Federal Court of Australia

Copper Mines of Tasmania Pty Ltd v Gaspersic Contracting Pty Ltd [2026] FCA 1712

File number(s):

TAD 45 of 2024

Judgment of:

NESKOVCIN J

Date of judgment:

13 November 2026

Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to amend defence and file further expert evidence – where pleadings have closed and matter is ready to be listed for trial – where proposed amendments speculative and depend on terms of hypothetical future lease – no reasonable explanation for delay – prejudice – application dismissed

Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 16.02, 16.51, 16.53

Environmental Management and Pollution Control Act 1994 (Tas) s 27B

Cases cited:

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175; [2009] HCA 27

Bellgrove v Eldridge (1954) 90 CLR 613

Caason Investments Pty Ltd v Cao (2015) 236 FCR 322; [2015] FCAFC 94

Dye v Commonwealth Securities Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCAFC 118

Selvaratnam v St George – A Division of Westpac Banking Corporation (No 2) [2021] FCA 486

Soar Development Group Pty Ltd v Fung [2026] FCA 1491

Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd (2009) 236 CLR 272; [2009] HCA 8

University of Sydney v ResMed Ltd (No 5) [2012] FCA 232

Division:

General Division

Registry:

Tasmania

National Practice Area:

Commercial and Corporations

Sub-area:

Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance

Number of paragraphs:

32

Date of hearing:

27 October 2026

Counsel for the Applicant:

C D McMeniman

Solicitor for the Applicant:

Norton Rose Fulbright Australia

Counsel for the Respondents:

D C Morgan

Solicitor for the Respondents:

Page Seager Lawyers

ORDERS

TAD 45 of 2024

BETWEEN:

COPPER MINES OF TASMANIA PTY LTD

Applicant

AND:

GASPERSIC CONTRACTING PTY LTD

First Respondent

IAN HARRINGTON GROUP PTY LTD

Second Respondent

order made by:

NESKOVCIN J

DATE OF ORDER:

13 november 2026

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.    The respondents’ interlocutory application filed on 2 October 2026 is dismissed.

2.    The respondents pay the applicant’s costs of the application, to be assessed in default of agreement.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

NESKOVCIN J:

1    The applicant, Copper Mines of Tasmania Pty Ltd, holds a Mining Lease in respect of the Mt Lyell copper mine near Queenstown, Tasmania. The Lease is in force until 30 December 2027, however, the mine has been under “care and maintenance” since 2014.

2    The first respondent, Gaspersic Contracting Pty Ltd, occupied a quarry on the land which is the subject of the Lease from 2003 to December 2023, and carried on quarrying operations until at least October 2020. The second respondent, Ian Harrington Group Pty Ltd, wholly owns Gaspersic. For convenience, I will refer to the respondents as Gaspersic.

3    Copper Mines says that Gaspersic occupied the quarry pursuant to a written Sub-Lease. The dispute in the proceeding concerns Gaspersic’s alleged breach of its obligation under the Sub-Lease to rehabilitate the quarry. Although Gaspersic disputes the validity of the Sub-Lease, I will refer to the Sub-Lease and Gaspersic’s obligations under the Sub-Lease in these reasons for convenience.

4    Following a recent announcement by Copper Mines’ parent company that its Board had resolved to reopen the mine, Gaspersic filed an interlocutory application seeking leave to file and serve an amended defence and further expert evidence in support of the proposed amendments. In summary terms, the proposed amendments and further expert evidence seek to deny that Copper Mines will suffer any loss because its obligation to rehabilitate the quarry will arise from further activities and not from any breach by Gaspersic of the Sub-Lease.

5    Gaspersic accepted that the pleadings were closed and leave to amend is required, pursuant to r 16.53 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), except where the amendments concerned facts that occurred since the proceeding commenced: r 16.51(4). Copper Mines opposed the application on the grounds of futility, delay and prejudice.

Background

6    The Lease was granted to Copper Mines in October 2013 and is in force until 30 December 2027. Under the Lease, Copper Mines is obliged to rehabilitate worked-out areas of the mine when the mining operations come to an end.

7    The Court was told that, in October 2020, Copper Mines closed the access road to the quarry and quarrying operations ceased at around that time.

8    Copper Mines says that on 17 October 2023, it:

(a)    gave Gaspersic notice of termination of the Sub-Lease, and the Sub-Lease was terminated with effect from 1 December 2023; and

(b)    directed Gaspersic to perform its rehabilitation obligations under the terms of the Sub-Lease.

9    As already mentioned, Gaspersic disputes the validity of the Sub-Lease. It is common ground that it has not undertaken rehabilitation works at the quarry.

10    In December 2024, a Notice of Intent with respect to the Mt Lyell Copper Project was submitted to the Environment Protection Authority (EPA) pursuant to s 27B of the Environmental Management and Pollution Control Act 1994 (Tas).

11    The Notice of Intent, which has been publicly available since 7 March 2025, set out a proposal for the reopening of the mine.

12    On 2 September 2026, the Board of Copper Mines’ parent company, Sibanye-Stillwater, announced that it had resolved to reopen the mine. That decision was also reported in a media article and via a media release by the Tasmanian Minister for Business, Industry and Resources.

13    Following those announcements, on 2 October 2026, Gaspersic filed the interlocutory application seeking leave to file a proposed amended defence and expert evidence in support of the amendments.

Applicable principles

14    The applicable principles in relation to pleading amendments are well-established and were not in dispute.

15    Relevantly, once pleadings have closed, a party may only amend a pleading to plead a fact or matter that has occurred or arisen since the proceeding started or with leave of the Court: rr 16.51(4) and 16.53(1) of the Rules.

16    The discretion to grant leave to amend is broad, but must be exercised in a manner that best promotes the Court’s overarching purpose to facilitate the just resolution of disputes according to law and as quickly, inexpensively and efficiently as possible: s 37M of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth); see Caason Investments Pty Ltd v Cao (2015) 236 FCR 322; [2015] FCAFC 94 at [19] (Gilmour, Foster and Edelman JJ).

17    Relevant factors to consider include the nature and importance of the proposed amendment to the party seeking it, the stage reached in the proceeding, the explanation for the amendment, any resulting delay or prejudice, and whether prejudice can adequately be addressed by costs. The Court must also consider the efficient use of its resources, the interests of other litigants, the objective that the pleadings identify the “real” issues between the parties and the objective of doing justice between the parties: Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175; [2009] HCA 27 at [30] (French CJ), [95], [97] (Gummow, Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ); University of Sydney v ResMed Ltd (No 5) [2012] FCA 232 at [14] (Stone J); Selvaratnam v St George – A Division of Westpac Banking Corporation (No 2) [2021] FCA 486 at [28] (Stewart J); Soar Development Group Pty Ltd v Fung [2026] FCA 1491 at [34] (Cheeseman J).

18    The party seeking leave bears the onus of satisfying the Court that the discretion should be exercised in its favour: Dye v Commonwealth Securities Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCAFC 118 at [17] (Marshall, Rares and Flick JJ).

Proposed amendments to the defence

19    By the proposed amendments to its defence, Gaspersic seeks to raise the following matters and facts, some of which post-date the commencement of the proceeding (commenced on 17 December 2024):

(a)    additional clauses of the Lease, which is in force until 30 December 2027, relevantly including cl 6.1(b), which provides that Copper Mines “must extract as much of the economic mineral or minerals in the Lease Area as is consistent with the Authorised Purpose, safety and good mining practice”;

(b)    in December 2024, a Notice of Intent was submitted to the EPA, which set out a proposal for the reopening of the mine and stated that the access road to the Sub-Lease area is to be used for the purposes of reopening the mine;

(c)    on 2 September 2026, the Board of Sibanye-Stillwater resolved to reopen the mine;

(d)    the decision to reopen the mine has been endorsed by the Minister; and

(e)    according to Copper Mines and the Minister, the mine will deliver an initial 23-year mine life.

20    In addition, Gaspersic seeks to amend its bare denial of the allegation that Copper Mines has suffered loss and damage by reason of Gaspersic’s alleged breach of its rehabilitation obligations under the Sub-Lease to plead the following matters (emphasis added, particulars omitted):

25A.    The Applicant will have no obligation to rehabilitate the Lease Area unless and until such time as it no longer holds a lease in respect of the Lease Area.

25B.    In circumstances where both the lessor and lessee to the Mining Lease (ie the Minister and the Applicant) have decided to reopen the mine site and recommence mining operations with an initial 23-year life, any obligation on the Applicant to rehabilitate the Lease Area will not arise for at least 23 years.

25C.    Clause 6.1 (b) of the Mining Lease compels the Applicant to extract from the quarry as much of the economic minerals as is consistent with the Authorised Purpose, safety and good mining practice.

25D.    Acting reasonably and in conformance with both its obligations under the Mining Lease and its duty to mitigate any loss suffered as the result of any breach of the 2020 Sublease, the Applicant is required to reopen the quarry and recommence quarrying activities there.

25E.    Following the future activities referred to paragraph 25D, any subsequent rehabilitation obligation in respect of the quarry will:

(a)    vary significantly in scope and cost from any rehabilitation that might arise today; and

(b)    will arise from those further activities and not from any breach by the First Respondent of the 2020 Sub-Lease.

Disposition

21    As Copper Mines submitted, there is an incoherence in the proposed amended defence in that, while it acknowledges that the Lease term will come to an end in December 2027, it seeks to rely on Copper Mines’ obligation under cl 6.1(b) of the Lease which “compels” it to “extract from the quarry as much of the economic minerals as is consistent with the Authorised Purpose, safety and good mining practice”. Counsel for Gaspersic acknowledged that the proposed amended defence is deficient in that it does not plead or refer to a future lease, however, they submitted that it was “implicit” that Gaspersic contends that there would be a further lease after the Lease expires. Pausing there, the obvious difficulty for Gaspersic is that the Lease expires at the end of December 2027 and there presently is no lease under which Copper Mines has any rehabilitation obligations beyond the end of the term of the Lease. Counsel for Gaspersic also acknowledged that there is no certainty that Copper Mines and the Minister would in the future enter into a lease that contains terms similar to cl 6.1(b) of the Lease, which is crucial to its pleading amendment.

22    Counsel for Gaspersic explained that Gaspersic seeks to deny that Copper Mines will suffer any loss from Gaspersic’s breach of the Sub-Lease in two steps. First, in light of the recent decision to reopen the mine, Gaspersic says that Copper Mines’ own obligation to rehabilitate the Lease area will not arise for at least 23 years. Secondly, Gaspersic says that by that time, Copper Mines’ rehabilitation obligation in respect of the quarry will “vary significantly in scope and cost from any rehabilitation that might arise today” and will arise from “the future activities referred to [in] paragraph 25D”, and not from any breach by Gaspersic of the Sub-Lease (paragraph 25E).

23    The relevant “future activities referred to in paragraph 25D” are the reopening of the quarry and recommencement of quarrying activities. Copper Mines submitted that Gaspersic has been aware since at least December 2025, when Copper Mines’ lay evidence was filed, that Copper Mines does not intend to reopen the quarry and the principles of mitigation of loss do not require it, as the innocent party, to recommence quarrying activities that it does not intend to conduct. Gaspersic acknowledged that Copper Mines said that it does not intend to reopen the quarry, however, it submitted that this is not fatal to its amendment because its contention, “[a]ssuming these matters are made good on the evidence”, will be that Copper Mines “is required to reopen the quarry and recommence quarrying activities there”.

24    By paragraph 25D of the proposed amended defence, Gaspersic seeks to plead that “[a]cting reasonably and in conformance with both its obligations under the Mining Lease and its duty to mitigate any loss suffered as the result of any breach of the 2020 Sublease, [Copper Mines] is required to reopen the quarry and recommence quarrying activities there” (emphasis added).

25    First and foremost, there is no lease under which Copper Mines presently has any “obligations” post-2027 with respect to the Lease area, including the quarry. Copper Mines’ obligations under the Lease will come to an end when the Lease expires in December 2027. It is a matter of conjecture and speculation as to whether any future lease will include a rehabilitation obligation in similar terms to cl 6.1(b) of the Lease. A pleading must state the material facts: r 16.02(1)(d). A matter of conjecture or speculation is not a “material fact” and ought not be allowed. Having reached that conclusion, it is unnecessary to address Copper Mines’ further submission that the proposed amendments are futile because they are inconsistent with admissions in the defence and with the existing expert evidence.

26    Secondly, Gaspersic has been aware since at least June 2025, in the context of a contested discovery application, that Copper Mines was undertaking studies in respect of restarting mining operations and the Notice of Intent has been publicly available since March 2025. There was no explanation in Gaspersic’s evidence for the delay in seeking to amend the defence, including the plea that Copper Mines’ duty to mitigate its loss “required [it] to reopen the quarry and recommence quarrying activities there”: see Aon at [30] (French CJ), [103] (Gummow, Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ). Counsel for Gaspersic acknowledged that the amendment application could have been made earlier but submitted that this is a matter that goes to the Court’s discretion, and proffered two explanations for the delay. First, it was submitted that an earlier application would have been met by an argument that the plea was purely speculative. The announcement that the mine will be reopened has removed that uncertainty and that objection can no longer be taken. Secondly, the pleading amendments arise from having briefed Counsel bringing “fresh eyes” to the pleading. While Counsel’s candour is to be commended, the recent decision to reopen the mine does not relate to the quarry and Copper Mines’ position in relation to the quarry has been made clear for some time. As a result, Counsel’s submissions do not alter the position that Gaspersic has not put forward a reasonable explanation for the delay in seeking to amend to plead that Copper Mines’ duty to mitigate its loss required it to reopen the quarry.

27    Gaspersic clarified that the purpose of the amendment to its defence was not to suggest that Copper Mines’ own rehabilitation obligations under the Lease affected Gaspersic’s rehabilitation obligations under the Sub-Lease but rather to support the contention that Copper Mines will suffer no loss from the alleged failure of Gaspersic to fulfil its obligations. It is therefore unnecessary to address Copper Mines’ further objection that Copper Mines’ own rehabilitation obligations are not relevant to Gaspersic’s rehabilitation obligations. As Copper Mines submitted, its claim relates to breach of Gaspersic’s obligations under the Sub-Lease and it sues on the loss of the bargain for which the ordinary measure of loss is the cost of the promised works, assessed at the date of breach: Bellgrove v Eldridge (1954) 90 CLR 613 at 617 – 618 (Dixon CJ, Webb and Taylor JJ); Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd (2009) 236 CLR 272; [2009] HCA 8 at [13] (French CJ, Gummow, Heydon, Crennan and Kiefel JJ).

28    Gaspersic accepted that there would be costs thrown away by the amendment. Copper Mines submitted that granting the application will cause prejudice which cannot be compensated for by an order for costs. Pleadings closed more than 12 months ago. Lay and expert evidence was filed between December 2025 and August 2026 and the matter is ready to be listed for trial. Disputes over discovery in this proceeding spanned more than a year, with two contested hearings before Registrar Ellis. Granting the application would reopen the pleadings, necessitate further expert evidence and, in my assessment, it is reasonably likely that Gaspersic would reagitate the discovery applications that it lost before Registrar Ellis.

29    In my assessment, granting the amendment at this stage of the proceeding would cause prejudice to Copper Mines by reason of further costs and may cause delay to the trial, which is to be listed in April next year. The proposed amendments rely upon and seek to plead matters that relate to a future lease that has not been entered into and whose terms are a matter of conjecture and speculation, which ought not be allowed. For those reasons, in the exercise of the discretion, leave to amend should be refused.

30    For completeness, although leave was not required under r 16.51(4) of the Rules for the proposed amendments that concerned events that occurred since the proceeding commenced, those amendments were part of the broader amendments sought by Gaspersic. For the reasons given, leave to amend should be refused.

Conclusion

31    There will be an order that Gaspersic’s interlocutory application filed on 2 October 2026 be dismissed, with costs.

32    The Court was told that the Notice of Intent envisages that the reopening of the mine may incorporate the use of the access road to the quarry. It is unclear whether the reopening of the mine and use of the access road will have any bearing on the rehabilitation of the quarry and the expert evidence that addresses that issue. The parties submitted proposed orders on 3 November 2026, which included an order for each party to file supplementary expert evidence addressing the effect, if any, of the Notice of Intent and resolution to restart the mine announced on 2 September 2026 on the existing evidence. Subject to hearing from the parties, I will make an order to a similar effect, confined to the relevant experts, which also requires the parties to provide the Notice of Intent and announcement to the experts and for the experts to advise whether they were aware of the Notice of Intent when they prepared their reports.

I certify that the preceding thirty-two (32) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Justice Neskovcin.

Associate:

Dated:    13 November 2026