protection of sacred sites, the Minister found that the Lessees had an obligation to comply with the Sacred Sites Act and that the Lessees were at that time in the process of obtaining an Authority Certificate to support their application for the Tourism Permit. The Minister said that the Authority Certificate would capture the area of the water extraction and that the Lessees would not be released from their obligations under the Sacred Sites Act. The effect of those reasons was that the grant of the Water Extraction Licence did not authorise any contravention of the Sacred Sites Act.
372 The Minister’s reasons concerning the adequacy of the water supply to sustain the Water Extraction Licence typify the way in which the reasons were expressed on other topics. In response to a ground alleging that there was no consideration by the Controller of current or accurate data to determine water availability, the Minister said:
The NLC contends that the Controller relied on the Gulf Water study (Zaar, 2009) which was published 15 years ago (the Zaar Report) and would not have taken into account the impacts of the volume of water the Licence Holder has previously extracted annually.
Given the minimal demand for water in the area there has been no imperative for further resource assessment work to have been undertaken.
In making the Decision, the Controller noted the Zaar Report classified Rosie Creek in the vicinity of the Lorella Springs as a regional waterway providing minimum flow of between 10 and 100 L/s at the end of the dry season.
Adopting a conservative approach for the purpose of describing water availability and using the lower end of the range (10 L/s), the daily flow in Rosie Creek is at least 864 kL/d or 157.2 ML/yr (dry season/ 6-months).
Under the Northern Territory Water Allocation Planning Framework the contingent allocation for a Top End river basin, such as Rosie Creek in the dry season is calculated as 20% of the river flows which sets the amount available from Rosie Creek at 31.4 ML/yr. This has been set at a highly precautionary level using the lowest end of the daily flow range. The Controller’s Decision to grant the 31.2 ML/yr is within the allocation available.
Based on the material before me, I consider the information considered by the Controller, which included the establishment of a highly precautionary allocation limit was sufficient to enable the Controller to make the Decision.
373 By way of further example, the Minister stated his own conclusion that there was minimal demand for water from the catchment and it was hence unnecessary for any further assessment of the resource to be undertaken. The Minister’s finding to the effect that the Controller did not err by having regard to the Gulf Water Study reflects the Minister’s engagement with the arguments that Top End had raised on that topic. It does not evidence a misunderstanding of the Minister’s powers on review.
374 Top End otherwise submitted that the Minister’s approach of merely adopting the Controller’s consideration of the comments it had made under s 71B(4) showed that the Minister had misunderstood his task or otherwise failed to independently consider and resolve the issues raised by those comments for three reasons. First, the subject matter of Top End’s comments under s 71B(4) was largely traversed elsewhere in the Minister’s reasons when responding to the Grounds that Top End had itself identified. It was not necessary for the Minister to repeat what he had previously said in connection with the same factual subject matter. When reviewing the Controller’s decision on the merits it was open to the Minister to express his own conclusions by expressing his agreement (by adoption) with the conclusions of the Controller. When read in conjunction with the reasons as a whole, the sentence appearing under the heading “Comments made under s 71B(4)” does not support a conclusion that the Minister failed to perform the function of a merits review.
375 By addressing each of Top End’s Grounds in turn, the Minister discharged the obligation to have regard to the considerations specified in s 90(1)(b) and (c) of the Water Act. The submissions in support of Ground 10 amount to an expression of disagreement with the Minister’s factual conclusions with respect to those considerations but do not disclose reviewable error. The contention that the Minister failed to have regard to the subject matter at all cannot be sustained, nor can the contention that the Minister failed to comply with the requirement under s 71C of the Water Act to independently consider the comments that Top End had made.
376 There is no basis to declare the Water Decision to be invalid by reference to the errors alleged. Accordingly, the relief sought at [6]-[8] of the OA will not be granted.
The Water Decision is not a future act
377 It remains to resolve Top End’s application for a declaration that the Water Decision “is a future act consisting of the grant of a licence under legislation that relates to the management of surface and subterranean water within s 24HA(2) of the [Native Title Act]”, as alleged in Ground 9.
378 That relief turns on questions of fact and law arising directly under the Native Title Act and proceeds from the starting point that the decision to grant the Water Extraction Licence was validly made under the Water Act. To succeed on that part of the application Top End must first establish that the grant of the Water Extraction Licence meets the description of a future act. Among other things, it must establish that the grant affects the native title of the native title holders: Native Title Act, s 233.
379 An act affects native title if it extinguishes the native title rights and interests or if it is otherwise wholly or partly inconsistent with their continued existence, enjoyment or exercise: Native Title Act, s 227.
380 Together, cll 9(b), 14(d), 15(f) and 16 of the Determination (at least) demonstrate the existence and nature of native title rights and interests with respect to the taking and use of water. The Determination is conclusive on that issue. However, the Determination does not demonstrate whether (and if so how) the grant of the Water Extraction Licence affects the native title in the relevant sense.
381 In the present case, the native title rights and interests are non-exclusive. As such, the native title holders do not have the direct right to control the access or use of the land and waters by any other person. The rights (and the enjoyment of the rights) co-exist with the rights of others to take and use water from the same resource. The mere circumstance that another person has been granted rights to take water does not of itself affect the native title.
382 In some respects, the rights and interests are akin to those described by the High Court in Griffiths (at [69]):
As the trial judge found, the Claim Group’s rights and interests were essentially usufructuary, ceremonial and non-exclusive. The Claim Group’s rights and interests were perpetual and objectively valuable in that they entitled the Claim Group to live upon the land and exploit it for non-commercial purposes. But they were limited. As earlier mentioned, the historic grant of the pastoral leases extinguished the Claim Group’s traditional right to control access to the land and to decide how the land should be used; and, once so extinguished, the right did not revive. Thereafter, the Claim Group had no entitlement to exclude others from entering onto the land and no right to control the conduct of others on the land. Nor did the Claim Group have the right to grant co-existing rights and interests in the land. And because the Claim Group’s native title rights and interests were non-exclusive, it was also open to the Northern Territory to grant additional co-existent rights and interests in and over the land, including grazing licences, usufructuary licences of up to five years’ duration and licences to take various things from the land.
(citations omitted)
383 I say “in some respects” because there may be cases in which the right to take water is not merely usufructuary but rather is fundamental to the exercise and enjoyment of a non-usufructuary right, such as the right to occupy and live upon the land.
384 I accept Top End’s submission that it is not necessary for the native title holders to adduce evidence of their actual exercise of the right to take water at the time that the Water Decision was made: Banjima People v Western Australia (No 2) [2013] FCA 868; (2013) 305 ALR 1 at [1098] (Barker J). The focus is upon the existence of the right and the continued capacity of the native title holders to exercise it.
385 However, I am not satisfied that the native title rights and interests are necessarily affected by the grant of a right to another person to take water from the same place. As the Territory correctly submitted, water is a “moveable, wandering” and rechargeable resource: ICM Agriculture Pty Ltd v Commonwealth (2009) 240 CLR 140 at [55], [57] (French CJ, Gummow and Crennan JJ) and [109], [112] (Hayne, Kiefel and Bell JJ).
386 Contrary to Top End’s submission, the facts are not akin to those in Banjima. In that case, the future act was the authorisation of the expansion of a mine which “on its face” affected the capacity of the native title holders to use the land for hunting, gathering, ceremonial or other purposes.
387 Whether the capacity of the native title holders to draw water from the area covered by PL 757 is affected by the Water Decision cannot be determined on the face of the Determination and the Water Extraction Licence themselves.
388 As a general proposition I accept that a non-exclusive right to take water may be “affected” by an act that diminishes the resource in a way that threatens its availability to such an extent that the native title right cannot also be exercised. However, whether it does so is a question of fact to be assessed in the ordinary course on the evidence. This is not a case where the consequence of an authorised act upon native title necessarily follows by reference to the nature and scope of the authorised act and the nature of the native title right or interest said to be affected: see the discussion in Narrier v Western Australia [2016] FCA 1519 at [1068] – [1069] (Mortimer J).
389 The Court has before it the Water Extraction Licence but there is no evidence to contextualise the authorised act by reference to the relevant water resource and no factual basis to conclude that the authorisation granted to LSS would affect the capacity of the native title holders to exercise and enjoy their co-existing right to draw water from the same source. It follows that Top End has not established that the taking of the authorised allocation by LSS would be wholly or partially inconsistent with the native title holders’ determined rights.
390 I am not satisfied that the Water Decision is a future act. It is hence unnecessary to postulate whether s 24HA of the Native Title Act would apply to it.
391 The declaratory relief sought at [5] of the OA will not be granted.
I certify that the preceding three hundred and ninety-one (391) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Justice Charlesworth J. |
Associate:
Dated: 13 November 2026
SCHEDULE OF PARTIES
NTD 9 of 2025 | |
Respondents | |
Fourth Respondent: | CONTROLLER OF WATER RESOURCES (NT) |
Fifth Respondent: | LORELLA SPRING'S STATION PTY LTD (ACN 099 921 785) |
Sixth Respondent: | MAXIMUS NO. 82 PTY LIMITED (ACN 010 026 070) |
Seventh Respondent: | LANDMARK DEVELOPMENTS PTY LIMITED (ACN 008 649 732) |