IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAG 149 of 1995

BETWEEN:

AQUASHELF SALES AND RENTALS PTY LTD

(ACN 009 077 267)

First Applicant

ceil comfort home insulation pty ltd

(ACN 003 239 763)

Second Applicant

Coc pty ltd

(acn 058 817 771)

Third Applicant

morcanna holdings pty ltd

(acn 009 450 597)

Fourth Applicant

natural fibre pty ltd

(acn 0055 452 910)

Fifth Applicant

AND:

csr ltd

(acn 000 001 276)

First Respondent

FIBREGLASS AnD ROCKWOOL INSULATION MANUFACTURERS' ASSOCIATION OF AUSTRALIA INCORPORATED

Second Respondent

CARTER HOLT HARVEY INSULATION AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

(formerly insulco pty ltd)

(ACN 001 175 355)

Third Respondent

kevin herbert

Fourth Respondent

insulation information australia pty ltd

(acn 055 295 899)

Fifth Respondent

dafan holdings pty ltd

(acn 002 659 010)

Sixth Respondent

gemhost pty ltd

(acn 003 691 432)

Seventh Respondent

                                                                                                WAG 117 of 1997

BETWEEN

COC PTY LTD

(acn 058 817 771)

First applicant

Morcanna holdings pty ltd

(acn 009 450 597)

Second applicant

CEIL COMFORT HOME INSULATION PTY LTD

(acn 003 239 763)

THIRD APPLICANT

THERMO-SEAL INSULATION PTY LTD

(acn 000 864 068)

FOURTH APPLICANT

NATURAL FIBRE PTY LTD

(acn 055 452 910)

AND:

csr ltd

(acn 000 001 276)

FIRST RESPONDENT

FIBREGLASS AND ROCKWOOL INSULATION MANUFACTURERS’ ASSOCIATION OF AUSTRALIA INCORPORATED

SECOND RESPONDENT

CARTER HOLT HARVEY INSULATION PTY LTD

THIRD RESPONDENT

ACI AUSTRALIA LIMITED

(acn 004 093 092)

FOURTH RESPONDENT

GERADO HOLDINGS PTY LTD

(acn 009 089 472)

FIFTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

TAMBERLIN J

DATE:

22 DECEMBER 1998

PLACE:

hEARD IN pERTH

dELIVERED IN sYDNEY