Federal Court of Australia

Parsons v Assistant Minister for Immigration [2026] FCA 1706

Review from:

Assistant Minister’s decision, dated 19 May 2026

File number(s):

SAD 142 of 2026

Judgment of:

O'SULLIVAN J

Date of judgment:

17 November 2026

Catchwords:

MIGRATION — application for judicial review of decision of Assistant Minister under s 501BA(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) to set aside decision of Administrative Review Tribunal and cancel applicant’s visa — whether the Assistant Minister’s decision was irrational, illogical or legally unreasonable — where Assistant Minister stated that no weight was given to applicant’s non-conviction offending and juvenile offending — where Assistant Minister referred to increasing seriousness of applicant’s offending history — whether Assistant Minister was prohibited by s 14 of the Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act 1987 (NSW) in combination with ss 85ZR and 85ZS of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) from considering applicant’s prior offending — where prior offending included offending as a juvenile in South Australia — where there is no South Australian equivalent to s 14 of the Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act 1987 (NSW) — where Assistant Minister not precluded from considering underlying conduct of applicant’s prior offending — where s 501M of the Migration Act permitted Assistant Minister to use criminal history information notwithstanding ss 85ZR and 85ZS of the Crimes Act — where Assistant Minister is not restricted in having regard to applicant’s criminal offending as a juvenile or adult — whether handwritten notation “has form” demonstrated impermissible reliance on prior offending — where authorship of notation not established — where notation is consistent with the applicant’s offending history — whether reference to increasing seriousness of offending history was incompatible with statement that no weight was given to prior offending — where prior offending used as comparator to identify trend of increasing seriousness rather than being attributed weight per se in favour of cancellation — no legal unreasonableness established — application dismissed

Legislation:

Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), ss 85ZM, 85ZR(2)(b), 85ZS(1)(d)(ii), 85ZV, 85ZW

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 5, 501(3A), 501BA(2), 501CA(4), 501M

Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act 1987 (NSW), s 14(1)

Cases cited:

Jamdar v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FCA 1620

Lesianawai v Minister for Immigration Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 6; (2024) 281 CLR 1

Division:

General Division

Registry:

South Australia

National Practice Area:

Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights

Number of paragraphs:

49

Date of hearing:

28 October 2026

Counsel for the Applicant:

Mr O H F Morris

Solicitor for the Applicant:

MSM Legal

Counsel for the Respondent:

Ms J Lucas

Solicitor for the Respondent:

Australian Government Solicitors

ORDERS

SAD 142 of 2026

BETWEEN:

ISSAC DEREK PARSONS

Applicant

AND:

ASSISTANT MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION

Respondent

order made by:

O'SULLIVAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

17 November 2026

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.    The application is dismissed.

2.    The applicant is to pay the respondent’s costs as agreed or assessed.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

O’SULLIVAN J:

1    The applicant is a citizen of New Zealand who arrived in Australia in 1996 as a four-year-old child. Relevantly, for the purposes of this matter, the applicant turned 16 years of age on 16 July 2008 and 18 years of age on 16 July 2010.

2    On 29 August 2018, the applicant was convicted in the District Court of South Australia and sentenced to a term of imprisonment of eight years with a non-parole period of four years and six months for:

(a)    five counts of intentionally cause harm – aggravated offence – other; and

(b)    two counts of commit assault – aggravated offence – no weapon

(together, the Index Offending).

3    The Index Offending was committed by the applicant on New Year’s Eve in 2012 in company with others. On any view, the Index Offending was very serious.

4    On 23 May 2019, a delegate of the Minister cancelled the applicant’s visa pursuant to s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The applicant subsequently made representations seeking that the cancellation of his visa be revoked pursuant to s 501CA(4), and on 23 June 2025, a delegate of the Minister refused to revoke the cancellation.

5    The applicant subsequently applied to the Administrative Review Tribunal for a review of the delegate’s non-revocation decision. Following a hearing on 15 September 2025, the Tribunal set aside the non-revocation decision and substituted a decision that the cancellation of the applicant’s visa be revoked. The Tribunal published its written reasons on 23 September 2025.

6    On 19 May 2026, the respondent (the Assistant Minister), acting under s 501BA(2) of the Migration Act, set aside the Tribunal’s decision and cancelled the applicant’s visa. The Assistant Minister provided written Reasons (R) for doing so.

7    It is from the Assistant Minister’s decision under s 501BA(2) that the applicant now seeks judicial review in this Court.

8    It is for the reasons which follow that the application is dismissed.

The single ground of review

9    There is a single ground of review which contends that the Assistant Minister’s decision is infected by jurisdictional error on the basis that the Assistant Minister’s consideration of the risk of the applicant reoffending was irrational, illogical and/or unreasonable.

10    The application focuses on the Assistant Minister’s Reasons: at R [23]-[25]:

23.    I have also had regard to Mr PARSONS' other criminal history, which has involved convictions for failing to comply with bail agreements, driving while disqualified/suspended, disorderly behaviour, assault and fighting. For these offences, Mr PARSONS received sentences of fines and 7 days imprisonment, or discharged with conviction, with no penalty imposed Attachment A.

24.    I have noted the increasing seriousness of Mr PARSONS' offending history, escalating from relatively minor offences to being involved in the violent attack upon multiple members of the Australian community.

25.    I note Mr PARSONS' offending prior to 2015 were offences without conviction and were not required to be declared or convictions recorded in the Children's Court Attachment A. I give his non-conviction offending and his juvenile offending no weight towards cancellation and subsequently give no weight to his non-declaration of these issues on his incoming passenger cards.

(Emphasis in original, highlighting omitted)

11    The particulars to the single ground, in summary, contend that:

(a)    prior to the Index Offending, the applicant had been found guilty of a number of other offences;

(b)    in the period prior to 27 March 2015, the applicant had either been convicted of various offences as a juvenile or alternatively found guilty of offences both as a juvenile and as an adult but for which no conviction was recorded. That offending is referred to by the applicant as the “Preceding Offending”;

(c)    the Assistant Minister stated: at R [25] that he gave the Preceding Offending no weight towards cancellation of the applicant’s visa;

(d)    nonetheless: at R [24], the Minister noted an “increasing seriousness” of the applicant’s offending history;

(e)    there is a handwritten note in the margin next to R [23] and [24] which reads “has form”;

(f)    it was illogical, irrational and/or unreasonable for the Minister to have regard to the Preceding Offending as indicating an “increasing seriousness” of the applicant’s offending history and to note that the applicant “has form” in circumstances where the Assistant Minister had recorded that he gave no weight to the Preceding Offending; and

(g)    the error was material.

Parties’ submissions and consideration

12    The applicant advances his submissions on the sole ground on three bases.

The first basis

13    The applicant contends that the Assistant Minister was prohibited from considering much of the Preceding Offending by operation of s 85ZR(2)(b) of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth). The applicant submits that on a proper construction of the Reasons, the Assistant Minister used the Preceding Offending in a way which was inconsistent, contrary to authority, and ultimately, unreasonable.

14    In advancing that submission, the applicant relies upon the Assistant Minister’s Reasons: at R [23]-[25] which are reproduced above.

15    Section 85ZR(2)(b) of the Crimes Act provides:

(2)    Despite any other Commonwealth law or any Territory law, where, under a State law or a foreign law a person is, in particular circumstances or for a particular purpose, to be taken never to have been convicted of an offence under a law of that State or foreign country:

…

(b)    the person shall be taken, in any State or foreign country, in corresponding circumstances or for a corresponding purpose, by any Commonwealth authority in that State or country, never to have been convicted of that offence.

16    Section 85ZS(1)(d)(ii) of the Crimes Act provides relevantly:

(1)    … despite any other Commonwealth law or any State law or Territory law, where, under section 85ZR, a person is, in particular circumstances or for a particular purpose, to be taken never to have been convicted of an offence:

…

(d)    anyone else who knows, or could reasonably be expected to know, that section 85ZR applies to the person in relation to the offence shall not:

…

(ii)    in those circumstances, or for that purpose, take account of the fact that the person was charged with, or convicted of, the offence.

17    Section 14(1) of the Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act 1987 (NSW) provides:

(1)    Without limiting any other power of a court to deal with a child who has pleaded guilty to, or has been found guilty of, an offence, a court —

(a)    shall not, in respect of any offence, proceed to, or record such a finding as, a conviction in relation to a child who is under the age of 16 years, and

(b)    may, in respect of an offence which is disposed of summarily, refuse to proceed to, or record such a finding as, a conviction in relation to a child who is of or above the age of 16 years.

18    Relying on s 85ZR(2)(b) of the Crimes Act, the applicant contends that the Assistant Minister took into account the Preceding Offending: at R [24] when he noted the increasing seriousness of the applicant’s offending history and refers to the Assistant Minister’s observations at: R [25] where the Assistant Minister says no weight is given to the applicant’s non-conviction offending and his juvenile offending towards cancellation of the applicant’s visa.

19    The applicant submits that contrary to the prohibition in ss 85ZR and 85ZS of the Crimes Act, and notwithstanding that the Assistant Minister recorded that he had given no weight to the applicant’s non-conviction offending and juvenile offending in deciding whether to cancel the applicant’s visa, it is apparent that he did afford weight to that offending because the Assistant Minister noted the increasing seriousness of the applicant’s offending history.

20    I do not accept that submission.

21    First, prior to the introduction of s 501M of the Migration Act, to which I refer below, the effect of s 85ZR(2) was that, taken together with the operation of s 14(1)(a) of the Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act 1987 (NSW), the applicant was treated as having not been convicted for those offences committed by him in New South Wales as a child: Lesianawai v Minister for Immigration Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 6; (2024) 281 CLR 1 at [35] (Beech-Jones J with whom each of the other members of the Court agreed).

22    On a proper reading of the Reasons, the Assistant Minister clearly did not take account of the applicant’s offending as a juvenile in New South Wales because: at R [23] the offending to which the Assistant Minister refers all relate to the applicant’s offending either as a juvenile before the Adelaide Children’s Court or as an adult.

23    Second, unlike New South Wales, there is no South Australian equivalent to s 14 of the Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act 1987 (NSW). The consequence is that s 85ZR of the Crimes Act is not engaged in relation to the offending for which the applicant appeared before the Adelaide Children’s Court and to which the Assistant Minister referred which was “fighting”. In those circumstances, the Assistant Minister was, in any event, not precluded from taking that particular offending into account.

24    Third, notwithstanding that there may be circumstances where an administrative decision-maker is unable to take into account the fact that the applicant had been charged with, or found guilty of, an offence because of, for example, the combined operation of State or Territory legislation and s 85ZR of the Crimes Act, nonetheless the authorities make it clear that administrative decision-makers are not precluded from considering the underlying conduct: Jamdar v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FCA 1620 at [49]-[51] (Rofe J) and the cases cited therein.

25    It is for these reasons that the applicant’s first basis for contending that the Assistant Minister’s decision was inconsistent, contrary to authority and unreasonable, cannot succeed.

26    There is also a fourth reason, which is that s 501M of the Migration Act came into effect on 5 December 2024. It provides:

501M Collection, use and disclosure of criminal history information

Collection, use and disclosure

(1)    The Minister or an officer of the Department may collect, use, or disclose to a person or body, criminal history information for the purpose of informing, directly or indirectly, the performance of a function or the exercise of a power under this Act or the regulations.

Secondary use and disclosure

(2)    If a person or body receives criminal history information as a result of a disclosure under subsection (1), the person or body may collect, use, or disclose to a person or body, the information for the purpose of providing advice or recommendations, directly or indirectly, to the Minister or an officer of the Department on matters relating to the performance of a function or the exercise of a power under this Act or the regulations.

Existing prohibitions do not apply

(3)    This section has effect despite:

(a)    any other provision of this Act or the regulations, Division 3 of Part VIIC of the Crimes Act 1914, or any other law of the Commonwealth; or

(b)    any law of a State or Territory.

No limitation on existing powers

(4)    This section does not limit any other powers the Minister or an officer of the Department has to collect, use or disclose information under this Act, the regulations or any other law of the Commonwealth.

Natural justice does not apply

(5)    The rules of natural justice do not apply to an exercise of power under this section.

27    Section 5 of the Migration Act provides a broad definition of “criminal history information”:

“criminal history information” means information about an individual's criminal history, and includes information about:

(a)    any charge against the individual for an offence against a law of the Commonwealth, a State or a Territory, whether or not the individual has been found to have committed the offence; and

(b)    any finding that the individual committed such an offence, whether or not the individual has been convicted of the offence; and

(c)    any conviction of the individual of such an offence, whether or not the conviction is spent (however described) under:

(i)    Part VIIC of the Crimes Act 1914; or

(ii)    a law of a State or Territory; and

(d)    any other result of a proceeding for the prosecution of the individual for such an offence.

28    Section s 501M(3) of the Migration Act provides that the section has effect despite:

(3)    …

(a)    any other provision of this Act or the regulations, Division 3 of Part VIIC of the Crimes Act 1914, or any other law of the Commonwealth; or

(b)    any law of a State or Territory.

29    Section 501M(1) of the Migration Act makes it clear that in the circumstances of this matter, the Assistant Minister may “use” “criminal history information” for the purpose of “the performance of a function or the exercise of a power under this Act”.

30    There is an issue as to the meaning in s 501M(3)(a) of the words “or any other law of the Commonwealth” and “any law of a State or Territory” in circumstances where there is a specific reference in that subsection to Division 3 of Part VIIC of the Crimes Act.

31    Division 3 of Part VIIC is comprised of two sections: s 85ZV titled “Spent Convictions” and s 85ZW titled “Effect of right of non-disclosure”.

32    Section 85ZM is within Part VIIC. For the purposes of this issue, s 85ZM(2)(b) relevantly defines when a conviction is “spent” in the following terms:

(b)    the person was not sentenced to imprisonment for the offence, or was not sentenced to imprisonment for the offence for more than 30 months, and the waiting period for the offence has ended.

33    Section 85ZV is directed to the obligation of a person to disclose the fact of a “spent” conviction.

34    Section 85ZW provides at (b)(i) and (ii):

(b)    anyone else who knows, or could reasonably be expected to know, that section 85ZV applies to the person in relation to the offence shall not:

(i)    without the person's consent, disclose the fact that the person was charged with, or convicted of, the offence to any other person, or to a Commonwealth authority or State authority, where it is lawful for the first-mentioned person not to disclose it to that other person or that authority; or

(ii)    in those circumstances, or for that purpose, take account of the fact that the person was charged with, or convicted of, the offence.

35    To that extent, s 501M(3) of the Migration Act operates to exclude the application of s 85ZW of the Crimes Act so that here, the Assistant Minister can take account of a spent conviction.

36    As to s 501M(3) of the Migration Act operating despite “any other law of the Commonwealth” or “any law of a State or Territory”, the section operates to avoid, at least, the operation of ss 85ZR and 85ZS in circumstances where there is relevant State or Territory legislation providing that a person is to be treated as having not been convicted for offences committed whether as a child or otherwise. The consequence in this case is that the Assistant Minister was able to take into account the fact of the applicant being charged with, or convicted of, any such offence.

37    Consequently, s 501M of the Migration Act operates such that there was no restriction on the Assistant Minister having regard to the applicant’s history of criminal offending, whether as a juvenile or as an adult.

The second basis

38    The applicant contends that the handwritten note “has form” in the margin next to R [23] and [24] indicates that, notwithstanding the Assistant Minister’s statement: at R [25], the Assistant Minister took into account the Preceding Offending and in doing so acted impermissibly.

39    I do not accept that submission. It is clear from the applicant’s criminal history that there was an increasing seriousness to the applicant’s offending history. To the extent that in the margin next to R [23] there is a handwritten notation “has form”, that notation is a handwritten representation of what is contained in R [23]. I add that there is no admission on the part of the Assistant Minister that the handwritten notation was placed there by the Assistant Minister. I am therefore unable to make any finding as to the author of that note, but in any event for the reasons I have set out, it does not assist the applicant.

40    Further, for the reasons I have set out, the Minister did not take the preceding offending into account, save for one matter to which I have referred, and was not, in any event, precluded from doing so.

The third basis

41    The applicant submits that, drawing those threads together, the Assistant Minister’s reference to the applicant’s offending history: at R [23], the reference to the increasing seriousness of the applicant’s offending history: at R [24] and the handwritten notation “has form”, is incompatible with the Assistant Minister’s statement: at R [25] that he gave no weight to the Preceding Offending in favour of cancellation.

42    The applicant continues by submitting that the Assistant Minister used the Preceding Offending to contextualise and exacerbate the weight attributable to the Index Offending such that, contrary the Assistant Minister’s statement: at R [25], the Assistant Minister did, in fact, afford weight to the Preceding Offending.

43    The difficulty for the applicant is that I do not accept the precursors to that submission. The Assistant Minister’s statement: at R [25] that he afforded no weight to the Preceding Offending, being offences for which no conviction was recorded and were not required to be declared (on an incoming passenger arrival card) or to convictions recorded in the Children’s Court, is, with one exception, accurate. As I have noted, that exception is that the Assistant Minister referred to a conviction in the Adelaide Children’s Court for assault and fighting which the Minister was entitled to take into account, either because he was not precluded by s 85ZR of the Crimes Act from doing so and/or because of the operation of s 501M of the Migration Act.

44    However, that reference was in the context of identifying an increasing seriousness in the applicant’s offending history. In that sense, the Assistant Minister did not give weight to that offending as a factor operating in favour of cancelling the applicant’s visa. Rather, that offending was used as a comparator as part of an analysis of the increasing seriousness of the applicant’s offending. That is, it formed part of identifying a trend.

45    Viewed in that context, it is clear that the Assistant Minister did not attribute weight per se to prior offending, which the Assistant Minister described: at R [25] as “non-conviction offending” and “juvenile offending”.

46    It follows that the applicant’s concluding submission that the Assistant Minister’s decision was not supported by a reasonable chain of analysis and is unreasonable, cannot be accepted.

Materiality

47    Since the applicant has failed to make out his contention that the Assistant Minister’s decision was legally unreasonable, the issue of materiality falls away.

Conclusion

48    The application is dismissed.

49    There is no reason why the applicant should not pay the Assistant Minister’s costs of and incidental to the application.

I certify that the preceding forty-nine (49) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Justice O'Sullivan.

Associate:

Dated:    17 November 2026