Federal Court of Australia
Shafston Avenue Construction Pty Ltd, in the matter of Shafston Avenue Construction Pty Ltd (in liquidation) [2026] FCA 1675
File number(s): | QUD 149 of 2026 QUD 150 of 2026 |
Judgment of: | LONGBOTTOM J |
Date of judgment: | 16 July 2026 |
Date of publication of reasons: | 13 November 2026 |
Catchwords: | CORPORATIONS – Application by liquidators under s 588FF(3)(b) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for extension of time for making any application under s 588FF(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – Where delay explained by a lack of funds to conduct investigations – Where liquidators have progressed investigations diligently since receipt of funds and appointment of additional liquidators – Where relevant persons and companies have notice of potential proceedings and have not sought to participate – Satisfaction that no prejudice likely to flow from grant of extension – Where assessment of merits not necessary because purpose of extension is to enable liquidators to decide whether basis to bring claims under s 588FF(1) – Where extension fair and just in all the circumstances – Extension granted. CORPORATIONS – Application by additional liquidators under s 588FF(3)(b) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for extension of time for making any application under s 588FF(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – Where additional liquidators were appointed by order of the Court – Where additional liquidators have acted diligently and efficiently since their appointment – Where extension sought is lengthy in the context of applications made under s 588FF(3)(b) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – Where there is no evidence of any prejudice likely to be suffered by affected persons and companies – Where assessment of merits not necessary because purpose of extension is to enable liquidators to decide whether basis to bring claims under s 588FF(1) – Where extension fair and just in all the circumstances – Extension granted. |
Legislation: | Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 9, 91(Item 12), 513C, 588FF, 588FF(1), 588FF(3) |
Cases cited: | BP Australia Ltd v Brown [2003] NSWCA 216; (2003) 176 FLR 301 Brereton, in the matter of ICT Century Pty Ltd (In Liq) [2025] FCA 107 Clout v Andi-Co Australia Pty Ltd [2013] QSC 278; (2013) 96 ACSR 512 Deputy Commissioner of Taxation, in the matter of Shafston Avenue Construction Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Shafston Avenue Construction Pty Ltd [2025] FCA 1673 Donnellon Childcare Holdings Pty Ltd (in liq), in the matter of Donnellon Childcare Holdings Pty Ltd (in liq) v Donnellon [2020] FCA 1003 Fortress Credit Corporation (Australia) II Pty Limited v Fletcher [2015] HCA 10; (2015) 254 CLR 489 Green v Chiswell Furniture Pty Ltd (in liq) [1999] NSWSC 608 Mansfield, in the matter of NR Complex Pty Ltd (in liq) (receiver and manager appointed) [2025] FCA 1349 McGrath v National Indemnity Company [2004] NSWSC 391; (2004) 182 FLR 309 Park v Privium Pty Ltd (in liq), in the matter of Privium Pty Ltd (in liq) [2025] FCA 500 Parker, in the matter of Worldwide Speciality Property Services Pty Limited (in liq) v Worldwide Speciality Property Services Pty Ltd (in liq) [2017] FCA 687 Re Clarecastle Pty Ltd (in liq) [2011] NSWSC 857; (2011) 85 ACSR 260 |
Division: | General Division |
Registry: | Queensland |
National Practice Area: | Commercial and Corporations |
Sub-area: | Corporations and Corporate Insolvency |
Number of paragraphs: | 59 |
Date of hearing: | 16 July 2026 |
Solicitor for the Plaintiffs (QUD 149 of 2026): | Mr L R McCormick of HWLE Lawyers |
Counsel for the Plaintiffs (QUD 150 of 2026): | Mr B W Wacker |
Solicitor for the Plaintiffs (QUD 150 of 2026): | MinterEllison |
ORDERS
QUD 149 of 2026 | ||
IN THE MATTER OF SHAFSTON AVENUE CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 169 409 705 | ||
BETWEEN: | DUNCAN CLUBB AND JEFFREY MARSDEN IN THEIR CAPACITY AS LIQUIDATORS OF SHAFSTON AVENUE CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 169 409 705 First Plaintiff SHAFSTON AVENUE CONSTRUCTION 2 PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 622 201 183 Second Plaintiff LINCOLN STREET CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 603 876 651 (and others named in the Schedule) Third Plaintiff | |
order made by: | LONGBOTTOM J |
DATE OF ORDER: | 16 JULY 2026 |
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1. Pursuant to s 588FF(3)(b) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the time for the making of any application under s 588FF(1) of the Act by the Plaintiffs in relation to any one or more of the Defendants is extended to 20 November 2026.
2. The Plaintiffs’ costs of and incidental to this application be costs in the liquidations of the Defendants.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
ORDERS
QUD 150 of 2026 | ||
BETWEEN: | ANTHONY NORMAN CONNELLY AND MARK ALFRED HOLLAND IN THEIR CAPACITY AS SPECIAL PURPOSE LIQUIDATORS OF SHAFSTON AVENUE CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 169 409 705 First Plaintiff ANTHONY NORMAN CONNELLY AND MARK ALFRED HOLLAND IN THEIR CAPACITY AS SPECIAL PURPOSE LIQUIDATORS OF SHAFSTON AVENUE CONSTRUCTION 2 PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 622 201 183 Second Plaintiff ANTHONY NORMAN CONNELLY AND MARK ALFRED HOLLAND IN THEIR CAPACITY AS SPECIAL PURPOSE LIQUIDATORS OF LINCOLN STREET CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 603 876 651 (and others named in the Schedule) Third Plaintiff | |
AND: | SHAFSTON AVENUE CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 169 409 705 First Defendant SHAFSTON AVENUE CONSTRUCTION 2 PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 622 201 183 Second Defendant LINCOLN STREET CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 603 876 651 (and others named in the Schedule) Third Defendant | |
order made by: | LONGBOTTOM J |
DATE OF ORDER: | 16 JULY 2026 |
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1. Pursuant to s 588FF(3)(b) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the time for the making of any application under s 588FF(1) of the Act by the Plaintiffs in relation to any one or more of the Defendants is extended to 21 June 2027.
2. The Plaintiffs’ costs of and incidental to this application be costs in the liquidations of the Defendants.
[Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.]
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
LONGBOTTOM J:
overview
1 In each of these proceedings, the plaintiffs seek an extension of time within which they may make a voidable transaction application under s 588FF(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) in respect of any one or more of the five companies that are named as defendants in QUD150/2026 (Construction Companies).
2 The plaintiffs in QUD149/2026 are the General Purpose Liquidators of the Construction Companies. They were appointed to that role on 12 March 2024. On that date, the voluntary administration of the Construction Companies came to an end, and the companies were placed into liquidation following the termination of a deed of company arrangement (DOCA) because a condition precedent thereunder had not been satisfied. This occurred in the context of litigation commenced by the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation seeking that the DOCA be terminated.
3 The plaintiffs in QUD150/2026 are the Special Purpose Liquidators of the Construction Companies. They were appointed by Orders Wheatley J made on 17 December 2025 on application by the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation: Deputy Commissioner of Taxation, in the matter of Shafston Avenue Construction Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Shafston Avenue Construction Pty Ltd [2025] FCA 1673.
4 Without an extension of time, the period for bringing a voidable transaction application expired on 21 March 2026. That date is three years after the “relation-back day” of 21 March 2023, when the administration of the Construction Companies began: Act, ss 9 (“relation-back day”), 91(Item 12), 513C and 588FF(3)(a).
5 On 16 July 2026, I made orders granting each of the General Purpose Liquidators and the Special Purpose Liquidators an extension of time within which to make an application under s 588FF(1) of the Act in relation to the Construction Companies. These are my reasons for making those orders.
relevant principles
6 Section 588FF(3) of the Act provides as follows:
588FF Courts may make orders about voidable transactions
…
(3) An application under subsection (1) may only be made:
(a) during the period beginning on the relation-back day and ending:
(i) 3 years after the relation-back day; or
(ii) 12 months after the first appointment of a liquidator in relation to the winding up of the company;
whichever is the later; or
(b) within such longer period as the Court orders on an application under this paragraph made by the liquidator during the paragraph (a) period.
7 As has been noted, the period referred to in s 588FF(3)(a) of the Act expired on 21 March 2026. Both the General Purpose Liquidators and the Special Purpose Liquidators applied for an extension of time on 19 March 2026 before the period expired. As such, the Court has power to make an order granting an extension: cf, McGrath v National Indemnity Company [2004] NSWSC 391; (2004) 182 FLR 309 at [18] (Barrett J).
8 The principles relevant to an application under s 588FF(3)(b) of the Act were summarised by Owens J in Brereton, in the matter of ICT Century Pty Ltd (In Liq) [2025] FCA 107 at [3] as follows:
(a) An order extending time may be made after the expiry of the period calculated in accordance with s 588FF(3)(a), provided that the application for an extension was filed within that period: McGrath v National Indemnity Company [2004] NSWSC 391; 182 FLR 309 at [18], per Barrett J.
(b) Section 588FF(3)(b) authorises the making of a shelf order: Fortress Credit Corporation (Australia) II Pty Ltd v Fletcher (2015) 254 CLR 489 at [24], per French CJ, Hayne, Kiefel, Gageler and Keane JJ.
(c) Because an order extending time is capable of adversely affecting the interests of third parties, ordinarily they should be given an opportunity to make submissions before the order is made: John Alexander’s Clubs Pty Ltd v White City Tennis Club Ltd (2010) 241 CLR 1 at [131], per French CJ, Gummow, Hayne, Heydon and Kiefel JJ. If that is not possible (and in the context of an application for a shelf order there will be obvious limitations on the ability to provide such an opportunity to all persons who may ultimately be affected by the order), then, upon application, the third party must be put in the same position as he or she would have been in had such an opportunity been provided: BP Australia Ltd v Brown (2003) 58 NSWLR 322 at [133]-[134], per Spigelman CJ (Mason P and Handley JA agreeing); see generally John Alexander v White City at [137].
(d) The discretion conferred by s 588FF(3)(b) is to be exercised having regard to the scope and purposes of Pt 5.7B (Fortress Credit v Fletcher at [24]), and the fundamental question is whether it is “fair and just in all the circumstances” to grant the extension: BP v Brown at [187]. Another way of viewing the question, is to ask whether the extension would represent an unreasonable prolongation of the state of uncertainty faced by those who entered into transactions with the company during the periods in respect of which designated transactions may be voidable: Fortress Credit v Fletcher at [24]; Parker, in the matter of Worldwide Specialty Property Services Pty Limited (in liq) v Worldwide Specialty Property Services Pty Limited (in liq) [2017] FCA 687 at [15], per Lee J.
(e) In most cases, the centrally relevant considerations will be (see, eg, Taylor v Woden Constructions Pty Ltd [1998] FCA 1228, per Finn J, synthesised and crystallised in many later cases, including Green v Chiswell Furniture Pty Ltd [1999] NSWSC 608 at [15], per Austin J):
(i) the liquidator’s explanation for the delay in commencing proceedings;
(ii) a preliminary assessment of the merits of the foreshadowed proceedings, directed to determining the fairness of prolonging the exposure of third parties to the uncertainty of possible litigation (although, where the purpose of the extension of time is simply to put the liquidator in a position to decide whether or not to bring a proceeding, a preliminary inquiry into the merits may not always be necessary);
(iii) whether the likely prejudice resulting from the grant of an extension is sufficiently substantial to outweigh the case for granting an extension.
(f) The particular nature of shelf orders may give rise to a number of additional considerations, including (Fortress Credit v Fletcher at [25]-[26]):
(i) disadvantage to potential defendants not identified in the shelf order;
(ii) the encouragement to liquidators not to identify potential defendants, thereby reducing the prospect of opposition at initial application;
(iii) the risk of a multiplicity of litigation by successive defendants applying to reagitate extension applications of which they had not been given initial notice;
(iv) the risk of inconsistent outcomes on applications to set aside extension orders by respective defendants;
(v) no finality, as claims by defendants that they were identifiable, but not identified, might cause ongoing challenges to any extension granted;
(vi) want of certainty for liquidators and prospective defendants who might seek to have leave revoked after it had been granted and after proceedings had commenced;
(vii) the potential for wasted costs to be incurred contrary to the interests of creditors; and
(viii) the determination of applications by reference only to evidence that the liquidator elected to put before the court.
evidence
9 In QUD149/2026, Mr Clubb of the General Purpose Liquidators has filed an affidavit dated 18 March 2026 in support of the application for an extension of time under s 588FF of the Act. The General Purpose Liquidators also rely on an affidavit of Teagan Laszlo dated 23 March 2026, two affidavits of Talysha Sabatino, respectively dated 12 and 26 April 2026, an affidavit of Christopher Zadravec dated 1 May 2026, and an affidavit of Lachlan McCormick dated 7 May 2026.
10 In QUD150/2026, Mr Connelly of the Special Purpose Liquidators has filed two affidavits, respectively dated 18 March and 23 April 2026 in support of the application for an extension of time. The Special Purpose Liquidators also rely on the affidavits of Richard Mumford dated 15 April 2026 and Rebecca Smith dated 24 April 2026.
11 What follows is an overview of the events giving rise to the proceedings as derived from that evidence.
factual background
12 The Construction Companies were part of a group of companies known as “Devcorp”. They were incorporated as special purpose vehicles to complete the construction of development projects in Brisbane, including the construction of two residential apartment buildings and 43 townhouses and the demolition of existing buildings and amalgamation of a lot in the Fortitude Valley.
13 Murray John Thornton is the sole shareholder and was, until 18 May 2021, the sole director of each of the Construction Companies. On 18 May 2021, Mr William Rhodes replaced him as director.
14 The land on which the development projects were undertaken was owned by four companies (Corporate Trustees). Mr Thornton and Mr Ian John Edwards were equal shareholders in each of those companies. They were also the directors of the Corporate Trustees until 7 July 2021, when they were replaced by Thomas James Wallace.
15 The corporate group also included two companies (Aust Companies). The Aust Companies advanced funds to both the Corporate Trustees and the Construction Companies to enable them to purchase and develop the relevant land. Mr Edwards was the sole director and shareholder of the Aust Companies.
16 On 21 March 2023, Mr Rhodes resolved to appoint the General Purpose Liquidators as voluntary administrators of each of the Construction Companies. There followed, on 30 June 2023, a meeting of the creditors of each of the Construction Companies at which it was resolved to execute the DOCA. The DOCA was proposed by Bohan Enterprises Pty Ltd ACN 669 013 094 and funded by one of the Aust Companies. Mr Rhodes is the sole director and shareholder of Bohan.
17 On 20 November 2023, the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation, who is the largest non-related party creditor of the Construction Companies, commenced a proceeding in the Federal Court seeking that the DOCA be terminated. That proceeding was dismissed by consent on 5 April 2024, following the termination of the DOCA because a condition precedent thereunder was not satisfied.
18 For the majority of the liquidation, and until approximately mid-September 2025, a lack of funds has hampered the capacity of the General Purpose Liquidators to undertake investigations into the Construction Companies’ affairs. In mid-September 2025, the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) paid the General Purpose Liquidators $280,000 in respect of two voidable transaction claims that they had submitted in October 2024 on behalf of two of the Construction Companies (voidable transaction payment).
19 The General Purpose Liquidators nonetheless took some steps prior to mid-September 2025 to investigate potential claims under s 588FF(1) of the Act. Mr Clubb gives evidence that those steps included, amongst other matters, reviewing the financial records and bank statements of the Construction Companies to identify potential voidable transactions; conducting investigations into insolvent trading, uncommercial transactions and preference transactions; as well as commencing and recovering the preferential payment from the ATO referred to above.
20 In September 2025, the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation commenced another proceeding in the Federal Court, this time seeking the appointment of the Special Purpose Liquidators. The application was made in the context of the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation asking, but the General Purpose Liquidators being unable because of a lack of funds, to undertake further investigations into the Construction Companies’ affairs.
21 Mr Clubb of the General Purpose Liquidators gives evidence that he considered that the proceeding brought by the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation needed to be determined before he could continue to substantively progress with the liquidation. That was because the orders sought, if made, would have “carved off” certain functions of the General Purpose Liquidators to the Special Purpose Liquidators. Notwithstanding, the General Purpose Liquidators took some further steps in this period including conducting investigations relating to the Construction Companies.
22 The General Purpose Liquidators’ investigations have revealed that for the majority of the 12-month period before the Construction Companies entered into administration their cash balances were below around $3,000. Those cash balances only increased momentarily when funds were drawn down from loans to pay immediate liabilities. Those drawdowns were also used to pay certain trade creditor liabilities, including potential unfair preference payments. But, as at the date of their appointment, the majority of the trade creditors were in arrears for more than 90 days. Since their appointment, creditors have submitted proof of debt forms including invoices for debts going back to 2021.
23 The last set of financial statements produced for the Construction Companies by an external accountant was for the 2019 financial year. Beyond that, only management accounts have been provided. Those management accounts do not appear to be complete or to have treated certain accounts correctly. Mr Clubb gives evidence that this has caused him to question the accuracy of the accounts and, consequently, has made an assessment of the Construction Companies’ trading history difficult.
24 On 17 December 2025, the Special Purpose Liquidators were appointed. Their functions are confined by the terms of the Orders Wheatley J made on 17 December 2025 and relevantly include the conduct of investigations into the Construction Companies: claiming of input tax credits; delaying or failing to adequately invoice the Corporate Trustees for construction costs incurred during the life of the development, with a consequential delay in the crystallisation of GST liability; and the extent to which that delay or failure has affected their capacity to recoup construction costs and repay amounts borrowed from the Corporate Trustees.
25 Following the appointment of the Special Purpose Liquidators, the General Purpose Liquidators have continued their investigations with respect to the Construction Companies. This includes commencing a proceeding in February 2026, seeking amongst other matters, the issue of a summons to examine Mr Rhodes about the Construction Companies’ affairs and directions to produce the books of three companies to whom potential unfair preference payments amounting to approximately $316,000 may have been paid: Vincent Young trading as Vincent CCL Pty Ltd ACN 116 002 110, First Equity Tax Pty Ltd ACN 601 548 109 and TJC#1 Pty Ltd ACN 606 421 452 trading as Balance Insolvency (Relevant Parties). The subject matter of those further investigations remain as matters for the General Purpose Liquidators under the Orders Wheatley J made on 17 December 2025.
26 The General Purpose Liquidators seek an extension of time until 20 November 2026. Mr Clubb gives evidence that period is required to enable him to complete relevant steps in relation to investigating the potential unfair preference payments to the Relevant Parties. The steps to be taken during that period include, amongst other matters, the conduct of the examination of Mr Rhodes in relation to the affairs of the Construction Companies; the completion of the production of documents and resolution of any claims of privilege; analysing the evidence from the examination together with the documents and obtaining advice in relation to potential unfair preference claims; securing litigation funding if necessary, as well as preparing and commencing any proceedings in respect of such claims.
27 Mr Clubb gives evidence that he also holds concerns that Mr Rhodes may have received unfair preference payments. The General Purpose Liquidators do not seek an extension of time in respect of any claim against Mr Rhodes, which Mr Clubb identifies as a potential insolvent trading claim, because the limitation period is six years.
28 Since their appointment, the Special Purpose Liquidators have taken a series of steps to progress their investigations. This includes meeting with each of Mr Rhodes and Mr Thornton in March 2026 and issuing Mr Thornton with follow-up information requests and requesting information from, and a meeting with, Mr Edwards and Mr Wallace. The Special Purpose Liquidators have also taken steps to obtain copies of books and records of the Construction Companies from the General Purpose Liquidators, as well as various entities who variously were, or may be, their former solicitors, accountants or advisers. Those inquiries have revealed the existence of relevant information. However, as of March 2026, the Special Purpose Liquidators had only received a small number of substantive responses. Mr Connelly of the Special Purpose Liquidators gives evidence that those books and records are required in order to enable them to advance their investigations.
29 The Special Purpose Liquidators seek an extension of time (until 21 June 2027) to finalise their investigations. Their investigations have, or will, involve, amongst other matters: obtaining, reviewing and analysing the requested documents to identify potential causes of action or breaches of the law; applying for and conducting examinations about the Construction Companies’ examinable affairs; applying for and reviewing documents obtained in response to an order for production and conducting a forensic analysis of the position of the Construction Companies, so as to form a view in relation to the date on which each became insolvent; and taking the further steps and investigations to determine, particularise and commence appropriate claims.
30 Mr Connelly gives evidence, based on his insolvency experience, as to the appropriate timeline for those steps to be completed by the Special Purpose Liquidators. That timeline, which includes estimates for relevant stages, extends until 21 June 2027 and allows for one month of potential “slippage”.
General Purpose Liquidators
31 I am satisfied, for the reasons that follow, that it is appropriate to make an order under s 588FF(3)(b) of the Act extending the time within which the General Purpose Liquidators may make a voidable transaction application to the Court under s 588FF(1) of the Act to 20 November 2026.
Explanation for delay
32 The General Purpose Liquidators’ explanation for the delay in commencing proceedings appears from the evidence of Mr Clubb to be connected with two matters. First, their financial inability to pursue investigations relevant to potential unfair preference claims until the middle of September 2025, when the ATO made the voidable transaction payment. Second, the view that it was prudent to not progress investigations until the proceeding commenced on 24 September 2025 seeking the appointment of the Special Purpose Liquidators was determined.
33 A lack of funds in the liquidation is a practical consideration that may be attributed weight in considering an application under s 588FF(3)(b) of the Act: Clout v Andi-Co Australia Pty Ltd [2013] QSC 278; (2013) 96 ACSR 512 at [62] (Mullins J). It may, for example, provide an explanation for a liquidator’s hesitancy to take action, or why they proceeded with the liquidation in a particular way: Donnellon Childcare Holdings Pty Ltd (in liq), in the matter of Donnellon Childcare Holdings Pty Ltd (in liq) v Donnellon [2020] FCA 1003 at [31] (Reeves J); Clout at [62]-[64]. Further, the fact that the steps the liquidator now wishes to take could have been undertaken before the expiry of the limitation period is a relevant factor, but not a reason in itself not to extend the limitation period, if that is what the balance of the factors otherwise favour: Clout at [64].
34 The General Purpose Liquidators submit, and I accept, that since the appointment of the Special Purpose Liquidators, they have acted expeditiously in progressing their investigations relevant to the potential unfair preference claims. Most notably, this includes issuing letters of demand on the Relevant Parties on 19 December 2025 seeking recovery of the unfair preference payments by 30 January 2026 and commencing a proceeding in February 2026 seeking the issue of a summons for the examination of Mr Rhodes and directions to produce to the Relevant Parties. The examination of Mr Rhodes was to take place shortly after the hearing, on 23 July 2026.
Preliminary assessment of the merits
35 A preliminary assessment of the merits of the proposed proceeding under s 588FF(1) of the Act involves an investigation as to whether the proceeding “would be so devoid of prospects that it would be unfair, by granting an extension, to expose the other party to the continuing prospect” of litigation: Green v Chiswell Furniture Pty Ltd (in liq) [1999] NSWSC 608 at [15] (Austin J).
36 The General Purpose Liquidators contend that they fall into the category of liquidators seeking an extension of time for the purpose of being able to decide whether or not to bring a proceeding: Parker, in the matter of Worldwide Speciality Property Services Pty Limited (in liq) v Worldwide Speciality Property Services Pty Ltd (in liq) [2017] FCA 687 at [16(b)] (Lee J). As Lee J outlined in Parker, in such a circumstance a preliminary inquiry into the merits may not always be necessary: at [16(b)].
37 Given their position, the General Purpose Liquidators did not provide substantive submissions addressing the merit of the potential unfair preference claims. Notwithstanding, Mr Clubb gave some evidence with respect to what is presently known in relation to those potential claims. He deposes that of the approximately $316,000 in payments being investigated the single largest amount (approximately $165,700) was paid to Vincent Young, the (then) lawyers for the Construction Companies in respect of a single development. The remaining amount (approximately $151,300) was paid to Mr Rhodes, First Equity Tax and Balance Insolvency in respect of five developments. The payments were made on various dates between 26 September 2022 and 22 March 2023, with $114,286.90 being paid on 20 March 2023, the day before the General Purpose Liquidators were appointed as administrators of the Construction Companies.
Likely prejudice
38 On 6 March 2026, Mr Clubb caused correspondence to be sent to the Relevant Parties asking their position with respect to the grant of an extension of time under s 588FF(3)(b) of the Act. One of the Relevant Parties (First Equity) responded on 11 March 2026 advising that, at that time, they were minded neither to consent to nor oppose any application for an extension of time. First Equity had earlier advised the General Purpose Liquidators that they will defend any claims brought against it.
39 The General Purpose Liquidators also caused sealed copies of the originating process in this proceeding and the affidavit of Mr Clubb to be served on Mr Rhodes and the Relevant Parties, together with a letter noting that a case management hearing would be held in the Federal Court on 27 March 2026. That material was delivered to Mr Rhodes and the Relevant Parties on either 23 or 24 March 2026.
40 On 27 March 2026, Downes J made Orders in this proceeding, which relevantly required any party with a sufficient interest who wished to be heard on the originating process to file and serve a notice of appearance by 7 April 2026. The General Purpose Liquidators caused a copy of those Orders, together with the originating process, to be served on Mr Rhodes and the Relevant Parties. Neither Mr Rhodes nor the Relevant Parties filed a notice of appearance in the proceeding.
41 Mr Clubb gives evidence that he is not aware of any prejudice that would arise should the extension be granted. He holds that view because the Relevant Parties have been aware of the potential preference claims and the General Purpose Liquidators’ interest in those claims since, at least, 19 December 2025. That is the date on which the General Purpose Liquidators issued letters of demand to the Relevant Parties seeking recovery of the potential unfair preference payments. I infer Mr Clubb considers those notifications to be material to the question of prejudice because it indicates an additional period in which the Relevant Parties have been aware of the potential claims. I am not persuaded that the letters of demand ought to be afforded particular weight in assessing likely prejudice. They simply form part of the context in which that factor, and the absence of an objection from the Relevant Parties to an extension of time, is to be considered.
42 Against the potential prejudice to Mr Rhodes and the Relevant Parties is the prejudice that would result to the creditors of the Construction Companies should the extension of time not be granted, given the total value of the preference payments in issue. The General Purpose Liquidators emphasise, in this respect, that s 588FF(3) of the Act is directed to placing liquidators under a “rigorous but, nonetheless, reasonable time limitation” for taking action in respect of voidable transactions reflecting the policy of avoiding transactions by an insolvent company regarded by the legislature as unfair qualified by the requirement reflected in the time limitation favouring certainty for those who have entered into transactions with the company during the relevant period: Fortress Credit Corporation (Australia) II Pty Limited v Fletcher [2015] HCA 10; (2015) 254 CLR 489 at [12] and [24] (French CJ, Hayne, Kiefel, Gageler and Keane JJ).
Additional considerations
43 The General Purpose Liquidators have not identified any additional considerations that are relevant to the orders they seek in this proceeding: cf, Brereton at [3(d)], citing Fortress Credit at [25]-[26].
Conclusion
44 Having regard to those considerations, I am satisfied that an extension of time until 20 November 2026 is fair and just in all the circumstances: cf, Brereton at [103(d)], citing BP Australia Ltd v Brown [2003] NSWCA 216; (2003) 176 FLR 301 at [187] (Spigelman CJ, with whom Mason P and Handley JA agreed). The lack of funds available until September 2025 explains why the General Purpose Liquidators did not substantively progress the steps necessary to reach a view as to whether proceedings ought to be commenced in relation to unfair preference payments to Mr Rhodes and the Relevant Parties. I am similarly persuaded that the decision to wait until 17 December 2025, when the order appointing the Special Purpose Liquidators was made, was warranted given the potential for overlap in the investigations to be undertaken by them. The evidence reveals that since that date the General Purpose Liquidators have been diligent in taking the necessary steps to put them in a position to decide whether to make any claims.
45 Given the adequacy of the explanation for the delay, I accept that this is a circumstance in which a preliminary assessment of the merits of any proposed proceedings is not necessary. The very purpose of the extension of time is to enable the General Purpose Liquidators to assess whether the potential unfair preference claims have merit, which they were unable to do prior to the end of the period stated in s 588FF(3)(a)(i) of the Act. Moreover, the Relevant Parties and Mr Rhodes have been given notice of this proceeding, and the nature of the potential unfair preference claims for which the extension of time has been sought. They have not sought to participate in the proceeding or identified any prejudice they would suffer should an extension be granted.
46 For all of those reasons and given the substantial amount of the potential unfair preference payments and the relatively short period that is sought, I consider it appropriate to grant the General Purpose Liquidators an extension of time (until 20 November 2026) to make any application under s 588FF(1) of the Act in relation to any one or more of the Construction Companies.
special liquidators
47 I am satisfied, for the reasons that follow, that it is appropriate to make an order under s 588FF(3)(b) of the Act extending the time within which the General Purpose Liquidators may make a voidable transaction application to the Court under s 588FF(1) of the Act to 21 June 2027.
Explanation for the delay
48 The Special Purpose Liquidators’ explanation for their “delay” in commencing proceedings within the period prescribed by s 588FF(3)(a) of the Act is that they were only appointed on 17 December 2025.
49 The Special Purpose Liquidators had a little over three months between their appointment and the expiry of the period in s 588FF(3)(a) of the Act to progress their investigations. They submit, and I accept, that in the time available to them, the Special Purpose Liquidators have diligently progressed investigations within the scope of their functions into potential voidable transaction claims under s 588FF(1) of the Act with respect to the Construction Companies: cf, Re Clarecastle Pty Ltd (in liq) [2011] NSWSC 857; (2011) 85 ACSR 260 at [137] (Ward J). As outlined above, Mr Connelly gives evidence that the steps the Special Purpose Liquidators have taken during this period include, but are not limited to meeting with, and issuing follow-up information requests to Mr Thornton and Mr Rhodes, meeting with the General Purpose Liquidators and issuing notices under the Act requiring the production of relevant books and records from two of the Relevant Parties (Vincent Young and First Equity) as well as six other entities who variously acted as solicitors, accountants or advisers for the Construction Companies.
Preliminary assessment of the merits
50 The Special Purpose Liquidators also contend that they fall into the category of liquidators who require an extension of time for the purpose of properly deciding whether or not to bring a proceeding: Chiswell Furniture at [15(b)] and Parker at [16(b)]. As such, they submit it is not necessary, and do not provide, substantive submissions with respect to the merits of potential claims.
51 Notwithstanding, Mr Connelly gives evidence with respect to their investigations relevant to potential voidable transaction claims under s 588FF(1) of the Act. Mr Connelly understands, based on those investigations, that the Construction Companies were to operate on a cost-recovery basis, whereby the costs they incurred for the project were to be funded by the relevant Corporate Trustee. The Corporate Trustees advanced funds under facility agreements purportedly secured by various general security agreements with the Construction Companies. The arrangements relevantly included the issuing of regular invoices by each Construction Company to the Corporate Trustee that corresponded directly to the costs incurred during the invoiced period.
52 During the life of each of the projects, the Construction Companies claimed GST input tax credits on construction costs totalling $12,422,565. Notwithstanding, Mr Connelly deposes that the Construction Companies appear to have delayed issuing invoices to the Corporate Trustees until several years after the relevant costs were incurred, with the consequence that the claimed input tax credits were not reduced by any corresponding GST liability. Mr Connelly gives evidence that, in effect, this meant that the Construction Companies were able to claim and be paid by the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation, GST funds totalling $11,977,796.95. He further deposes that when the Construction Companies issued invoices to the Corporate Trustees, and the GST liabilities in relation to those invoices became due and payable by reason of interest purportedly accruing on amounts apparently loaned by the Corporate Trustees, the Construction Companies did not have the funds available to pay their GST liability. That liability remained unpaid as at the date the Construction Companies entered into administration.
Likely prejudice
53 The Special Purpose Liquidators candidly acknowledge that the extension sought (15 months) is lengthy in the context of applications made under s 588FF(3)(b) of the Act. But as was acknowledged by Jackman J at [21] of Mansfield, in the matter of NR Complex Pty Ltd (in liq) (receiver and manager appointed) [2025] FCA 1349, “The evaluative nature of the discretion is necessarily fact sensitive, such that the length of extensions granted in other cases may not be of significant utility to the determination of” that sought here. The facts here relevantly include the detailed timetable provided by Mr Connelly which provides substantive detail of the steps necessary to enable the Special Purpose Liquidators to complete their investigations regarding potential claims.
54 The Special Purpose Liquidators have identified, and served, 18 potential defendants with the originating application, the affidavit of Mr Connelly filed on 19 March 2026 and an email from the Associate to Downes J identifying that the first case management hearing was listed at 9:30 am on 27 March 2026. The 18 potential defendants included Mr Thornton, Mr Rhodes, Mr Wallace, Mr Edwards, the Corporate Trustees, the Aust Companies, First Equity, Vincent Young and the six other entities referred to above. Those potential defendants were also emailed the Orders made by Downes J on 27 March 2026, which required any party with a sufficient interest who wished to be heard on the originating process to file and serve a notice of appearance by 7 April 2026. None of those potential defendants have responded to the Special Purpose Liquidators or their solicitors objecting to the extension sought (or sought to become an interested party).
55 The Special Purpose Liquidators acknowledge that there may be other potential defendants not yet identified but emphasise that this is not fatal to the application for an extension of time: Park v Privium Pty Ltd (in liq), in the matter of Privium Pty Ltd (in liq) [2025] FCA 500 at [20] (Downes J). Mr Connelly is not aware of any specific prejudice that any person may suffer should an extension of time be granted.
56 Against the prejudice to any identified and unidentified potential defendants, is the prejudice to the creditors of the Construction Companies should an extension of time not be granted. The Special Purpose Liquidators emphasise, in this respect, the evidence given by Mr Connelly that it is the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation who will fund any investigations to be undertaken by the Special Purpose Liquidators, as well as any subsequent proceedings under s 588FF(1) of the Act.
Additional considerations
57 The Special Purpose Liquidators have not identified any additional considerations that are relevant to the shelf orders they seek in this proceeding: cf, Brereton at [3(f)], citing Fortress Credit at [25]-[26].
Conclusion
58 Having regard to the considerations identified above, I am satisfied that an extension of time until 21 June 2027 is fair and just in all the circumstances: Brereton at [3(d)], citing BP Australia at [187]. By reason of the date on which they were appointed, the Special Purpose Liquidators have not had a reasonable opportunity to complete the investigations necessary to determine whether there are voidable transaction claims that ought to be made under s 588FF(1) of the Act. While the extension sought by the Special Purpose Liquidators is lengthy, given the particular circumstances surrounding the date of their appointment, the absence of evidence of prejudice to any identified and unidentified potential defendants should an extension of time be granted, the prejudice to creditors should an extension of time not be granted and the evidence given by Mr Connelly as to why the period sought is necessary to complete the investigations involved, I consider it appropriate to grant the Special Purpose Liquidators an extension of time under s 588FF(3)(b) of the Act.
costs
59 Finally, I will make an order that the costs of the General Purpose Liquidators and the Special Purpose Liquidators in their respective proceedings are the costs in the liquidation of the Construction Companies.
I certify that the preceding fifty-nine (59) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Justice Longbottom. |
Associate:
Dated: 13 November 2026
SCHEDULE OF PARTIES
QUD 149 of 2026 | |
Plaintiffs | |
Fourth Plaintiff: | 28 BAXTER STREET CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 611 160 215 |
Fifth Plaintiff: | 80 SETTLEMENT ROAD CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 611 447 100 |
SCHEDULE OF PARTIES
QUD 150 of 2026 | |
Plaintiffs | |
Fourth Plaintiff: | ANTHONY NORMAN CONNELLY AND MARK ALFRED HOLLAND IN THEIR CAPACITY AS SPECIAL PURPOSE LIQUIDATORS OF 28 BAXTER STREET CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 611 160 215 |
Fifth Plaintiff: | ANTHONY NORMAN CONNELLY AND MARK ALFRED HOLLAND IN THEIR CAPACITY AS SPECIAL PURPOSE LIQUIDATORS OF 80 SETTLEMENT ROAD CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 611 447 100 |
Defendants | |
Fourth Defendant: | 28 BAXTER STREET CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 611 160 215 |
Fifth Defendant: | 80 SETTLEMENT ROAD CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 611 447 100 |